Alien Mafia DP3

Dude I’m saying Lynch the og scum because I think you are scum lol. As scum you have to be the target tomorrow

as town you would not give a fuck who is lynched. You lunch one and then we kill yoi and you shoot the other.

nothing about you being town makes sense because based on how you said is scum, it would not mean a fuck to you

I’ve answered this multiple times. It’s very plausible he’s og

That’s not what I asked you. In what scenario is WF NOT the OG scum? Theres a plausible scenario for me. What plausible, documented scenario is there for WF?

I absolutely think pie can be og. He’s literally named in Casey’s pm. Just because he claimed a passive role does not remove the option that he started as scum.

I absolutely think pie can be og. He’s literally named in Casey’s pm. Just because he claimed a passive role does not remove the option that he started as scum.

The fact he's named is why I think he is not the og.

that he is a balance to a shitty doctor. That he claimed what he did at the start of the dp before Castin said who she tracked and could have got called out. Has said this in both dps with the risk of being cced. It’s safe claims sure but if Castin picked him on either night he could have got caught out

I on god to really care about why would you not be og or why he would not be og

I care about plausibility and behavior.

the only thing all game to me that I’ve been dead set on is David is the only one that made sense as a recruit and David has said he scum reads you and wf.

david is not willing to kill you when by his own reads it would not matter who he picked. It’s inconsistent as shit.

david is not willing to kill you when by his own reads it would not matter who he picked. It’s inconsistent as shit.

It's not inconsistent. If push comes to shove I'd vote pie, but we are trying to lynch the og scum which I believe is wf

that’s no sensical. I’ve explained this.

a yazkua is broke. The fact he is mentioned in the pm could be a balance to the recruit being busted. Yakuzas are strong in late game. So what if pie got killed and then Casey shot and flipped a town to on dp3. Entire game is reset and the fact pies character there means nothing. I just think pies is ballsy enough to claim it and deflect.

you are the main reason I’m not voting wf. Im Not sure if it’s Pie or wf. I am pretty sure it’s you. So if you can tell me why a town you

who has actively said pie and wf are scum refuses to pick pie first. Then I’ll back off but what you have typed does not make sense.

town you goes

sure idc who we lynch

kill one and then kill me and ill shoot the other. Game solved. Going off your own reads it would

Bruh we are trying to go og because I think you are scum. If you are town. Oh scum doesn’t matter cus the game is solved.

Bruh we are trying to go og because I think you are scum. If you are town. Oh scum doesn’t matter cus the game is solved.

I admit I am tunneling wf due to POE. The only scum recruit (from my POV) is pie. The game is easy as pie. You 1000% lynch me tomorrow

Kohai is a nonstarter this DP.

Correct because he cannot be OG scum

1) No reason to CC Thoth

2) No reason to full claim that early

3) You tracked him and he didn’t visit anyone (and that’s telling cause OG scum likely has an active action)

You’re also a non-starter because you can’t be the OG scum and you’re basically confirmed town.

1) Tracker fits in the game so at worst you’re converted

2) You’re role confirmed via Mikal because if you and Mikal were the team, then WF would be lynched by now

3) Everyone here thinks you’re town

Mikal says he visited me and my tracking corroborates it. No, that's not bulletproof, but it's more than I have to go on for whiteflame and Pie. If he was scum, his visiting me means (correct me if I'm wrong plz) he has to be the recruit anyway, and I'm after the OG.

That is correct. Mikal can still be the converted scum and probably only the converted scum.

So, again, whiteflame and Pie.

Despite all of the back-and-forths I see here, nothing has tipped me for Pie or whiteflame. They were on both mislynches. Both their role justifications make sense. Neither whiteflame or Pie has done anything especially scummy to me. If whiteflame was scum he would've had to relay Vader's informant message anyway, so that does nothing. I'll need to think on this more after I'm done for the day.

Here’s a couple of thing:

This is what I said in DP1 to soft claim Martyr:

”Anyone on that wagon probably isnt going to die, especially me, so I suggest to any protective roles to not target me.”

Can you conceivably read this as soft claiming Martyr and trying to bait the NK? The answer should be yes, and that alone puts me at a leg up over WF because it means that I would have been the converted scum.

Ive asked Mikal this a million times, what conceivable evidence do you have that WF is NOT the OG scum? If he’s fake claiming David 8, then Supa’s information doesn’t matter cause he could’ve just changed it. He’s missed twice on the apportion. He has nothing going for him that could prove he’s not the OG scum.

okay let me walk you through the issue with this. You are tunneling wf when you are the one to most likely be recruited.

you have said. Pie and wf are scum. 100 percent and you are okay with dieing tomorrow

scum you and scum pie - want this because the game is over

scum you and scum wf - would not do this. You would see me pushing pie and just end the game

so you are either scum with pie or you are town and you are right. Scum is wf and pie

issue is town you would not give a fuck who we kill and shoot the other one tomorrow but all you’ve did is tunnel wf.

so yeah I think it has to be you and pie.

so yeah I think it has to be you and pie.

I understand your paranoia. I’m ok with lynching pie today and me killing wf tomorrow.

My only point is town you sees this path.

because you as town based on your own read do not care who dies. So yeah you flipped me off wf because of resistant to pie you are.

my solve is

vote pie

lynch you and have you shoot wf if you are town

if you are scum it’s over and doesn’t matter

If I’m wrong about Castin I’ll eat it. But I don’t see her as scum.

I understand your paranoia. I’m ok with lynching pie today and me killing wf tomorrow. 

Why can it not be Mikal/WF with WF as OG scum? There’s a 100% chance via POE that WF is scum. There’s more of a 50/50 for me vs Mikal. That should be an objective fact for you.

Mikal is explicitly pushing for a Pie/Kohai team. You know you’re not scum. So why is he trying so hard to lynch me?

Why can it not be Mikal/WF with WF as OG scum? There’s a 100% chance via POE that WF is scum. There’s more of a 50/50 for me vs Mikal. That should be an objective fact for you.

Mikal / Wf doesn’t make any sense due to castin’s results.

I have very strong reasons to believe Castin and Mikal are town. If I’m wrong I’ll eat it. From my POV that means Pie and Wf

If it was wf and I. I’d have bussed him already and have you shoot pie tomorrow.

its why I know it’s pie

If it was wf and I. I’d have bussed him already and have you shoot pie tomorrow. 

its why I know it’s pie 

I understand your paranoia. If you want to kill pie today I am down for it. Here’s where I am at

1. Mikal / Castin or Wf / Pie is the only possible team for reasons I’ve already explained.
2. Castin being the tracker and not being NK’d only makes sense if wf is scum and wanted to gain town cred for protecting them
3. Pie is not the og scum due to flavor reasons. This leaves wf as the only option for Og scum.

Also wf’s power role makes absolutely zero sense. How would he know what the power role even is before it flips?

What picking a role from a graveyard. Confused about this. But don’t care.

we have a way to solve so as long as we go pie first since I think you are scum. I’m down.

What picking a role from a graveyard. Confused about this. But don’t care. 

we have a way to solve so as long as we go pie first since I think you are scum. I’m down

1. how does wf get to pick a role from the graveyard if the role hasn’t been revealed?

2. I can yield to a pie lynch.

Why do you think Pie is more likely scum than wf?

Huh

Why do you think it’s me/pie vs me/wf?

I’ve explained this over and over

I think the two possible teams are you and pie or pie and wf

1) you and wf don’t make sense as the game would be over cus id vote pie

2) wf and I make no sense as I’d just bus and have you shoot pie tomorrow since you are locked on him as scum

3) operating under Castin is town

a) you and pie

b) pie and wf

pie is the common denominator

you as town don’t care because you think it’s Castin or I and if we are the game is done already

or it’s Pie and wf. (This is you hardest read)

it placates me because it covers the person who’s in both my reads and it placates you because it’s your only read.(as town)

Here’s a couple of thing:

This is what I said in DP1 to soft claim Martyr:

”Anyone on that wagon probably isnt going to die, especially me, so I suggest to any protective roles to not target me.”

Can you conceivably read this as soft claiming Martyr and trying to bait the NK? The answer should be yes, and that alone puts me at a leg up over WF because it means that I would have been the converted scum.

Ive asked Mikal this a million times, what conceivable evidence do you have that WF is NOT the OG scum? If he’s fake claiming David 8, then Supa’s information doesn’t matter cause he could’ve just changed it. He’s missed twice on the apportion. He has nothing going for him that could prove he’s not the OG scum.

Of course I can see it as you being martyr and baiting. But if you were OG, you knew Casey was going to flip DP2 anyway, and that there might well be a call for mass claims, so you needed to get your story straight early.

And there is no evidence that whiteflame is not OG.

Please read the post above yours

we have each other town locked and it solves.

Also to note. Wf and pie as scum have to bus.

pie and David would push wf to end the game

pie and wf have to tunnel each other to put distance between them

Mikal / Wf doesn’t make any sense due to castin’s results. 

How?