The Legend of Zelda: The Mafia Game (DP1)

Ngl If I was scum and got someone lynched for having an Epstein pfp, I would laugh my ass off. It feels a little odd for him to be that opportunistic out of the gate, though. But I could be wrong.

Mag1cman - Softclaimed, pushed back on policy lynching Wylted, largely basing early scumreads on activity. Townreads Wylted for townreading Pie for saying saying he's town, less clear on the slight town reads for Thoth and Magoroth.

Wylted’s townread on Pie is something Wylted does a lot as town, trying to quick solve things. Also him trying to buddy up with Pie is something he does frequently as town.

Magoroth’s cult questioning by was something I felt was a sign of a townie ignorance. Nothing feels off about the way he’s posting either.

As for Thoth that situation has changed

I’d say I am in agreement for the most part with your town pile, maybe I’d switch you for mago, mago is null to me atm

There’s no opportunity because we shut it down. But he keeps going. For most people I’d say it’s honest and call it a day, but I’ve seen Thoth as scum and he mentioned something about taking advantage of his typical weirdness.

The only thing I’m getting from this whole Lunatic/Thoth conundrum is that they’re probably separate alignments. Or both Town. But they can’t both be scum.

I haven’t seen them scumread each other just yet. I don’t think some teammate bickering is off the table. Lunatic’s response didn’t really sway me either.

I have a question for Pie I’m still waiting on. Still thinking about Rex and Whiteflame.

Trying to avoid past mistakes. I ain’t townreading you just yet either.

anyway if I’m ringing alarm bells, why leave me out of the list of people you could get a claim from?

It’s not enough to garner a scumread, just a spidey sense tingling. You’ve done more than the other 3 people as well imo

I'm pretty much in the same boat. Usually, certain players are lynch magnets DP1 and a lot of them aren't in this game. I feel like we're treading water a bit because of that. I especially want to see more posts from Magoroth. If I had to pick, it'd be there. He had a pretty rough last game and was a prolific poster, so if he rolled scum this time, I could see him being a bit reticent.

Unvote

VTL Magoroth

I'll check in again in the morning.

This is a good point. The game he was scum with Kohai, very inactive. As town, active and a prolific poster. Hasn’t done much this game, which is significant.

unvote

VTL Mago for full claim

4 anyone still suspecting me or voting me i can confirm my role at the end of the day phase if needed n theres no way my role would b on scum 

Nah leave it.

idk if I fully buy that and it’s making me start to sus you.

Thoughts on Lunatic and Thoth?

What makes you think Pie is town just for saying he’s town? Is there more to the townread?

I will full claim if requested, but I would prefer not to.

Now you kinda have to

Alright boys, new pfp. If your offended and you know it clap your hands!

👏👏

I just realize this is why pie is voting people. Jesus Christ. Yes the soft claiming meets is retarded. Next game we lunch whoever attempted to do it first as policy

It’s the best way to hone the initial pressure imo. Otherwise we’re just stuck in RVS

I wasn’t there and I’m not gonna dig through it. I know he was mislynched that game and that’s it. Could you expand on this?

He was basically inactive the entire game. Didn’t even show up to full claim. Got lynched because of time pressure

Town pile: Banana, Wylted, Magoroth

Why Mago?

Not offended. Loving it. Pie probably does also but means good luck in India or something 

It’s a holy sign

I haven't said anything about a cult this game

See, this is why doing a late night ISO on limited sleep isn't great. You did mention a cult, but in the context of how people would think about the "alignment changes" portion of the OP. You were indeed not suggesting the existence of a cult, my error.

Wylted’s townread on Pie is something Wylted does a lot as town, trying to quick solve things. Also him trying to buddy up with Pie is something he does frequently as town.

I'll need to go back through previous games, but I distinctly recall him buddying as scum before as well. It's NAI to me.

Magoroth’s cult questioning by was something I felt was a sign of a townie ignorance. Nothing feels off about the way he’s posting either.

Hasn't really pinged me, either. Always hesitant to indicate alignment based on ignorance, but fair point.

As for Thoth that situation has changed

Got it.

idk if I fully buy that and it’s making me start to sus you.

Going back to status quo. Much better

Thoughts on Lunatic and Thoth?

Null on both. Luna picks up late game. He’s not wrong about that. Thoth is just weird. It’s hard to read into his behavior because he does weird stuff as town and scum, and I’ve been burned by it

Alright boys, new pfp. If your offended and you know it clap your hands!

That's certainly a statement.

I’m Peatrice. I’m Vanilla. I have a huge crush on Link.

I won’t claim my justification for why my role is Vanilla, because I think it would count as angle shooting, due to the way it’s worded. If there are other Vanilla they could 1) townread me for it and 2) scum could figure out who the Vanilla are (trivial) and shoot in the PR pool.

If Lunatic is scum, I think it’s more likely he is TMI’ing Pie as Town or defending a team mate, with Thoth just caught in the crossfire. There is probably at most one scum in Lunatic/Thoth. In my experience that kind of bickering doesn’t usually occur between teammates.

I’m Peatrice. I’m Vanilla. I have a huge crush on Link.

Been a long time since I've played Skyward Sword, but I somehow do remember this character. Seems like a pretty safe claim, even if her being Vanilla isn't surprising.

I won’t claim my justification for why my role is Vanilla, because I think it would count as angle shooting, due to the way it’s worded. If there are other Vanilla they could 1) townread me for it and 2) scum could figure out who the Vanilla are (trivial) and shoot in the PR pool.

Don't really see how providing the justification is angle shooting, but I also can't see how it's worded so that's a call you're going to have to make. As for making it easier for scum to shoot in the PR pool, that's based on whether other Vanillas out themselves, which would be a mistake. I don't think that's more likely just because you provide your justification.

well, the wording is somewhat unusual. I haven’t checked the rest of the games that had Vanillas in them but it’s a wording I encountered on my homesite and which seems to be very uncommon, at least on MS/MU. so I figure, if someone else has the same stuff in their role card as me, they would immediately realise I’m telling the truth, which could be read into for scum

Whelp, I am being dm'ed about changing my profile picture. I guess those not privy to the mafia game probably don't know my point was to make fun of thoth and demonstrate having an edgy pfp doesn't mean you believe and support nazi'ism, but whatever. Point still stands.

Whelp, I am being dm'ed about changing my profile picture. I guess those not privy to the mafia game probably don't know my point was to make fun of thoth and demonstrate having an edgy pfp doesn't mean you believe and support nazi'ism, but whatever. Point still stands.

🤦‍♂️

I’m Peatrice. I’m Vanilla. I have a huge crush on Link.

Very interesting.

We should not have given Barney or Kohai any mod powers.