American Jews will simultaneously claim:
- They put America above Israel.
- We can't annex Canada because it makes it tougher to defend Israel (America has 2 million more Jews than Muslims; Canada has 1.8 million more Muslims than Jews and all those Muslims would vote to end US funding to Israel).
The American Jews want the US to fund Israel for reasons that objectively make sense; Hamas kills Jews; Jews don't want to die, they will use a small amount of money to be alive. In reality, we can annex Canada, and America can even be more Muslim than Jewish while Israel still gets funding.
It's not like American Jews are known to be broke; they have lots of money. American Jews make up 2% of the US population and 6% of the net worth ($7 Trillion total). Every American Jew can annually just donate .05% of their net worth to Israel annually so Israel gets the same amount of funding that they get right now (and this is election proof; a Mamdani like person can literally be president and Israel is still safe).
$1.7 million raised in scheme for Hamas, including from U.S. donors, prosecutors say, announcing charges - CBS News says that Gaza only gets $600k in donations a year. Think about that.
Gaza gets less donations annually than the combined salary of Trump and Vance; people don't donate to Gaza (and why would they? Prety much the only people that would donate to Gaza are not even Muslims, but actual Gazans).
If every Jewish person with a net worth of $1 million donated $500/year to Israel (and the same proportion for jews with more/less money), than Israel gets funding in a safer way; and THEN American Jews can consistently claim that their loyalities are to America first; Israel 2nd.