Locked

Barry Mafia - DP1

Started by whiteflame

Replies
231
Posts
232
Page
5 / 8

Conversation

Total: 232
ISO #121 •••

I hate how quiet this day phase is

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #122 •••

Just over 17 hours remain in the DP.

Edit post

ISO #123 •••

Scum team is probably just sitting back and hiding

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #124 •••

Lack of activity just aids scum, folks.

Edit post

ISO #125 •••

Welp, if I was scum I would just sit back and lie low until Ceru is mislynched. Easy peasy. No one has tried to generate suspicion on anyone else, so either Ceru isn't scum, scum is willing to bus, or scum just haven't been very active, of which the first seems likeliest to me at the moment.

Edit post

ISO #126 •••

I dont really wanna lynch ceru honestly, vtl kohai and thoth for suggesting it


Edit post

In loving Memory of Lannan and Ajab, fallen debaters.

ISO #127 •••

Woe be to the inactive Cerulean.


Actually, I do want to VTL Kohai for going from this:


You know, I'm having a hard time that Cerulean would gambit like that. It would be a waste of a question, and in addition force a mafioso into the spotlight. Cerulean could be town, but I wonder what Scum!Cerulean would feel about his scum buddy volunteering his head on the chopping block.

To:

48 hours in and I feel like we’ve gotten absolutely nowhere. I’ll start with a soft my character is male.
VTL Cerulean
Not a fan of this but if we have to lynch I’d rather lynch a person who could negatively impact town.



Edit post

ISO #128 •••
--> @Wryly
Welp, if I was scum I would just sit back and lie low until Ceru is mislynched. Easy peasy.

Is there anyone you think best fits this profile? Anyone you think would be talking more than usual that's seeming to sit back right now?

Edit post

ISO #129 •••
--> @Thoth
So if the Cop checks you, you show up as the opposite of what a Miller would show???


What are you even saying?

Edit post

ISO #130 •••
--> @Thoth
My question is what kind of monster would include a godfather in a setup where the player count almost guarantees two scum. What good is half a cop?


Thats a balance argument. Town could just be as weak

Edit post

ISO #131 •••
--> @Shining
Are you claiming Ceru is possibly a godfather?


It’s possible, but more likely his partner is

Edit post

ISO #132 •••
--> @Lunatic
No offense dawg but at this point I think it’s one of those stances you have and believe but don’t ever really follow because you secretly realize the logic behind it is faulty but don’t wanna admit your wrong in lmao. You’ve had this anti miller policy for years but I don’t think I ever really remember you actually advocating a lynch on one past maybe saying they should be a default lynch in case of no others once or twice but then never following through on that. 


What do you mean? There have been a few games where we lynch a scummier player, and I think some were town and some were scum. Sometimes it’s worked in our favor down the line just purely based on the behavior of the Miller.


lmao it’s like the Christian parent who doesn’t believe in gay marriage but has a gay kid and they still love them and don’t lecture them on their life choices. It’s okay to admit you were wrong in that logic pie! Time to drop it lol not a hill worth dying on. Don’t be the Christian mom who refuses to change with the times!


Nah, I’d prefer not dealing with the potential headache. No lynching doesn’t make sense and right now idt there’s a legitimate target that tingles my spidey senses

Edit post

ISO #133 •••
--> @Lunatic
My soft is that my character is on the list I provided. I recommend we all soft a different way, I think scum have in general caught on to the "type claiming" meta where people claim male/female, DOB, etc. Maybe we all do something different. 


I don’t think this strategy is effective though. You could just be vague like my guy is a criminal and it would encompass everyone. It’s hard to do POE if the baseline is different

Edit post

ISO #134 •••
--> @Kohai
48 hours in and I feel like we’ve gotten absolutely nowhere. I’ll start with a soft my character is male. 

VTL Cerulean

Not a fan of this but if we have to lynch I’d rather lynch a person who could negatively impact town.


Okay so what made him go from heavily town to scum cause you just completely 180ed

Edit post

ISO #135 •••
--> @Kohai, @Lunatic

I will hard claim because I'm not particularly interested in being Day 1'd.


I am Goran Pazar, the mob boss who hired Barry. Apparently the justification is that I've lost control of hitmen before, so I leave fingerprints on deaths that I'm not responsible for- therefore, I'm a "Gravedigger" who shows up as visiting anyone who dies on the night of their deaths.


Personally, I don't like "Gravedigger" as a role name because it seems too close to the role that takes abilities from dead players, but apparently it's something that's used here.


Tagging Lunatic so he can do a double check on that flavor if he wants and tagging Kohai as a reminder of my vote on them.

Edit post

ISO #136 •••
--> @Shining
DP1 problems lol. I feel like everyone is simply on board with policy lynching Cerulean and doesn't have much nore to add.


You never answered my question. Also who do you scunread

Edit post

ISO #137 •••
--> @Wryly
Requesting soft claims or some explanation for lack thereof


I think we should be consistent with what we soft claim

Edit post

ISO #138 •••
  1. Thoth
  2. Pie
  3. Wryly
  4. Vader
  5. Kohai
  6. Lunatic
  7. RexFavilla
  8. Shining
  9. Cerulean - Goran Pazar - Gravedigger


Edit post

ISO #139 •••
--> @Kohai, @Lunatic, @Thoth, @Vader, @Wryly
Welp, if I was scum I would just sit back and lie low until Ceru is mislynched.


How do you know Ceru is a mislynch?

Edit post

ISO #140 •••

Votes:


Wryly (1/5): RexFavilla

Cerulean (2/5): Kohai, Thoth

Kohai (1/5): Cerulean

Edit post

ISO #141 •••
--> @Thoth
My question is what kind of monster would include a godfather in a setup where the player count almost guarantees two scum. What good is half a cop?

The last game I played on DART, Call of Duty, had a Godfather with 2 scum total. That was a Pie game, actually, so I could see why he thinks it'd be a reasonable thing to happen in the first place.

Edit post

ISO #142 •••
--> @RexFavilla, @Vader

any comments from yall?

Edit post

ISO #143 •••
--> @ILikePie5
How do you know Ceru is a mislynch?

I... suppose I wouldn't be surprised if someone was TMIing me Town in a situation where it looks like I'm the default lynch in order to look good. Hm.

Edit post

ISO #144 •••
--> @ILikePie5
Okay so what made him go from heavily town to scum cause you just completely 180ed


Did you not read what I wrote? If we have to make a lynch today at least let it be someone that can hurt town. I’d really would rather not run up another person to L1 and have them claim.


VTNL


Ceru’s claim can be tested tonight.

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #145 •••
--> @ILikePie5
Welp, if I was scum I would just sit back and lie low until Ceru is mislynched.


How do you know Ceru is a mislynch?


This is gross a distortion of Castin’s words.

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #146 •••
--> @ILikePie5
How do you know Ceru is a mislynch?


I don't, but I explained my reasoning for the guess in the original post you quoted.

Edit post

ISO #147 •••
--> @Kohai
Did you not read what I wrote? If we have to make a lynch today at least let it be someone that can hurt town. I’d really would rather not run up another person to L1 and have them claim. 

VTNL 

Ceru’s claim can be tested tonight.



So you want to give up our chance to lynch now? We should definitely not No Lynch as the game is 7-2

Edit post

ISO #148 •••
--> @Cerulean
Welp, if I was scum I would just sit back and lie low until Ceru is mislynched. Easy peasy.
Is there anyone you think best fits this profile? Anyone you think would be talking more than usual that's seeming to sit back right now?


In my experience, Rex and Vader are both sporadic posters in general, with periods of inactivity common. Thus difficult to pin down when their silences are scummy.


I can't remember if I've ever played a game with Shining.


Kohai and Pie are usually quite active and have been consistent with that this DP.


Thoth is usually an active player as well. He's been perhaps a bit less prolific than normal, but it's been a slow DP all around.

Edit post

ISO #149 •••
--> @Kohai
This is gross a distortion of Castin’s words.


How so

Edit post

ISO #150 •••

Kohai is scummy af but he’s always scummy af. Earth has this problem as well, it’s annoying af

Edit post