Safest bet when you redirect someone is to redirect them into themself. If they’re secretly a killing role instead of whatever they claimed that way they die
Safest bet when you redirect someone is to redirect them into themself. If they’re secretly a killing role instead of whatever they claimed that way they die
Why do you think you probably should have tracked Mago if you thought you would get a result on Shining?
Because I didn't get a result on shining...
In loving Memory of Lannan and Ajab, fallen debaters.
the thing with shining vs me is that its impossible to get an accurate read on shining due to how little he talks. he doesn’t seem uber scummy in his few comments, only thing you can really pin on him is agenda and FMPOV I have TMI since Shining is almost certainly scum and for me that’s easy but it does nothing for you.
so I think if you really wanna make a decision and find shining as scum, get him to talk more. theres plenty to read into when it comes to me
to clarify, I don’t think either of you is scum, but if you are, well-fucking played. I admit defeat, and I blame shining for not town telling enough, or rather town telling less than the scum lmao
what I mean is that Shining was utterly convinced it was me and Wylted last day, didn’t even consider the possibility of Thoth or Lunatic. it’s borderline TMI-ish. not a single doubt? hes also not read or been here most of the game yet somehow seems “informed” of all the things that have gone down. remember D1 Lynch when I asked shining how much of the game hes read?
I realise this is is some BS to you since as scum I coulda just planted that doubt on purpose (I guess it would not be hard to do), though
If Luna is scum, he made the most ridiculously unnecessary bus in history. If I am scum, the setup is at least borderline bastard since it means scum got two kills. So, not really that well played.
I forgot, did Vader check Shining night 1?
Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.
Yeah, but you couldn’t have known going into last night that you wouldn’t get a result.
Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.
Yeah, but you couldn’t have known going into last night that you wouldn’t get a result.
Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.
Yeah, but you couldn’t have known going into last night that you wouldn’t get a result.
I know, in hindsight I am saying I made a bad call since I would have rather got a succesful track off to make this easier. Now we basically are at 50% chance of winning based on who we guess is scum out of mago and shining.
In loving Memory of Lannan and Ajab, fallen debaters.
just saying that if you had tracked me you would’ve gotten the same result so we would be in the same situation
it’s not really ridiculously unnecessary, but I see your point
Holy hell nothing in 9 hours?
We can be fairly confident that Thoth is town confirmed because a mafia vig is stupid. Now, with a Vig, Doctor and cop, is there a tracker? Maybe. Lunatic bussed Wylted hard and its not like you can claim Lunatic bussed him because Pie was on his ass. Judging by your post that Lunatic would have the same result if he visited you, I assume you are a Ninja.
Why would there be a ninja and a lawyer?
Fuck off, Ninja and Lawyer vs Tracker and Cop is retardded
Redirector makes WAY more sense
Ninja and Lawyer vs Cop/Tracker virtually guarantees Scum will never be found. It’s almost as bad a combination as Godfather/Ninja. It don’t make a lick of sense. At least Rediector is skill-based...
Every-night Redirector would make sense because it gives scum a response to everything in a stacked town.
Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.
Yeah, but Shining can’t say Redirector makes sense or it throws suspicion onto him lol
morning just waking up
In loving Memory of Lannan and Ajab, fallen debaters.
So yeah behaviorally I have been townreading mago all game. Shining has been kind of null but it does help that he didn’t get tracked moving. So I’m conflicted. I doubt it’s Thoth, so it kind of feels like a coin flip here between mago and shining and I kind of hate that.
In loving Memory of Lannan and Ajab, fallen debaters.
You really want a redirector to be accepted because its the only way I am not confirmed town. Maybe there isn't a redirector and ninja. Maybe banana overtuned town and last mafia is just goon. Who knows.
How are you confirmed Town?
Also that doesn’t sound balanced either. Tracker/Cop/Doctor/Vigilante, with Mafia having no protection against tracker? Tracker could literally find the entire Mafia my friend, there being a Mafia Goon doesn’t make sense
As an aside Mafia can defend themself against Vigilante by redirecting him. Redirector or Bus Driver or what have you is effectively an anti-claim mechanic
I'm going to iso Shining and Magoroth tonight, but if it's Shining then I won't have that much to work off of.
Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.
Yeah, this is why the Strat for today would likely be to get Shining to talk as much as possible. If there’s any questions you or Lunatic have for me I’ll be happy to answer them. I can literally just tell the truth and win the game, Shining has to lie. The only thing he has going for him is the fact Lunatic didn’t see him visiting, and that he was quiet all game.
Man if mago is scum here he played really well. I’m not completely writing him off as scum yet, but he had me fooled for the whole game if so
In loving Memory of Lannan and Ajab, fallen debaters.
Man if mago is scum here he played really well. I’m not completely writing him off as scum yet, but he had me fooled for the whole game if so
In loving Memory of Lannan and Ajab, fallen debaters.