Madoka Magica - Episode 1

Not to get too deep into information, my PM does not discuss anything really that could be anti claim at all.

Not Pie but I think we have similiar thoughts so I’ll share mine. When I played with Casey as scum I remember them taking a bit of a back seat as scum and giving base level analysis. When they are town, it tends to usually be them being one of the leaders for town. Not saying this is vindictive of there affiliation because obviously people have priorities to attend you and we can’t all be active, but it is something to take note of IMO

That being said, I'm not triggering the end of the DP this early. If nothing else, I'm still here to get some behavioral info.

Agreed. But we need to be careful.

There is no need to rush to a VTNL. Even if we decide to do that you are better off taking all the time off the clock than voting to cut the DP early

Long day, checking in. Guess we haven't made much more headway.

For the people who have a sus pile, can you explain why those players are in your sus pile?

For the people who have a sus pile, can you explain why those players are in your sus pile?

I think I covered that in my reads list. I can elaborate where desired.

yall I jus care about this DP anymore

im fine with a no lynch

lowkey wanna yolo Casey

*I just don’t carr

**care

The DP had run long and sparse. Apathy hung thick in the air, a hazy blanket of indecision and ennui. Like sweaty lounging sailors sprawled on a becalmed ship they eyed one another through swollen red lids.

"Ion curr bout this DP no mo," declared Mag1c, snorting hard through his left nostril and then spitting.

I mean I didn't see you sus anyone, or did i miss something? Your reads seemed mostly null/NAI and your Casey VTL seemed like it was just trying to generate activity.

I don't know if I came up with an actual means for us to softclaim in that post, at least not one that I'm comfortable with yet. We might just want to wait until next DP to get any kind of broader idea of what's going on with the setup, if only to give everyone the maximum chance to make best use of their roles. I might come up with something better by next DP, but I figure we either end this DP with a NL straight up or we push a single target and make our decision after they claim. 

It’s honestly probably for the best that we VTNL. If the game is 6-2, which makes sense, then we may have to VTNL anyways down the line. Giving scum zero info is very painful to them. They’re basically shooting blind

Whiteflame, Casey, and Pie are the names under my microscope.

Wryly is null.

k that’s all for now gn

I would be surprised if I wasn’t on your list lol

Why Casey over me or WF?

WF has theme knowledge regardless of if he’s scum or town. But if he’s town, it’s useful to us.

Casey’s behavior is far easier to read than yours. Even when you were scum last time, I couldn’t read that properly. Casey I can read better for sure

yall I jus care about this DP anymore

im fine with a no lynch

lowkey wanna yolo Casey

Nah No Lynch is better. We’ll have results tomorrow I’m sure

I think it's best to no lynch now at this point, but I would rather let the time rundown and then the NP start. I think we also risking going in too blind if we rush vtnl now. I say we wait for some more thoughts and get more reads out there (without giving away too much info), and then proceed to go to the NP

For the people who have a sus pile, can you explain why those players are in your sus pile?

Almost everyone is currently in my null pile expect mharman, who I am viewing is conf town.

Vote Count

Kohai (2/5) | Rex, Casey

Casey (2/5) | Pie, whiteflame

VTNL (1/5) | Kohai

About four hours left.

yall I jus care about this DP anymore

im fine with a no lynch

lowkey wanna yolo Casey

Given how little Casey has posted and the contents of said posts, I get the desire, but it seems a little excessive.

The DP had run long and sparse. Apathy hung thick in the air, a hazy blanket of indecision and ennui. Like sweaty lounging sailors sprawled on a becalmed ship they eyed one another through swollen red lids.

"Ion curr bout this DP no mo," declared Mag1c, snorting hard through his left nostril and then spitting.

You paint quite the picture, love to see it.

I mean I didn't see you sus anyone, or did i miss something? Your reads seemed mostly null/NAI and your Casey VTL seemed like it was just trying to generate activity.

It's based on POE. I don't have any clear scumreads, though if I had to rank ppl based on what I said and how I've seen everyone since, Casey is more of a behavioral outlier. Can't say they're even much of a scumread, but they trend that way.

It’s honestly probably for the best that we VTNL. If the game is 6-2, which makes sense, then we may have to VTNL anyways down the line. Giving scum zero info is very painful to them. They’re basically shooting blind

Yeah, my thoughts exactly. We have a VTNL to use effectively free of charge, best to use it with the greatest number of town night actions in play to reduce interference.

4 hours left. I think VTNL is the best option. Hopefully we will get results

Given that Casey has been MIA for over 48 hours with no explanation, it's frustrating that attention has been focused their way for so much of this DP since it hasn't yielded much beyond thoughts from other players. I was hoping to get something more for behavioral reads, but here we are with a little over 3 hours left in the DP and still no word.

If this ends in an auto-NL, that's fine, just means we're relying a lot on night activity. In case I do perish in the night, I've given a general outline of the set of characters I think are in the game, but I don't want to get too caught up on the "likely" ones this time around, so I'll leave it at that. In terms of theme splits, the obvious one is just antagonists (there are two main ones, one of which I'm sure is here) vs. others. There are two friends that are mainly interesting for the feelings they hide during the plot, though that's a much rougher split beyond their shared interaction with a certain magical girl.

For other splits, keep in mind that some characters in this series can play very different roles depending on where they're at in this season. It's a spoiler, but I'd rather spoil this than leave this to be figured out later because it does get complicated. There is a time loop at play in this series and, at least within certain loops, things go very wrong in very different ways. Some characters are self-destructive, some kill other characters among the leads, some turn into witches (look up "soul gem" and "grief seed" for more information) and wreak havoc. There are strong bonds between certain pairs, and some instances of these crash-outs are shared between a couple. There are two main adults I expect to be here, but I doubt they're a team.

All ideas I plan to revisit once we get a flip/more information.

I agree Casey being MIA is not good.

My biggest scum reads are whiteflame and Casey but I just can’t figure out how to say it

I’m also down to lynching Casey if they don’t show up though I’d prefer NL

yeah I'm willing to vtnl

eh

VTL Casey

YOLO

This game isn't fun, let's do something funny to make it fun

Join me or don't.

idc