Assume I have a problem with my working memory to the extent I can't remember shit either of you has said. Why are we voting Kohai?
Feels comfortable, like an old glove.
Not really sure who I want to lynch tbh. No negative utility roles, no strong scumreads.
Are people up for Thoth? What's the case for him?
Are people up for Thoth? What's the case for him?
They want to policy lynch me because I edited a post, even though it was a joke that had nothing to do with the game
Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.
He edited his post and I am more willing to forgive a new player. Kohai had his vote on him prior to the edit
Do you think he's likely to have done this as scum, or do you just think he should be punished for stepping over that line?
Sorry I haven’t been paying much attention. Been hyper focused on other things. Sorry for not giving this the time it deserves. Gonna go through this when I get home
"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein
Just fyi, I thought that editing a post left a message that said "Last edited by [person] at [time]" or something along those lines. So I never would have done it with any game-related post.
Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.
Are people up for Thoth? What's the case for him?
i dont wanna lynch thoth, hes been pretty forthcoming with his soft claims to the point where if i was to go rogue i could probably guess who he is, and no one was forcing him to claim either so if he is scum we have to assume mafia just didnt want to use their questions yet or they used them really early already and were super confident in a claim. its possible. is there any specific reason you want to lynch him, because right now hes my towniest read
vtl rexfavilla, i feel like im pretty lazy and inactive, but even im caught up, im getting the impression he hasnt read the game and is looking to follow other peoples opinions. asking for some case on thoth instead of just reading a few posts himself to find out, seems like he isnt that invested in the game
What was the joke, and why erase it?
It does bother me a bit that you seem to be self conscious about posting fluff. Why is that something that would make you self conscious?
The joke in post #57. I didn't erase it. I edited it because I forgot a word and typos like that can ruin jokes. I'm not self-conscious about posting fluff.
Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.
Stepping over a line but also I do think he is marginally more likely to do this as scum. I have had an urge to do it as scum in situations where I thought I could do it before anyone noticed just from not being careful with my words. What is he like 2/9 to be scum. That sort of thing may make him 3/9 to be scum in my opinion
Not sure how it makes him more likely to be scum. He's calling attention to himself and potentially resulting in a mod kill. Thoth is the kind of guy who wouldn't necessarily touch base with his partner before making a choice like this, but it's odd that he'd be this cavalier.
vtl rexfavilla, i feel like im pretty lazy and inactive, but even im caught up, im getting the impression he hasnt read the game and is looking to follow other peoples opinions. asking for some case on thoth instead of just reading a few posts himself to find out, seems like he isnt that invested in the game
There are other elements of his play that make him questionable for me, but this reads as more of a towntell or NAI from REF. He's more likely to be invested and following the game if he's scum.
Official Vote Count:
Thoth (2/5) - Kohai, Wylted
Kohai (2/5) - REF, Thoth
REF (1/5) - Banana
Approximately 27 hours remaining
Relative lack of participation on your part is pinging me a bit. You started off the DP saying you'd be busy, came back in and sussed me for seeking softclaims before just providing yours and, later, calling it "weak softing" without "much purpose." Would like to get some thoughts on the DP so far, since all I'm seeing here is inconsistency.
VTL Magoroth
Official Vote Count:
Thoth (2/5) - Kohai, Wylted
Kohai (2/5) - REF, Thoth
REF (1/5) - Banana
Mago (1/5) - Whiteflame
Approximately 27 hours remaining
There are other elements of his play that make him questionable for me, but this reads as more of a towntell or NAI from REF. He's more likely to be invested and following the game if he's scum.
but if he knows this is a common tell of his wouldnt as scum he want to try and blend in by acting like that
Relative lack of participation on your part is pinging me a bit. You started off the DP saying you'd be busy, came back in and sussed me for seeking softclaims before just providing yours and, later, calling it "weak softing" without "much purpose." Would like to get some thoughts on the DP so far, since all I'm seeing here is inconsistency.
VTL Magoroth
shining seems to fit this category as well, doesnt seem to really post anything of substance but critizes people for making theme analysis even though he doesnt offer anything to go on in its place
I wouldn't put much money in a possible mod kill. I did think it was odd that Thoth edited his post because he been he long enough to know thats not allowed here. idk.
Its DP1. Everyone is practically fluff posting. I don't care who we pressure. Pick someone, make them character/role claim and lunch them if they are especially scummy.
I can see where you're coming from, even if I have some trouble believing that he posted something incriminating and felt the need to remove it at the potential cost of getting modkilled. I don't like that he did it and I'm not saying I'm buying wholesale into the reasons he's given for doing it, I'm just not convinced he did it specifically to remove a scummy element of his post only to then call attention to the removal.
As for explaining his state of mind, he said already that it was because a typo ruined a joke he was trying to tell. I don't know how much he can expand on his state of mind beyond that if he's telling the truth.
To be clear, I don't see these as towntells. It's a baffling choice, but it comes off as NAI to me.
but if he knows this is a common tell of his wouldnt as scum he want to try and blend in by acting like that
Maybe, that's why I said it's either a towntell or NAI to me. I could see REF using this kind of post to look a little townier to people who know him well, I put similar likelihood on his investment being low.
shining seems to fit this category as well, doesnt seem to really post anything of substance but critizes people for making theme analysis even though he doesnt offer anything to go on in its place
True, and he's pinged me as well. I'd say it's the inconsistencies post-to-post that have Magoroth a little higher on my list.
I am like 90% sure that banana is scum I don't want to put a lot of effort into corralling you guys and since we have no good choices other than her let's just lynch her.
Can you at least give me some idea of why, or is this just a strong gutread?
I'll give them a read-through. Don't have a lot to go off of anyway and it gives me something to focus on.
