Locked

Andor Mafia DP1

Started by Savant

Replies
263
Posts
264
Page
7 / 9

Conversation

Total: 264
ISO #181 •••

Kind of waffling on whether to townread Rex for it

Edit post

ISO #182 •••
--> @Wryly
I am getting a bad gutread on Wryly. I can’t place it, but something seems off.

This again?


i will say i can see where he is coming from, u seem less light hearted and fluffy as you normally do as town

Edit post

ISO #183 •••
--> @Banana

I literally posted fluff for three pages until whiteflame declared no more fluff and everyone stopped posting fluff, what

Edit post

ISO #184 •••
--> @Wryly

sure a post about ewoks and jabbas fat rolls, a jokey seeming vote on thoth, and a post pointin out that your fluffing. idk if i can explain it or pinpoint it properly but it doesn't feel the same. im open minded tho. anyways i dont think we lynch you or anything just sayin i can see his point is all

Edit post

ISO #185 •••

okay my town pile is as follows


mago- based on his claim n behavior

thoth and wylted- thoth says his pm makes wylted look okay, so im putting a bit of trust into that n hopin its not a bus



whiteflame- null, but i like his takes

rex- null

skipper- null, inacitve


i've got scummy vibes from kohai from his over defensiveness from magos vote and i also feel wryly is a bit off, but i dont neccesly scum read them either, just slight inklings so far.

Edit post

ISO #186 •••

Sounds like vibes reads, which are as the wind


We need to lynch someone, we have 5 days left


VTL Skipper

Edit post

ISO #187 •••
--> @Thoth
I don’t want to specify, but wylted’s claims fits with my role


I think I get what you're suggesting. I'll avoid prying further for now, though if I am understanding you correctly, I wouldn't view that as any kind of confirmation.

Edit post

ISO #188 •••
--> @Kohai
i don’t feel the need to do full claims on day 1. It just gives scum TMI and helps them plan their night actions. I’d rather do a character claim or soft.


I'm fine with limiting the number of full claims we get this DP, but you should expect that you'll have to full claim next DP.


Also I do town read wylted even though I don’t buy the claim because 1) I doubt scum makes that up and 2) I don’t see scum full claiming like that unprompted.


Literally made up the same exact role claim before as scum. I'm less certain on the "why" of his full claiming in this moment, but I could see town and scum reasons to do it. It's NAI to me right now.

Edit post

ISO #189 •••
--> @Skipper

Have we even tagged you yet?


Help us out and post a claim, I don't want to lynch a townie

Edit post

ISO #190 •••
--> @Wryly

For what?

Edit post

ISO #191 •••
--> @Wryly
I don't think wylted is confirmed town like Thoth does, but the character and role are plausible and there aren't many people who have claimed; it makes sense to put aside the few who have and focus on those shifting their weight in the shadows.


Yes, the character and role do work together. While I don't see a reason to lynch him over it and I agree that the focus should be on people who are inactive, I'll note that scum do have the option to ask two questions each about characters and roles.


Why are you townreading Rex? For pointing out the timer? That could as easily be an attempt to farm towncred.


I think he had the opportunity to just let things ride for a while and run out the clock. Sure, he could just be farming towncred, but doing it when he did felt townie to me. He could have easily waited another 12-24 hours and gotten the towncred anyway.

Edit post

ISO #192 •••

For being the one to point out the timer? +town points for it for sure

Edit post

ISO #193 •••

So what I think we could do to balance time with reads/etc is spend 24 hours max each day phase from now on.

Edit post

ISO #194 •••
--> @whiteflame
I think he had the opportunity to just let things ride for a while and run out the clock. Sure, he could just be farming towncred, but doing it when he did felt townie to me. He could have easily waited another 12-24 hours and gotten the towncred anyway.


This is a fair point

Edit post

ISO #195 •••
--> @Skipper, @Wryly
Have we even tagged you yet?

Help us out and post a claim, I don't want to lynch a townie


He's been tagged at least a couple of times, I know I did a couple of pages back. I'm hesitant to lynch blind too, but he's literally burning our daylight and I don't see a better choice. I'm going to be busy much of the afternoon, but if I'm tracking this correctly, he's already at L-1. If we don't hear from him soon, I'll hammer.

Edit post

ISO #196 •••
--> @Savant

Any chance we can get a quick replacement for Skipper

Edit post

ISO #197 •••

Someone cast a negative vote on Skipper!

Edit post

ISO #198 •••

Official Vote Count:


Kohai (3/5) - RexFavilla, wylted, Thoth

Skipper (2/5) - Kohai, Magoroth, Wryly

Edit post

ISO #199 •••
Someone cast a negative vote on Skipper!


That's... huh. Someone want to fess up to doing this or are we dealing with a scum mechanic? Because I'm not familiar with the concept of a "negative vote" and it seems particularly problematic if it's extending the DP for an absent player.

Edit post

ISO #200 •••

I could have sworn he was at L-1, but now that I have some room to put down a vote, I'll join the wagon.


VTL Skipper


I'm willing to wait to see if Savant can get someone, but not that long. Again, we shouldn't be taking up 2 full days of our time on a DP1, especially given the lack of viable information.

Edit post

ISO #201 •••
⚠️ This comment has been marked as offensive.

Edit post

ISO #202 •••
⚠️ This comment has been marked as offensive.

Edit post

ISO #203 •••

Lunatic just agreed to replace him

Edit post

ISO #204 •••
⚠️ This comment has been marked as offensive.

Edit post

ISO #205 •••
--> @Lunatic

Lunatic has agreed to replace Skipper!

Edit post

ISO #206 •••

Official Vote Count:


Kohai (2/5) - RexFavilla, Thoth

Lunatic (4/5) - Kohai, Magoroth, Wryly, wylted, whiteflame

Edit post

ISO #207 •••

Three scenarios here:


  1. Skipper is scum and his scummate removed a vote
  2. A townie with negative voting powers thinks we're making a mistake
  3. Scum thought they had secured a Skipper lynch, saw Lunatic was about to replace Skipper, and removed a vote just to cast suspicion on his replacement

Edit post

ISO #208 •••

Unvote


I want to hear from Lunatic

Edit post

ISO #209 •••
⚠️ This comment has been marked as offensive.

Edit post

ISO #210 •••
--> @Lunatic

Thanks for subbing!


Can we have a claim plz

Edit post