Locked

Barry Mafia - DP1

Started by whiteflame

Replies
231
Posts
232
Page
3 / 8

Conversation

Total: 232
ISO #61 •••
--> @Kohai
If you think MU is bad try MS. They’ll ban you if you even dare say lynch. At least MU is a tiny bit more lenient.


I prefer free speech. Anyways back to the game. Why are town reading Ceru

Edit post

ISO #62 •••
--> @Lunatic

What would you expect some common theme splits are

Edit post

ISO #63 •••
--> @ILikePie5
I prefer free speech. Anyways back to the game. Why are town reading Ceru


1. +1

2. I am town reading them for SOP claiming a negative utility role which is exactly what I would expect from a townie and not a mafia person

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #64 •••
--> @Kohai
I am town reading them for SOP claiming a negative utility role which is exactly what I would expect from a townie and not a mafia person

The reason this is usually read as town is because scum who do it risk a counterclaim, so while it has rewards for them it also has risks. The incredibly vague way that Ceru claimed eliminates that risk of a counterclaim, so I don't see how it warrants a town read.

Edit post

ISO #65 •••
--> @Kohai
2. I am town reading them for SOP claiming a negative utility role which is exactly what I would expect from a townie and not a mafia person


You realize scum could ask if roles exist right

Edit post

ISO #66 •••
--> @ILikePie5
I prefer free speech.

Eh. You have to look at free speech on a spectrum. I don't think it would fly on here if someone were wildly slinging slurs, especially not the N word and the bundle-of-sticks slur. That's what this site looks like to them.

Edit post

Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.

ISO #67 •••
--> @RexFavilla
The reason this is usually read as town is because scum who do it risk a counterclaim, so while it has rewards for them it also has risks. The incredibly vague way that Ceru claimed eliminates that risk of a counterclaim, so I don't see how it warrants a town read.

It's unlikely but possible that scum used at least one of their questions on a SOP-claim role to set that up.

Edit post

Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.

ISO #68 •••

So I watched two episodes of this last night and man, it's pretty good. I'm already loving this little bald eyebrowless guy.

Edit post

ISO #69 •••

There is no reason to townread Ceru unless he hard claims his role. However I'd like to know why he should be our de facto lynch target based on his soft claim.

Edit post

ISO #70 •••
--> @ILikePie5

Probably should have tagged you in that last one

Edit post

ISO #71 •••
--> @Thoth

I guess I just take things too practical

Edit post

Kick logic to the curb and do the impossible!

ISO #72 •••

I don’t love that sarcastic useful but I read too much into last game and I don’t want to be burned by something similiar last game and don’t wanna have it happen again

Edit post

Kick logic to the curb and do the impossible!

ISO #73 •••

Page 2 is a big nothing burger

Edit post

Kick logic to the curb and do the impossible!

ISO #74 •••
--> @Kohai

Ceru should not be a hard town read at this point. I’m only town reading him if a few things happen in this game but there’s no reason he’s town just for following town protocol

Edit post

Kick logic to the curb and do the impossible!

ISO #75 •••
--> @Thoth
It's unlikely but possible that scum used at least one of their questions on a SOP-claim role to set that up.

More to the point, you'd almost need both questions to get a reliable claim, since you need a character that fits it as well.


Although I suppose there are several characters who could fit a Miller-like role on this particular theme, aren't there? Even the main character, perhaps.

Edit post

ISO #76 •••
--> @Wryly
However I'd like to know why he should be our de facto lynch target based on his soft claim.

I imagine it's something along the lines of "Do you have a better idea?", since I wouldn't be a major loss if mischopped.

Edit post

ISO #77 •••
--> @ILikePie5
What would you expect some common theme splits are

My spitball is police/detectives (Mafia) vs. not (Town).


I would say that because the show seems to put some focus on the contrast between Barry's acting life and his killer life, that could be the theme split, but my character makes me doubt that.

Edit post

ISO #78 •••
--> @Cerulean
My spitball is police/detectives (Mafia) vs. not (Town).

Theme splits are up to the game host and don't have to be obvious or even be characters who would normally be working together. This is the first whiteflame game I've played in, so I'm curious what modpsych suggests here.

Edit post

Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.

ISO #79 •••
--> @ILikePie5
You realize scum could ask if roles exist right


You know, I'm having a hard time that Cerulean would gambit like that. It would be a waste of a question, and in addition force a mafioso into the spotlight. Cerulean could be town, but I wonder what Scum!Cerulean would feel about his scum buddy volunteering his head on the chopping block.

Edit post

ISO #80 •••
--> @Wryly
So I watched two episodes of this last night and man, it's pretty good. I'm already loving this little bald eyebrowless guy.

 i was literally just telling Whiteflame that i think Noho hank absolutely Carries the show. Love his character

Edit post

In loving Memory of Lannan and Ajab, fallen debaters.

ISO #81 •••
--> @ILikePie5
What would you expect some common theme splits are


I was thinking about that. I’ll have to think harder because the protagonist here is kind of a bad guy and the “villain” of the first season is Janice Moss who is after him but she’s not really a bad person she’s just counter to the protagonist. I could see Barry being scum, but I do doubt that here based on things in my role PM but I could be mistakenly understanding something.


It could be like Checyens vs everyone else or Bolivians vs Chechen’s or Barry vs actors or actors plethora of things. Will need a scum flip before I can really cook with this

Edit post

In loving Memory of Lannan and Ajab, fallen debaters.

ISO #82 •••

I’m willing to lend ceru a bit of a town cred for the miller claim sure

Edit post

In loving Memory of Lannan and Ajab, fallen debaters.

ISO #83 •••
--> @Lunatic
I’m willing to lend ceru a bit of a town cred for the miller claim sure

Did he explicitly claim Miller? From what I recall, he could have meant Gravedigger or, much less likely, a custom role.

Edit post

Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.

ISO #84 •••

In my previous post, I assumed that Cerulean is male. I apologize if this was incorrect, and will try to avoid making such unwarranted assumptions in the future.

Edit post

Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.

ISO #85 •••
--> @Thoth

I’m lending town cred to whatever it is

Edit post

In loving Memory of Lannan and Ajab, fallen debaters.

ISO #86 •••

A little over 38 hours remain in the DP.


Hank: "Oh my god, my guys suck ballsyou know it. Especially this motherfucker right here."

Akhmal: "If I suck ballsyou are king of suck balls mountain."

Edit post

ISO #87 •••
--> @Thoth
Eh. You have to look at free speech on a spectrum. I don't think it would fly on here if someone were wildly slinging slurs, especially not the N word and the bundle-of-sticks slur. That's what this site looks like to them.


Have you met Wylted lol

Edit post

ISO #88 •••
--> @Wryly
There is no reason to townread Ceru unless he hard claims his role. However I'd like to know why he should be our de facto lynch target based on his soft claim.


It’s a couple of things. If he’s town, scum are never gonna kill him. If he’s scum, we can’t investigate him or anything. He also brings low value to the rest of the game in terms of his role. In MYLO/LYLO it’s always going to hang over you that he could be scum because they used one of their questions on this type of role. I’ve been wanting to do it for eons when I’m scum

Edit post

ISO #89 •••
--> @Shining
You know, I'm having a hard time that Cerulean would gambit like that. It would be a waste of a question, and in addition force a mafioso into the spotlight. Cerulean could be town, but I wonder what Scum!Cerulean would feel about his scum buddy volunteering his head on the chopping block.


Why would it be a waste? It’s good play. Imagine if you’re a scum godfather. You know there’s a cop or something similar. It’s worth it to ask about a Miller and SOP claim that immediately

Edit post

ISO #90 •••
--> @Lunatic
I’m willing to lend ceru a bit of a town cred for the miller claim sure


You know what my stance is lol

Edit post