Their counterargument is, "The 1st amendment merely states the government can't restrict your free speech. It says nothing of private individuals."
Alright; so then the left wants their government to be pro free speech, but the left personally isn't (with few exceptions).
They are allowed to hate free speech on the personal level and disassociate with people that are like 50% right wing and they can call this free association, but freedom of association has consequences. They piss off more and more normies, and the republicans win so intensely that the democrats will have to do what the whigs did in the 1800s; cease to exist as a major party.
But with Kirk, dead, tbh, there is nothing I believe the left can do to stop any right wing victories in VA, NJ, and maybe NYC. Here's why:
2020: NY State is D+20 in POTUS elections.
2022: Lee Zeldin gets shot at and lives. He turns NYC D+10 by virtue of him getting shot at.
2020: VA is D+10; NJ is D+15.
2024: VA is D+5; NJ is D+5.
2025: Charlie Kirk gets shot at and dies.
Here is the massive scale that Kirk vs Zeldin had with their assassination attempts:


10 day pre assassination attempt average for:
- Zeldin: 1.7% of max
- Kirk: <1% of max
10 day post assassination attempt average for:
- Zeldin: 9% of max
- Kirk: 16.4% of max
Zeldin had a 10 day retention multiplier of about 5.5 (9%/1.7%) and he benefitted in NY State by 10 pts politically. People say it was because of cashless bail; but nobody cares that much about cashless bail because it only applies to non-violent offenders. Kirk's multiplier (16.4%/lets say .1%) is 164.
This should be a red psynami that makes 2024 look like blood work (not calling for murder, but blood is red just like republicans).