Pantheism is the most unique faith which demonstrates atheism

Voting religion pantheism materialism

The participant with the most points wins.

Voting stays open until 3 more votes are cast.

Like this debate? Score 0
···
X Facebook
Pro Instigator Opens first
Instigator Avatar
0
Rating
1483
Debates
7
Win rate
50.00%

Match format

Type
Unrated · 2 rounds
Time
Three days
Limit
10,000
Vote
One week · 3 votes to close
Con Contender
Contender Avatar
0
Rating
1502
Debates
27
Win rate
51.85%


Round 1

1 of 2
avatar Pro #1

hello I'm rushing so I'm sorry if the argument is bad, thank you for accepting the debate and in the next round I will explain myself better I promise.

Briefly, the Christian's assumption of the incarnation of God in a human being, logically means that exists only one real Christian, the so called "child of God"- Jesus.

This can be logically proven that it actually only involves the one, if it isn't happened subsequently to other people.

With this assumption we can trace it until the Pantheist assumption: Deus Sive Natura (God is nature).

This assumption even though it is reasoned and also it has a large impact on the science progress and also for materialism, it is an empirical assumption, we can't logically prove it.

Obviously there are the proof in nature of this godly perfection, the silver ratio, the golden ratio, evolution and also the primal morality of human beings, we have the primal instinct to understand that killing the other is evil, is bad, or better, is anti-moral.

Although these manifestations of nature perfection, the simply assumption that God coexist in nature not as trascendent but as something that exists, is real, is purely empirical, unproven, therefore, from the ration vision, we either don't need God to morality, but also, we don't even need God anymore, we should just accept that nature during time evolved and perfectioned itself through various factors.


Hope this shor argument is enough for the moment. Let me know!

Pantheism cannot explain the problem of evil as good of theism. Pantheism leads to moral ambiguity. Pantheism is circular reasoning. There is no proof the universe is eternal. There is no proof the universe must exist. What does universe even mean?

Round 2

2 of 2

Pro forfeits the round. Pro was busy doing something else. A new debate has been started instead.

New comment

avatar
Leaning Global Moderator
•••
#7
--> @pierree

Briefly, the Christian's assumption of the incarnation of God in a human being, logically means that exists only one real Christian, the so called "child of God"- Jesus.


Christians are followers 'of Christ.
Same way for Zenoists following Zeno, or Confusanists following Confucius.

Though I suppose in a sense, all these people might be the most (Themself)ists, in a sense.
. . .

Defining God is often difficult in debate,
I'm not sure something needs to be transcendent to be considered God,
Nor that some things we partially experience, to not be considered God.
Lot of definitions and views on God.

Pantheism is the most unique faith which demonstrates atheism

Might have been better as,
Pantheism demonstrates atheism.

But maybe you also should have defined Pantheism, God, Atheism in the description.

Maybe also title would have been better if title was,
Pantheism (If true) demonstrates atheism.

avatar
•••
#6

my bad I was making the argument, couldn't make it in time I was rushing, is it okay to write it down here?

avatar
•••
#5

why this could be useful for us in your opinion? I'm just asking 'cause I'm just very confused...

avatar
•••
#4

By must, I mean required to exist. Like there couldn’t be a reality or timeline in which it didn’t exist. And atheists accuse us of being idiots

avatar
•••
#3

it must exists because it does lol, what's even the purpose of the question

avatar
•••
#2
--> @pierree

I mean how you know the universe is the thing that must exist. I believe God to be the one thing that must exist.

avatar
•••
#1
--> @SomeDebatePerson

there is no such thing as thinking "why the universes must exist?", it exists. stop it. why ask us these questions which themselves don't make sense at all? it is metaphysics shit, it's useless to even ask. Universe exists, that's all we know and what we NEED to know.