Can you sin and go on sinning in Christ being born of God ?

Voting #religion #jesuschrist #bible #2026 #faith #truth

The participant with the most points wins.

Voting stays open until 3 more votes are cast.

Like this debate? Score 0
···
X Facebook
Con Instigator Opens first
Instigator Avatar
0
Mal
Rating
1390
Debates
469
Win rate
45.52%

Match format

Type
Unrated · 5 rounds
Time
One week
Limit
10,000
Vote
Six months · 3 votes to close
Pro Contender
Contender Avatar
0
Rating
1504
Debates
2
Win rate
75.00%

Please quote exactly. Do not rephrase or reinterpret. Answer all questions directly. Failure to comply with all this is an automatic forfeit.


Disclaimer : Regardless of the setup for voting win or lose, The aim of this interaction, Is for those that view it, Learn and or take away anything that will amount to any constructive value ultimately. So that counts as anything that'll cause one to reconsider an idea, Understand a subject better, Help build a greater wealth of knowledge getting closer to truth. When either of us has accomplished that with any individual here, That's who the victor of the debate becomes.

Send a message for questions on the topic.


Round 1

1 of 5
avatar
Mal
Con #1

Greetings, just so we have a substance filled discussion.


This is a scriptural topic . Everything will strictly rely on written biblical scripture to validate a point.


Keyword "written" . Strictly important to note.


The topic is regarding those born of God, born of the spirit, having received the spirit, the eternal life.


So we're clear, I have said it.


Do you believe or was taught that saved people of God in Christ can and will continue to wage war to sin falling in sin?



avatar Pro #2

Despite still being a Calvinist, I gave up sola scriptura years ago. It contradicts itself and no one actually follows it.


The original church fell into apostasy (I think we both agree on this point). I'll even admit I have problems with the Trinity myself. The rule to use the scriptures alone has been nullified since the church rejected it. If the church won't listen to the bible, no one will. The bible didn't work and we need a new option. This is why we have pentecostalism to reboot private revelation and signs of faith.


No one is perfect, we all sin, brother in Christ. The bible says calling yourself sinless makes God a liar. The bible has been nullified because God is now a liar. God chose to nullify his word. Look for him somewhere in this world and he will reveal hidden knowledge.


Johnny was just joking when he said those born of God are unable to sin. Call it hyperbole, exaggeration, poetic, anything to keep the bible infallible.


John fell into sin and worshipped an angel even tho he was supposedly born of God. Simon Magus was baptized, believed but fell into the sin of simony. Judas was chosen by Jesus, yet committed suicide and is likely in hell as we speak. Adam and Eve were in perfect paradise and still sinned against God.


How many times have you sinned this week, mal? Liar brother whatever you answer

Round 2

2 of 5
avatar
Mal
Con #3

This is a strictly scriptural topic. Now if you were just looking for a casual discussion, we can have it. But you do forfeit the topic ok.


We can even have a live discussion on YouTube stream yard .


A serious discussion. Not idle or trivial. Not the latter . I'm not the one for that.


Let me know.

avatar Pro #4

My brother in Christ, sola scriptura was indeed something God gave his people for a certain amount of time (such as in Deuteronomy, in some of Paul's letters, in Revelation) but it was in no way meant to last forever. Why force this debate into a "strictly scriptura" debate when there are very few passages of scripture that once commanded sola scriptura in the first place? It's no longer binding either. God commanded it for practical reasons, not doctrinal ones.


The Bible has tons of examples of people who were supposedly born of God yet fell into sins, including major ones, not simply minor sins.


The Bible assumes its readers will continue to sin, which is why it commands them to forgive and ask forgiveness. Paul says he does what he hates. Peter denied Christ. John committed idolatry. The list goes on and on, like how God goes on forever. The infinite power of God.

Round 3

3 of 5
avatar
Mal
Con #5

I'm going to give you three witnesses from scripture since you say "The Bible assumes".


The bible says out of the mouth of three witnesses let every word be established.


First Peter 1

"14 As obedient children, do not conform to the evil desires you had when you lived in ignorance"


First Peter 4


"4 Therefore, since Christ suffered in his body, arm yourselves also with the same attitude, because whoever suffers in the body is done with sin. 2 As a result, they do not live the rest of their earthly lives for evil human desires, but rather for the will of God"


And this one , Romans 6, this seals the deal.


" What shall we say then? Shall we continue in sin, that grace may abound?


2 God forbid. How shall we, that are dead to sin, live any longer therein?"


I went into a whole discussion on this in a video posted on the YouTube channel J. Talks to the people. For more information in watching, let me know.


Scripture say God forbid and God who is Christ Holy thing Holy God wants his people to be holy as he is and arm themselves the same so that they're done with sin that they continue no longer there in.


Do you believe that?

avatar Pro #6

The first example you gave only showed what the ideal standard is. It never said we will never sin. It only sets the bar too high for us to achieve, meaning only faith alone can save us and nothing else.


There's also a difference between living in sin and sinning. Living in sin is an entire lifestyle of sin. Everyone sins every once in a while, but the special chosen by God will not die to their sins.


God gives free will, I think.


I know what the bar is, being Santa. No one on the nice list ever is perfect, my friend.


The bible says clearly that if we say we are without sin, we make God a liar. The bible is no longer relevant. God lied. The bible is not infallible, which is why John was joking when he said we would not sin.

Round 4

4 of 5
avatar
Mal
Con #7

Let us remind ourselves what the topic is.


So we don't get lost and off track.


"Can you sin and go on sinning in Christ being born of God ?"


First Peter 4 , says at


"2 As a result, they do not live the rest of their earthly lives for evil human desires, but rather for the will of God"


What is the WILL OF GOD?


Let's get Romans 6. , first two verses


" What shall we say then? Shall we continue in sin, that grace may abound?




2 God forbid. How shall we, that are dead to sin, live any longer therein?"


It says GOD FORBID.


Simple plain straightforward question is, do you believe this or not ?


Remember the topic stipulation here : Answer all questions directly. Failure to comply with all this is an automatic forfeit.

avatar Pro #8

"God forbid" isn't the actual meaning of it. The actual text is just saying "May it never be!" It was added by those stupid King James translators who didn't know what they were doing. They saw God where he wasn't.


Also, when Peter said they live the will of God, he didn't mean they will never sin. He meant they will generally obey God but not completely. Only God is perfect. Stop trying to be God.

Round 5

5 of 5
avatar
Mal
Con #9

Case closed.


The opposing side did not confess that the opposing side believes what the scripture said as written.


In order to believe it you have to concede.


Least be honest and say "I won't say yes to the question."


By not saying "yes" or "no" to a "yes" or "no" question, that is a forfeit. Unless there is a justified explanation starting with saying "I can't or will not be able to answer". You have to be transparent enough to where you are demonstrating that you are not trying to evade questions versus be unable to which I don't know which .


That's because of the lack of transparency.


So the opposing side has one more chance for self sake . We're out of rounds to continue.


But in a SCRIPTURAL based debate, it has been shown according to as it written in the scriptures proves "no" to the topic question.


Case closed.

New comment

avatar
SkepticalOne Global Moderator
•••
#3
--> @Mal, @Santa_Claus, @ShtLp

>Reported Vote: ShtLp // Mod action: Removed
>Voting Policy: https://www.debatecraft.com/debates/vote-rubric
>Voted for: pro
>Reason for Decision: fails-to-analyze
>Reason for Mod Action:
ShtLp

avatar
SkepticalOne Global Moderator
•••
#2

---ShtLp's former vote---
Voted for: pro
Con never provided any scripture that defends their claim. At best from their references you can say that god does not want us to sin, but not that we never will. There's even a verse that says anyone who says that they have no sin is a liar and the truth is not in him.

avatar
SkepticalOne Global Moderator
•••
#1
--> @ShtLp

The vote lacks an analysis of the arguments from both debaters and will be removed. Please update it to show a broader consideration of the merits of both sides. Thank you.