Hot take: The BS Asymmetry Principle is False

Started by Savant

Replies
5
Posts
6
Page
1 / 1

Conversation

#1 •••

Many times, when Side A wins a debate on formal debating standards, or the Side B fails to address most of their points, it will be said that Side A simply won because nonsense takes longer to refute than good arguments. The BS asymmetry principle, in fact, seems extremely widely accepted almost on faith, despite people rarely trying to prove that it is true.


However, I would argue that it is false, and we have good reasons to believe that it is false. An extreme example would be if I just said "xtgjkhwnjrgkiodmv" instead of making an affirmative case. Despite being nonsense, it's not like it would be super hard to make a better argument than a bunch of random letters. Additionally, the implication seems to be that if I say a bunch of made-up facts, those facts are now harder to refute than if everything I said was true. But false statements can be self-contradictory and don't have as much evidence to support them, so that seems flatly false.


Additionally, if some amount of false information sounds more convincing than an equal amount of true information, then we should just be unable to learn anything we don't directly observe, right? As soon as we observe something and discuss it, we would just get dumber and dumber as we keep moving toward false conclusions.


There's another version of this called the "gish gallop" that basically says that the wrong side could make a bunch of short arguments and the other side won't be able to respond to all of them. This seems slightly more compelling, but then in a worst-case scenario, the other side can just gish gallop too, right? And they have the advantage of true arguments not contradicting each other. Additionally, making a lot of short arguments is not a great strategy as similar arguments can be grouped together, and then the opponent has more space to respond than you had to make the short argument each time. The side making more fleshed-out arguments can also offer a framework and say "these are the factors that matter," after which they can either group your arguments if they all relate to that framework, or they can dismiss many of them as irrelevant. The gish galloper can't advocate a bunch of frameworks without contradicting themselves.


Basically the pattern this leads to is the gish galloper can make three arguments, and then in the same space the responder can make one argument and also have time to argue that it's the only one that matters or is the most important argument. Some arguments are better than others, so the gish galloper will hit diminishing returns.


However, I'm willing to test this by doing a debate where someone else has to make a lot of one sentence arguments and then I have to respond to their case. With a high enough character limit, like 10k, I think it would be pretty easy to defeat a gish gallop with grouping. If I win decisively, you can admit that maybe accusing the other side of gish galloping isn't an excuse for losing or ignoring most of their points. If you win decisively, I'll admit that maybe I'm wrong about the BS asymmetry principle.


I think my main point is that we should generally agree debate is a good means of reaching the truth, so that one side can't come up with endless excuses for not being able to defend their points or say that impartial means of debate judging are unfair. I mean, we can't constantly be arguing as if that's going to help us reach the truth, and then say actually making a convincing argument is meaningless because the BS asymmetry principle.

Edit comment

#2 •••
@Savant

Most people apply bullshit asymmetry principle incorrectly, so they are getting diminishing results.


Let me demonstrate the correct application of bullshit asymmetry:


Circumcision is confirmed to cause brain damage, trauma, horrible pain, cases gone wrong, penis damage, altering sexual function, non-existent health benefit, permanent loss of penis, countries which do it have lower life expectancy on average, is a form of torture, infants cant consent.


Good luck responding to all this with less than 44 words.


The trick with bullshit asymmetry principle is that you speak believable bullshit, not "adsfasfsaffa" bullshit. Trump won elections twice making use of BAP so its pretty efficient.

Edit post

#3 •••

Tho gish gallop of bullshit is not my favorite rhetorical tactic. Its just the most efficient one against ordinary people, and its principle is true theoretically, you are supposed to maximise character space, and making arguments shorter by throwing unnecessary words achieves that.


My favourite rhetoric tactic remains repetition plus denial. Its a much more simple one and doesnt require me to do huge thinking to form gish gallop listing.

Edit post

#4 •••
@Savant
where someone else has to make a lot of one sentence arguments


This is inferior gish gallop.


True perfected gish gallop is all arguments in one sentence.

Edit post

#5 •••
@DoctorLied
Circumcision is confirmed to cause brain damage, trauma, horrible pain, cases gone wrong, penis damage, altering sexual function, non-existent health benefit, permanent loss of penis, countries which do it have lower life expectancy on average, is a form of torture, infants cant consent.

Most of those risks are rare, and adults need to make many health decisions on behalf of babies, like vaccines for Hepatitis B. The number one authority on circumcision in the US is the AAP, which states that the health benefits outweigh the risks.


Pretty easy to group and then point to a single argument as more important.

Edit post

#6 •••
@DoctorLied
its principle is true theoretically, you are supposed to maximise character space

Yeah, that's not a fallacy. It's the fault of the responder for being inefficient.

Edit post