MAGA Mafia DP1

Official Vote Count:

Kohai (2/5) - REF, Thoth

Banana (1/5) - Wylted

Thoth (1/5) - Kohai

Shining (1/5) - Banana

Mago (1/5) - Whiteflame

looking at the vote count we are pretty divided. i still would like to hear from shining but i think ill help whiteflame for now and work on mago since he is also in the same boat as rex and shining

unvote, vote to lynch magorath

And magic i forgot to say

Official Vote Count:

Kohai (2/5) - REF, Thoth

Mago (2/5) - Whiteflame, Banana

Banana (1/5) - Wylted

Thoth (1/5) - Kohai

Official Vote Count:

Mago (3/5) - Whiteflame, Banana, Wylted

Kohai (2/5) - REF, Thoth

Thoth (1/5) - Kohai

VTL Magoroth

I think mag is objectively one of the best lynched. He’s far too inactive compared to his game style in the last game.

I don't get the scumread on Bananer, but I've only played one game with her and we were both scum so I probably can't read her very well. I did recall her being lurkier as scum.

I find the Thoth post by Kohai to be suspicious - if he voted for Thoth before editgate and then comes out saying editgate is why he voted Thoth that is a bit suspicious.

Another soft: my character started a fashion trend.

1. Thoth - Role PM mentions a lot of stuff from 2016 election, held political office before 2016 - ??

2. Magoroth - Republican, not in either Trump administration - ??

3. Mag1cman - currently in the Trump administration - ??

4. Whiteflame - not in the Trump administration, but in Trump's orbit, has not held political office - ??

5. Kohai - major part of the Trump admin and loyal supporter / Former Congressmen- ??

6. REF - not in the Trump administration, but in Trump's orbit / Started fashion trend - ??

7. Shining - currently in Trump administration - ??

8. Banana - currently in the Trump administration, deals with money - ??

9. Wylted - public official, not in the Trump administration, but in Trump's orbit - ??

Unvote

4 votes is a little too close for comfort and he should have a chance 2 talk. Idk i don’t like how willing kohai put him so close to a lynch either

i think I kno who u r 2 based on that

don’t we have like 16 hours? why cant he have a chance to speak?

it seems we are agreeing on the ideas behind on most of our reads here, that makes me a bit more comfortable with the idea that you are town

Don't usually like to undercut townreads, but I know I wouldn't be the first person to try to largely line up my reads with a town player for towncred. Not that you're for sure town, just saying it's not the strongest basis for a townread.

i dont think i picked up on that, thanks for the heads up

Yeah, his original VTL came with the statement that Thoth was "disrespecting the greatest president in US history," which seemed more like he was embodying his character than actually placing a serious vote.

wait a darn second i thought he was softing trump, but trump wasnt a US senator. that moves him back down a notch on the town list for me.

Can't say I thought he was softing Trump. If he's who I think he is, he's pretty solid town.

Ya but everyone should have a chance to defend themselves

I'm comfortable leaving my vote where it is, though I would vastly prefer Magoroth's participation to lynching him blind. A character claim would help a lot there.

Can't say I thought he was softing Trump. If he's who I think he is, he's pretty solid town.

i think that narrows him down to like 3 or 4 people but im not sure why any of them r solid town

i think that narrows him down to like 3 or 4 people but im not sure why any of them r solid town

I'm going to avoid speculating since that might result in him outing who he is. I agree there are about that number of possibilities.

I’m here. Haven’t been invested as much this time around.

We have until 10:30 pm est

Official Vote Count:

Mago (3/5) - Whiteflame, Wylted, Kohai

Kohai (2/5) - REF, Thoth

If you’re speculating scum’s characters, you’re wasting time. They aren’t gonna straight claim when they have four whole questions and our softs to work with.

I’m going to believe 51 from Kohai.

I’m going to believe 51 from Kohai.

why? what character besides trump could be town confirmed? u dont have to answer that because it would be speculating his pm, im just not understanding the logic

My character has been extremely loyal to Trump and has been a vital part in the Trump administration.

If you all want I can just hard claim my character. 99% chance you already know who I am

My character has been extremely loyal to Trump and has been a vital part in the Trump administration. 

If you all want I can just hard claim my character. 99% chance you already know who I am 

I wasn’t asking for that i was just wondering how we can know what characters are town or not if we do not know what the theme split is. i might assume trump is town but that’s about it

I wasn’t asking for that i was just wondering how we can know what characters are town or not if we do not know what the theme split is. i might assume trump is town but that’s about it

As I said earlier, I think we can assume that scum were not given characters that could easily go unnoticed if claimed. Pie gave them four questions, which suggests they are in need of good character and role fake claims. As an example, I ran a game just a little bit ago with Barry characters where I'd given scum two of the MCs, and as a result, they only got two questions to ask. If everyone in this game is just straight up MAGA and the split is more subtle, then I doubt they'd need so many questions since they probably could get away with just straight up claiming their characters, or at least one of them could. So I think we can assume that the split is current MAGA people vs. some flavor of non-MAGA or former MAGA.