1990s-2000s Nostalgia Mafia (DP2)

Vote Count

Not voting: (6/6): ILikePie, Awesome5000, Airmax1227, Rex, Mikal, Whiteflame 

With 6 players alive it takes 4 to lynch.

Day phase 2 will end on Saturday 9/20/2025 @ 6:00 PM EST unless there is a majority. 

So… OK. I’m trying to piece this together:

Unsaid almost certainly died due to his own role. Likely targeted town, automatically died. Don’t think it was the best choice to use that NP1 where he had the most possible people in POE, but his choice.

As for how Thoth and Luna both died… I can only speculate. Thoth didn’t have a visiting role, so he was probably the NK target. Luna had some sort of forced Commuter role where he could impose it on someone else, so maybe someone triggered his death on visit like a PGO? Anyone want to speak up about having a role like that?

Just realized one of their deaths might be explained by the anti-claim mechanic. We don’t know what scum got access to, even though they didn’t know either Luna or Thoth’s roles.

Also, we’re effectively at MYLO now, since there are likely two scum and six players left. I don’t think we have much choice other than to get more claims. I’m fine with going first.

could be a third faction, but this game is dumb.

I had a way to lock scum and the way david processes results made it impossible. On god im just willing to yolo lynch to get to the next game.

3 deaths in one night, im just lol

Beyond me, man. Still trying to process what the fuck happened.

im like 99 percent sure max is town and they of course kill the 2 town locks.

so im fine with shooting you pie or awesome and just crossing my fingers.

I will give input after people full claim.

we prob need to full claim

max is already claimed

im claimed

awesome is claimed

You and pie softed, so I expect something to come out

and the only person left is skep

I think this is normally dumb but if there is a tp, this game is prob fucked and we may as well poe down.

Like I said, I’m fine claiming first.

go ahead

Might as well.

I’m Dexter’s Laboratory. Justification says there’s almost nothing I can’t create or solve.

I’m the Doc/Cop. I copped Awesome innocent.

interesting, the game is solved

To clarify on the obvious “why Awesome” question, I chose him because I remained unsure of his affiliation despite that claim. That is almost certainly his role, meaning he’s not the GF even if he’s scum. So unless he got Lawyered or I got manipulated some other way, I think it’s accurate.

I’ll be off and on over most of the evening. Looking for claims from Pie and REF at this point.

I have a pertinent peace of information. I am sitting on it until it's necessary. But as dumb as last night is, I think we can solve.

I’ll wait for it.

Might as well.

I’m Dexter’s Laboratory. Justification says there’s almost nothing I can’t create or solve.

I’m the Doc/Cop. I copped Awesome innocent.

To clarify on the obvious “why Awesome” question, I chose him because I remained unsure of his affiliation despite that claim. That is almost certainly his role, meaning he’s not the GF even if he’s scum. So unless he got Lawyered or I got manipulated some other way, I think it’s accurate.

My question isn't 'why awesome' it's 'why cop?' We had two town-confirmed players. Why on earth didn't you protect either of them? The nightkill targets were incredibly obvious.

Also, why the fearless claim? We just had three deaths in one night after being warned about a strong anticlaim mechanic, with much of town claiming DP1 regardless of that. Personally, I'm incredibly leery about further claims. I have no role which could account for the extra deaths. That's the first question that should have been asked. I've tagged Pie as well to ask him that question. If he also answers no, the only explanation for those extra deaths is anticlaim. In that case full claiming this DP could lose us the game.

I think it's possible to solve this game without more full claims on the table. Given the circumstances, I think that full claiming may lose us the game even if we hit scum this DP by doing so if the mechanic is so strong that it can create extra deaths in the NP.

It wont, I can explain why in a second but I am like 99 percent sure we can solve. I am waiting on something

Like protecting either one gave you a 50% chance of stopping a NK. How is that better than copping someone who imo does not seem particularly scummy? Why not cop Pie? He's one of the most polarizing players and a far more difficult to read one.

*how is that NOT better than

Pie also said he was affil confirm.

I will explain this after we hear from everyone. But I think I have both scum

Copping Awesome makes sense if you want to buddy him and Airmax at MYLO. I think it's an absolutely mind-boggling night action from a town perspective.

trust, wait. It's a good thing

not that choice is good, but I have very very likely have the solve

Fine. But I want Whiteflame to defend his night action. It might give us insight. And I want Whiteflame to tell me who he supports lynching today.

you said you were afill lock, I need you to tell me exactly why you are affil lock and like now.

If you don’t think I made the optimal decision, then fine, whatever. Trying to protect Luna or Thoth might have been the better choice, but I had no way of knowing there would be three deaths during the NP and my goal was to focus on trying to bring down POE first and foremost. In retrospect, using the Doc made more sense, but I disagree that would have been the best choice if there had been one NK.

I disagree that Awesome was not scummy or that Pie was the better choice.

As for claiming, frankly, we’re at MYLO. What happens to me during the NP is entirely irrelevant if we don’t lynch correctly this DP, and I know I was on the chopping block if I refused to claim. Again, you might disagree with the choice, but I see it as the only meaningful way forward at this point.

can you explain to me why you know we are at mylo?

math this out?

But I want Whiteflame to defend his night action. It might give us insight. And I want Whiteflame to tell me who he supports lynching today.

I have defended my choices. I can detail all the reasons I was on the fence about Awesome if you’d like, though I discussed several last DP. As for who to lynch, I’m waiting for whatever other information Mikal, you and Pie may provide before I try to sort it out.

can you explain to me why you know we are at mylo?

math this out?

Six players alive, includes two scum. 4-2 is MYLO.