Periodic Table of Elements Mafia - DP1

Thoth wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Bro the day phase is over. Time limit ended. We almost didnt get a lynch off. literally rex hammered with two minutes remaining. Do better.

And you are whining now that you mislynched? You think that is preferable to no-lynching? Lmao do better

I didn't whine that I mislynched. I dont think we mislynched. Im still waiting on the flip.

*shift the wagon off

Hammer

Automated Vote Count

This vote count was generated by the mafia vote bot.

Magoroth (7/7): whiteflame (p#918), Mikal (p#871), Lunatic (p#725), Banana (p#745), Kohai (p#848), Shining (p#896), RexFavilla (p#928)

Casey_Risk (2/7): Bullish (p#865), Mag1cman (p#693)

Lunatic (1/7): Magoroth (p#888)

RexFavilla (1/7): Helz (p#222)

Helz (1/7): Thoth (p#577)

Not Voting (1): Casey_Risk

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day phase has ended.

⚠️ Magoroth has reached the lynch threshold. Hammer appears to be p#928.

Never did a deep dive but Helz’s approach at a glance seems more like townie who is obsessive and wrong than scum

i wanna stick to my theory that town was letting us run off a cliff

neither helz nor Thoth look scummy by that metric

Could lunatics late DP townier, ironically?

Casey

Bansna

lunatic

wf

high Poe no particular order

Mag1cman wrote:

Never did a deep dive but Helz’s approach at a glance seems more like townie who is obsessive and wrong than scum

I don’t think Helz has been scum on here, so no control group

Btw, I don’t blame Rex and shining for voting there. Better than vtnl

Sure, but in general it doesn’t seem scummy at first glance. Not at all

If Mago flips town I’m confident in saying 2/3 of the scum team is in that wagon, 3/3 if Casey town which I doubt

Lunatic wrote:

Thoth wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Bro the day phase is over. Time limit ended. We almost didnt get a lynch off. literally rex hammered with two minutes remaining. Do better.

And you are whining now that you mislynched? You think that is preferable to no-lynching? Lmao do better

I didn't whine that I mislynched. I dont think we mislynched. Im still waiting on the flip.

I still don’t understand WTF there is to debate. Pie literally posts alignment at the end of the day. There’s “nothing” to “think”, there’s 0 reason for me to lie. I’d get outed literally at the start of the night. Why keep pretending? Makes 0 sense

Mag1cman wrote:

Sure, but in general it doesn’t seem scummy at first glance. Not at all

Helz seems like a pretty good player. I would assume he has no trouble looking towny.

I guess you could pretend to be town to derail twilight discussion, at least. Not as useful as my act in Solo Leveling with no EoD alignment flips.

Magoroth wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Thoth wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Bro the day phase is over. Time limit ended. We almost didnt get a lynch off. literally rex hammered with two minutes remaining. Do better.

And you are whining now that you mislynched? You think that is preferable to no-lynching? Lmao do better

I didn't whine that I mislynched. I dont think we mislynched. Im still waiting on the flip.

I still don’t understand WTF there is to debate. Pie literally posts alignment at the end of the day. There’s “nothing” to “think”, there’s 0 reason for me to lie. I’d get outed literally at the start of the night. Why keep pretending? Makes 0 sense

Whats done is done. If you are town, we will have to make the most of your flip and information tomorrow.

I think how quickly that wagon on Magoroth got traction vs the wagon on Casey is noteworthy

Mag1cman wrote:

I think how quickly that wagon on Magoroth got traction vs the wagon on Casey is noteworthy

It wasnt quick at all. I had to pull teeth for that shit. And it probably wouldnt have happened if the day phase wasnt going to end in a no lynch otherwise.

Lunatic wrote:

Mag1cman wrote:

I think how quickly that wagon on Magoroth got traction vs the wagon on Casey is noteworthy

It wasnt quick at all. I had to pull teeth for that shit. And it probably wouldnt have happened if the day phase wasnt going to end in a no lynch otherwise.

If anything I am more sus of people not on the wagon trying to farm town cred.

meant to tag you not mago

Lunatic wrote:

No texting and driving! Real friends don’t let friends play mafia and drive

ISOing Lunatic and found this.

I second this.

If anything I am more sus of people not on the wagon trying to farm town cred. 

I’ve been towning Magoroth for the whole DP, fighting actions against him whenever I’m online. This is disingenuous

Mag1cman wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

No texting and driving! Real friends don’t let friends play mafia and drive

ISOing Lunatic and found this.

I second this.

Very anti-town tbh. Activity is pro-town.

RexFavilla wrote:

Mag1cman wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

No texting and driving! Real friends don’t let friends play mafia and drive

ISOing Lunatic and found this.

I second this.

Very anti-town tbh. Activity is pro-town.

😭 bruh Rex is the devil on Mikal’s shoulder while he’s driving

RexFavilla wrote:

Very anti-town tbh. Activity is pro-town.

Mikal out here tryna become an irl deadposter

The question on Lunatic is if he would switch the wagon away from Casey (assuming Casey is scum). He’s ballsy enough, but would he have good reason to think he can get away with it?

Mag1cman wrote:

The question on Lunatic is if he would switch the wagon away from Casey (assuming Casey is scum). He’s ballsy enough, but would he have good reason to think he can get away with it?

Being ballsy could be the reason.

Thoth wrote:

Mag1cman wrote:

The question on Lunatic is if he would switch the wagon away from Casey (assuming Casey is scum). He’s ballsy enough, but would he have good reason to think he can get away with it?

Being ballsy could be the reason.

nah. You could have some giant balls of steel, but if the move is just low iq,

even the ballsiest will avoid doing it

for example Wylted is the ballsiest player on this site. He has the balls to lynch himself if he thinks it would somehow help his faction in the long run. He got a bomb ability a few games ago and tried to use it, thinking worse case scenario his ability activates. If he had known his ability wouldn’t be activated, he wouldn’t have done it. Part of that was impulsiveness, but that speaks to my point. Even Wylted has his limits. And so does Lunatic.

So any scum case on Lunatic, from the PoV of someone who thinks Casey is scum (which I do) needs to provide a good reason why scum Lunatic would reasonably but not correctly think he could get away with it, from a scum incentives standpoint, not just “lunatic ballsy Kek”

Magoroth wrote:

Can you explain in what way you having a confirmed or near confirmed Town at, say, MyLo, assuming I lived that long, is worse than getting “information” from lynching said confirmed Town?

It also doesn’t help that this take isn’t really game related. Pretty scummy to talk about tactics and strategy ngl

Town doesn't win by not lynching town. They can not lynch town all game and still lose. They win by lynching scum. They accurately lynch scum by developing accurate reads. They develop accurate reads through results and behavioral analysis - the biggest facet of behavioral analysis is that scum want to lynch town and not lynch scum. So if you lynch, even if the lynch is town, scum will act in a way which is revealing in hindsight. If you puss out and quail away from lynches scum can just hide in endlessly refracting wifom and win the game easily.

Mag1cman wrote:

The question on Lunatic is if he would switch the wagon away from Casey (assuming Casey is scum). He’s ballsy enough, but would he have good reason to think he can get away with it?

Im the guy known for bussing almost every time im scum lol

Mag1cman wrote:

If anything I am more sus of people not on the wagon trying to farm town cred. 

I’ve been towning Magoroth for the whole DP, fighting actions against him whenever I’m online. This is disingenuous

Yeah but it never really made sense why, your explanations never added up. If he is town the entire read looks dis-ingenuous. Your whole thing was that Activity = town was actually NAI. I can see town reading him from ignorance as you werent in some major mago games where he was extremely townie. But even mago admits he was playing differently, multiple times. So if he flips town, your reading him town doesn't do much for me.