I went into this game thinking I probably wouldn't be able to keep up. Didn't expect us to be at a very thin 4 pages by the end of day two. Jeez.
Mikal - Sus pile. Says his character is a Jew and that part of his role will sound really scummy, but mum on the deets. The wagon on Pie definitely feels like it could be scum!Mikal opportunism. Trying to get him lynched on the off chance there's an extra kill tonight? Eh. Regardless of the role he's given, Pie is a strong town player, and wanting to get rid of him early because of a low-probability variable is hard to rationalize from a town perspective. I'd like more people to weigh in on whether Hateds usually disable at MYLO/LYLO in their experience, so I can gauge the credibility of his claim that he's played few games where they did.
Pie - Despite Mikal's speculation that it's a convenient scum claim I think I'm still townpiling Pie for now. I have his full claim, which is more than I have for anyone else. Also I feel like scum!Pie more often keeps his claim to his chest as long as possible. I'm coming up blank when I try to think of a game where he was scum and fake claimed immediately, though that doesn't mean he never has.
Kohai - Null. Jumped on the Pie wagon a bit fast, I suppose.
whiteflame - Null. Measured and neutral as always. Hesitates to jump on the #SacrificePie! movement, but he'd do that as either alignment.
wylted - I don't know what to make of his bullshit about my left titty joke or whether he even is Candace Owens. I feel like there's no way he didn't get that I was joking, or at least I would have said so before Thoth and Kohai and Pie seemed to entertain the notion that I might not be joking.
Lunatic - Not enough to go off of. I want to town pile him because I feel like a sense of obligation to his scummate would have led him to post more than this if he was scum, but maybe he's just too busy.
Thoth - Nothing to go off of except casting some doubts about my Pie townlean. I know he's been inactive as scum before, so the above Lunatic reasoning doesn't apply.
Vader - Even nothinger to go off of. Don't even know his scum game.