HCBM Mafia DP2

I have the one-shot ability to tell how many scum were on a lynch.

Yesterday there was exactly one.

I asked the host if my results are guaranteed to be accurate, if it’s possible for there to be zero or two scum when I get “one scum” as a result, and his reply was “Your results are guaranteed to be 100% accurate”. I dunno what that means. Lol

But, gut wise if you put a one-shot ability in the game like this, you probably won’t give scum roles that can make them invisible to it.

So probably there’s exactly one scum in [Whiteflame, Kohai, Mag1cman].

IF we can trust my ability that also directly implies there’s one scum in [Thoth, Shining, Wryly]

It’s not very useful information, I know.

I have the one-shot ability to tell how many scum were on a lynch.

O_o I've never heard of this role, what's it called.

Interesting... I have been townreading Kohai, who sadly hasn't been more active, and while Mharman has been more active, I only have a lean town on him. I honestly wouldn't put it past WF to be buddies with Thoth.

Magoroth

As noted earlier, his progression on claiming was so weird. He was clearly thinking about the risks of character claiming and just, did it anyway. This feels like scum eager to use his fake claim.

There’s also the constant shade throwing. He never really pushed anyone, he just sits back and throws shade. Like he’s afraid to commit.

“Were you perchance looking for what character you could fake claim as scum? :P”

“Did you perchance try to call me out for claiming two characters as a way of “faking scumhuting” as scum? :P”

“I scumread one of your posts: “I always pictured you as Chinese for some reason”.

Tonally it feels off.“

He never establishes any real reads, just always has shade to throw. But he has joined wagons suddenly out of nowhere.

hard scum

What's your role called

I’m thinking about his claim hold on

I’m thinking about his claim hold on

Wait there’s one scum between Magoroth and Kohai, 100%

Miller implies Cop.

Cop + Tracker + Scum wagon counter role

that’a too many investigatives

If a cop claims, Magoroth is lock scum.

Like I guess it could technically be possible that a Miller would flip guilty to Magoroth’s role and there’s no cop.

but if a cop claims that’s wraps for him

I could be proven wrong quickly, but I’ve been doubting claim. I don’t think investigative claim character instantly. Y’all saw how Pie handled it.

The only thing that trips me up is how he asked Vader about his results. But that dialogue can be faked.

Well, if I were a cop, I would claim cop right now, and I'm not

O_o I've never heard of this role, what's it called.

Sensor, probably

Cop or not? Or another investigative that could be bothered by a miller.

Ask Vader about how a miller interacts with your role

Can you just full claim already?

Who?

Sensor.

I did ask him. His reply was “Your results are guaranteed to be 100% accurate”. Yes, a second time. Lol.

Mag1cman are you claiming Miller?

Mag1cman, I don’t get most of your takes. Why does a Cop claiming make me scum? My role isn’t even that strong.

I remember the scum on a lynch sensor being a role before. If I recall, its pretty busted. And Town had a tracker, in Pie's hands, mond. I have more reasons to not immediately believe Magoroth.

if your results are guaranteed to be 100% accurate, then a miller would not register as scum then, no? That implies a cop and it scumlocks one between you and Kohai.

and no I’m not claiming miller I’m talking about Kohai

Are you ignoring [Whiteflame, Kohai, Mag1cman]? There is literally one scum in this group, which includes YOU. Have you forgotten?

Whiteflame can also be scum.

cop + sensor + tracker is insane town investigative power and your role is way better than you give credit for.

Tracker is already in the game so either a sensor or a cop is fake. If the cop is fake, so is the miller. Unless Vader answered weirdly it guess. But that feels off. Why would he tell you 100% if a Mille could ruin it? Makes no sense. So I think either the cop isn’t real, or the sensor isnt real. And then it’s just you vs Kohai.

Are you ignoring [Whiteflame, Kohai, Mag1cman]? There is literally one scum in this group, which includes YOU. Have you forgotten?

this assumes your role is real

I don’t even get what’s weird about my progression according to Mag1cman. You’re listing things that are completely normal. You’re taking issue with my phrasing which is subdued because I’m new on this website and therefore “shy” and I don’t give it my best, I rely on others to progress the game and I’m just kinda reacting. That’s why you think my takes are that weird.

As a new player who doesn’t know anyone, they’re really not that weird.

Nobody has claimed Miller.

And maybe scum is immune to Tracker.