Locked

Madoka Magica - Episode 2

Started by Thoth

Replies
419
Posts
420
Page
14 / 14

Conversation

Total: 420
ISO #391 •••
--> @Mag1cman

Also post 272 I stated what I did because I looked at it from a normal perspective from my usual experience with mafia. An ascetic is immune to all night non-lethal actions which I’d assume would mean they’re immune to recruiting. Thoth clarified that recruit would supersede that. It is a weird order of priority


Also does scum me really verify whiteflame’s claim?

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #392 •••
--> @Kohai
Also does scum me really verify whiteflame’s claim? 


You were the first one to verify it but it’s not like Thoth wouldn’t tell us lol

Edit post

ISO #393 •••
--> @ILikePie5

Kohai’s behavior has been all over the place tbh. It’s like he’s in pure defensive mode


Honestly I’d rather be the lynch over no lynching two days in a row. At least town can review who was on my wagon.


I’m not being defensive. I am clarifying things that got MIs interpreted

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #394 •••
--> @ILikePie5

You were the first one to verify it but it’s not like Thoth wouldn’t tell us lol


But I was the one who got Thoth independently confirming wf’s claim

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #395 •••

Honestly this game is just a massive cluster fuck with the million mechanics. It’s impossible to determine motive based on them. So just play it like a regular vanilla game imo. I’d say Kohai is behaviorally the most scummy right now. Going to reread DP1 just to be sure

Edit post

ISO #396 •••

VTL Kohai

Edit post

Kick logic to the curb and do the impossible!

ISO #397 •••

VTL Mikal


I hate how radio silence this slot has been all game.

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #398 •••
--> @Vader

Nice of you to join us

Edit post

ISO #399 •••

It really bothers me that Casey / Mikal have not continued this game.

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #400 •••
--> @ILikePie5

Was going to log off. Is there enough support for this to happen in the next 20 minutes?

Edit post

ISO #401 •••

Vader


Nothing to write home about DP1; I guess #92 of that DP was good. TBH I don’t even have to look at DP1 to know he started as town.


There’s no way scum Vader claims redirector, unless he knows town can have it this game, which he would only know if he started this game as a town redirector. Also makes sense with the setup since the mechanic central to this game is recruitment.


DP2 he’s clueless about the offer he got from Kyubey, even after everyone else. He did this by over analyzing / over thinking the contract. He does a similar thing with his read on Kohai, in his moment of poor reading comprehension. It’s plausible ignorance. He kinda just tunnels on Kohai.


I do like how he waited for Mikal to reveal action plus result before he did.


His night action justification is weird.

  1. Anything that happens to me may lock Mikal scum. Sure.
  2. If Mikal’s an investigative, it’s interference, but he doesn’t seem to pick up on this, thinking Mikal would see something happen to me when that’s not how the role works. He’s basing it off retroactive results, which seems fake.


but wait, there’s more. He doesn’t immediately clarify whether he declined or accepted the contract, until a few posts after his first on me in this DP. You’d think scum would have a decision ready on what they were going to say on this from the start, no? Which tells me he *really* did not understand the nature of the contact (if that wasn’t obvious enough already), which tells me he probably didn’t get recruited. The hesitation to say whether he accepted or not, which likely comes from not knowing just how important it is to say, is the key that his whole misunderstanding of the contact (thinking it’s just a hidden ability thing), is real.


It’s so stupid because some things look fake, but in one area, the *specific* way in which he’s clueless in ridiculously towny, even if he’s on par with Kohai in it.


Love ya Vader, don’t want to disrespect you here, but I kinda feel like I have to.


Slight town, I guess.



Edit post

I still don’t know what to type!

ISO #402 •••
--> @whiteflame

I think there is

Edit post

ISO #403 •••
--> @ILikePie5

I think the case is good enough against him. He's either the lynch today or he's going to be a major focus of the next DP, and we can always use the VTNL later. I'll stay on long enough to be the hammer if enough people are willing to do it.

Edit post

ISO #404 •••

Ugh. Maybe Kohai can really be that clueless and town then. Thing is, I don’t see a way around him getting a reveal on his hidden ability for something that isn’t a recruitment bonus. And the antics must seems way too specific, and I still don’t like how he jumps on people over small things.

Edit post

I still don’t know what to type!

ISO #405 •••

I worded for 404 like an idiot. I just don’t see how Kohai gets a reveal on his hidden ability in a way that is towny, I don’t see how he has an argument around that.

Edit post

I still don’t know what to type!

ISO #406 •••
--> @Mag1cman
Ugh. Maybe Kohai can really be that clueless and town then. Thing is, I don’t see a way around him getting a reveal on his hidden ability for something that isn’t a recruitment bonus


Honestly this is the most frustrating aspect of my role

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #407 •••
--> @Mag1cman
I worded for 404 like an idiot. I just don’t see how Kohai gets a reveal on his hidden ability in a way that is towny, I don’t see how he has an argument around that


Do you really think scum me would admit that my hidden ability was revealing characters?

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #408 •••

Vote Count

Kohai (2/5) | RexFavilla, Vader

VTNL (1/5) | ILikePie5

Mikal (1/5) | Kohai


Not voting: whiteflame, Mag1cman, Wryly, Mikal

Edit post

Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.

ISO #409 •••

14 minutes left to make a decision

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #410 •••

Cutting any decision close. If we end in a NL, I guess we can pick this back up next DP.

Edit post

ISO #411 •••
--> @whiteflame

So glad we went back to 72 hr days

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #412 •••
--> @Kohai

When we're still cutting it down to the last few minutes in the DP... yeah, kinda defeats the purpose.

Edit post

ISO #413 •••

Pie


Ok so #46 of DP1. Don’t agree about the first paragraph, Pie complaining about the hidden roles is interesting to me. Like it get his complaint but I know Pie well enough to say he doesn’t really complain unless it negatively impacted him. I can see him being frustrated with me being townlocked in DP1 because of hidden ability that a different townie had.


His vote on Casey isn’t too special but I does kickstart the trend of just voting with the crowd.


The VTNL was bad strategy looking back, but I made the mistake too and it made sense at the time. So eh. Can’t say that’s scummy.


DP2:


Started townreading Kohai, then turned against him while everyone else did, although he does say he was convinced. Maybe, but it continues the trend of just voting along with everyone else.


I can buy that if he was offered the contract, he would reject because playing scum is not his favorite. Although it’s no guarantee cause the position could be perceived as advantageous for scum at the time. I think Pie loves winning more than he hates being scum.


anyway that assumes he started as town.


his idea to find the original scum is good, although fakeable as town. His logic is sensible.


He asked Mikal for results, which stands out to me as he could’ve been teeing Mikal up.


and Pie’s defenses do make sense but he’s just so off.


Skight scum.

Edit post

I still don’t know what to type!

ISO #414 •••

Mikal


The way in which he revealed his role is dubious to me. Like he was gonna say he confirmed Pie but changed his mind, almost as if he’s considering whether he wants to tie himself to Pie or not.


Slight scum.

Edit post

I still don’t know what to type!

ISO #415 •••

Well, with one minute left, this DP is over. Guess we're tackling all this next DP. Use night actions wisely, people.

Edit post

ISO #416 •••

Well here we are. Good night happy thanksgiving

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #417 •••

Rex slight scum, Whiteflame slight town.


dont have time to elaborate.


yes ik i have to be wrong on two people bc i have too many listed as slight scum.

Edit post

I still don’t know what to type!

ISO #418 •••

Yep, happy thanksgiving everyone.

Edit post

ISO #419 •••

Final Vote Count

Kohai (2/5) | RexFavilla, Vader

VTNL (1/5) | ILikePie5

Mikal (1/5) | Kohai


Not voting: whiteflame, Mag1cman, Wryly, Mikal


The day ended without anyone succumbing to despair.


Day 3 starts once night actions are in or 24 hours have passed, whichever takes longer. Please try to get night actions in as soon as possible.

Edit post

Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.

ISO #420 •••

Edit post

Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.