Scum Shining also might want to kill Banana because she had a MASSIVE hardon for him yesterday.
Everyone was gunning for Shining at some point yesterday and he would know everyone would gun for him today. I don't think he would've targeted her in particular.
What’s your justification again?
I don’t think she was the NK target. There are bigger fish to fry. Mestari/WF are far better targets and were widely townread
Yeah I said that.
Behaviorally she's looked pretty good all game, but I don't see them wanting to NK her over Mestari. They could've just NK'd Mestari and silenced you. That's what I would've done, knowing Vader would doctor you.
Can Silencer be used alongside an NK?
That I thrive in chaos and destruction and am ruthless. The ability is called 'Villainous Nature'
I also softed my character at some point but I can't remember when. I was arguing that SJW was a bad dude because my role card says he murdered my little bro and I wanted to kill him.
I’m willing to give Banana till tomorrow. I think behaviorally she’s not horrible
Behaviorally she's looked pretty good all game, but I don't see them wanting to NK her over Mestari. They could've just NK'd Mestari and silenced you. That's what I would've done, knowing Vader would doctor you.
Can Silencer be used alongside an NK?
Yes, it can
VTL vtlVTLvtl vtlvtlVTL vtl
Eh actually I need to reread DP1 again
Actually, it was my older brother, just double-checked.
No way scum!Banana tries to divert the lynch from Helz to Shining. I suppose there's an outside chance she knew the Helz lynch was inevitable and just went for a distancing play, but it's remote. I don't see Banana/Shining here.
I guess it's not unthinkable that she was the NK target instead. I'll admit I hadn't considered that. I don't like how she just gave up like that tho
VTL
I guess it's not unthinkable that she was the NK target instead. I'll admit I hadn't considered that. I don't like how she just gave up like that tho
This is a good point
No way scum!Banana tries to divert the lynch from Helz to Shining. I suppose there's an outside chance she knew the Helz lynch was inevitable and just went for a distancing play, but it's remote. I don't see Banana/Shining here.
I think it’s possible considering they would’ve bussed their partners
I don't see Banana/Shining here.
Maybe not, but it doesn't mean she's not scum, it just means they aren't partnered.
https://www.debatecraft.com/mafia/c/active-games/posts/3p/solo-leveling---day-phase-3?commentId=69db688af1ca45e41305dd39
This post caught my attention
I don't like how she just gave up like that tho
im not giving up, my vote is on who i think is scum. how am I supposed to defend against wha im accused of? i didnt do anything lol
You aren't defending yourself, tho. You were just like, "well, guess I'm gonna be lynched then. Oh, bummer!" That's not pro-town
im not giving up, my vote is on who i think is scum. how am I supposed to defend against wha im accused of? i didnt do anything lol
In ur own words, why is shining scum?
Ask Mikal how your justification applies to your ability
You aren't defending yourself, tho. You were just like, "well, guess I'm gonna be lynched then. Oh, bummer!" That's not pro-town
bcuz I’ve done this with pie b4, he always wins . if he wants me lynched i will b lynched. he mislynched me in ruyi zhuan 2, and i spent a lot of time arguing against him and no one took my side. also there isn’t really a case against me to respond to. u guys think i carried out the night kill. i told u i didnt. what more can i say against that? if u guys lynch me it will suck but it’s not the end of the world, we have a good advantage here so if it helps u guys focus on lynching scum in the next DP by eliminating me from the Poe I get it. U kind of have said as much 4 urself since ur also in the Poe so I assume u know what I mean here
In ur own words, why is shining scum?
role is scummy, and the justification doesn’t make sense plus it was cc’ed by casey. also being inactive is one thing but he has demonstrated he is not because he is posting here and there but not showing any signs of not being caught up. this is a big game, there’s been thousands of posts and he’s made less than almost anyone each day phase except maybe awesome. but even awesome has some kind of original takes. i keep asking him why we should townread him and he can’t answer it. his whole strategy is to stay undercover and keep his nose down each day phase and let town tear themselves apart. he will keep getting away with it over and over again if we don’t call him out on this.
So here is what I have against Banana. As my special ability, I can Jailkeep someone if the guild waived last night, which we did cause we’re not assholes like the Tiger guild.
I jailkept Banana. I confirmed with Mikal that it would prevent the NK.
Alright, so Banana's on the chopping block with Shining. Three possibilities:
1) Banana tried to do the NK
2) Banana was the target of the NK and your JK protected her
3) Someone else tried to NK you and Vader protected you
Yeah, my issue at present is still that Banana doesn't seem like a good NK target and it's unlikely scum would have tried to NK Pie.
Yeah, my issue at present is still that Banana doesn't seem like a good NK target and it's unlikely scum would have tried to NK Pie.
Thinking the same thing on Banana, can't see why she'd be a good target. The NK on Pie isn't impossible considering that scum already killed Luna who was also town confirmed, but they would have to have known that he'd be protected.
I disagree with this, Pie was also a good backup/wifom target with a claimed cop. A lot of people would assume the doc would protect the cop.
i mean that’s a good point tho, if they killed Luna why is it so out of the question they would kill pie?
I disagree with this, Pie was also a good backup/wifom target with a claimed cop. A lot of people would assume the doc would protect the cop.
Maybe so, though the decision to target the guild leader seems pretty... obvious after Luna got NK'd. If I recall correctly, Vader had basically outed himself as a protective role before Luna was killed, too.
