Taxation is theft or like theft.

Voting

The participant with the most points wins.

Voting ends in:

1 : 6 : 40 : 17
DD    HH    MM    SS
Like this debate? Score 0
···
X Facebook
Pro Contender Opens first
Contender Avatar
0
Rating
1502
Debates
27
Win rate
51.85%

Match format

Type
Unrated · 5 rounds
Time
Three days
Limit
10,000
Vote
One month · No minimum
Opening turn
Contender opens as Pro
Con Instigator
Instigator Avatar
0
Mal
Rating
1390
Debates
469
Win rate
45.52%

Please quote exactly. Do not rephrase or reinterpret. Answer all questions directly. Failure to comply with all this is an automatic forfeit.


Disclaimer : Regardless of the setup for voting win or lose, The aim of this interaction, Is for those that view it, Learn and or take away anything that will amount to any constructive value ultimately. So that counts as anything that'll cause one to reconsider an idea, Understand a subject better, Help build a greater wealth of knowledge getting closer to truth. When either of us has accomplished that with any individual here, That's who the victor of the debate becomes.


Round 1

1 of 5
avatar
Mal
Con #2

I rest my case.

Round 2

2 of 5

Sorry, I didn’t realize it was my turn.


Anyway, taxation is indeed like theft. It’s not exactly like theft, but it does have some similarities, which should be enough. They both involve taking something, and taxation is often against one’s will. Taxation without representation was deemed to be essentially theft by the Colonies.


Here is are my arguments:


  1. Taxation has some similarities with theft.


  1. Certain forms of taxation are more like theft.


  1. Extreme forms of taxation can be the same as theft
avatar
Mal
Con #4

You can expand more on your points and the things that are similar between theft and taxes if you have time.


"They both involve taking something, and taxation is often against one’s will."


Do you really want to stand by the point that if something is taken against a person's will, that would be theft?



I'll leave you with this one question being that you are busy .


Round 3

3 of 5

I never said that would make it theft, but it certainly makes it like theft.

avatar
Mal
Con #6

Well please explain how it's like theft and demonstrate it because the question still remains of you standing by that due to it being against your will it makes it "like" theft.

Round 4

4 of 5

Taxation and theft both involve taking something. That's clearly a similarity.

avatar
Mal
Con #8

Taking something doesn't necessarily mean anything to do with like, the same , etc. to theft nor if it's against somebody's will does it automatically constitutes the same.


This remains unsubstantiated claims but thanks for giving some attempt.


Maybe just stick to subjects you're invested in like religion.


Case closed.

Round 5

5 of 5

Taking is something they have in common. What makes them different is whether there is consent. They have things in common and things not in common.

avatar
Mal
Con #10

Stay off this subject.

New comment