Originally Posted by wylted on 10/24/2026 at 3:43 PM (post #31)
Let's hear it
I think it will do more harm than good until more info comes out
Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.
Originally Posted by wylted on 24/10/2026 at 22:46 (post #32)
Why in the hell would we mass claim?
It's dumb
Although since mago called for one he should claim.
Anyways let's press banana. If mago is going to push for one I am cool getting him to start it. We can popcorn it if there is enough support but the guy openly asking for it to be done 9/10 is scum hunting for something or someone specific.
Nah, I won’t claim.
I will shoot any who doesn’t tho
Aamirus, have you been Hitler recently?
- Kenny, 2019 (actual Mafia quote)
Ok the last is (/s). I haven’t yet decided if a mass claim is something we should do.
I just think, with how weird our roles are, I think it will be hard for scum to even know what questions to ask.
Aamirus, have you been Hitler recently?
- Kenny, 2019 (actual Mafia quote)
Where you at
Aamirus, have you been Hitler recently?
- Kenny, 2019 (actual Mafia quote)
@Ref
Aamirus, have you been Hitler recently?
- Kenny, 2019 (actual Mafia quote)
Well… not much has happened I guess. Banana and REF haven’t posted yet and Luna’s not back, so we’re almost half gone. I’ll admit, I’m just exhausted today and it’s sapping my investment, so I might not post much tonight. We’ll see.
Yeah bit of busy weekend. Strange kill. Mass claim sounds retarded. WF is town. I think if Mago is scum then Luna (Kohai) is town as his bizarrely impassioned defense is a bit much and seems almost like inside knowledge. Vig is also a textbook scum fakeclaim.
Luna, who were you scum reading last DP? Figure it's easier to just ask you rather than doing an iso.
"Human kind cannot bear very much reality."
T. S. Eliot
Yeah... I can't focus. I'll put time into this tomorrow, but I'm flagging fast. Good to see REF posting, I'll leave off here.
Originally Posted by wylted on 10/24/2026 at 11:41 PM (post #46)
Do you think bananas change of heart is at all suspicious.
Absent most of dp1 until we try to get a lynch going near the end. Comes on to say she town reads Kohai.
As time is about to expire makes a lame excuse that we must lynch with odd players. Not exactly a fact banana would ever care about and then hammers?
I would say if banana is scum it clears Kohai/lunatic2 and it's a strong possibility here.
I'd say it's more likely Magoroth is scum than Banana. Checking in at the end of the DP and seeing your vote is needed to push a lynch through isn't necessarily suspicious. I do that all the time cause I hate no lynches on principle; I've hammered players I've townread before because I think getting into a no-lynch slump is deadly for town. Besides if Kohai is innocent it's not like he's a hard mislynch, she could easily have convinced me for instance to hammer him and I was logging on to do just that - hammer if needed, no matter who it was. Magoroth on the other hand was hard defending Kohai in a way that made little sense to me - literally nothing in his behavior screamed town. And now he seems to want to lead town over having 'called it correctly' - that seems way more like scum leveraging inside knowledge. So if Mago is scum all his behavior makes sense and it would also confirm Kohai as town, as there was no way he could know the governor would come into play and so it couldn't possibly be a distancing gambit between scum/scum. If he's town he's just acting bizarre and scummy, which tbf is kind of his meta, and Kohai's affiliation remains up in the air. At least that's where my brain is right now. Could Banana be scum? Yeah my town read on her is pretty weak. But I think the events of last DP make Mago look way worse. But I have also been busy all day and am just going off of memory, will have to reread tomorrow night.
"Human kind cannot bear very much reality."
T. S. Eliot
Originally Posted by wylted on 10/24/2026 at 5:36 PM (post #34)
It's Saturday wtf are you guys doing
Is this a jab at us for being too active or not active enough?
Forum signatures are bullshit. Nobody wants to waste their time and bandwidth reading something they have read 29,998,559,671,349 times before.
Originally Posted by RexFavilla on 25/10/2026 at 4:51 (post #47)
Originally Posted by wylted on 10/24/2026 at 11:41 PM (post #46)
Do you think bananas change of heart is at all suspicious.
Absent most of dp1 until we try to get a lynch going near the end. Comes on to say she town reads Kohai.
As time is about to expire makes a lame excuse that we must lynch with odd players. Not exactly a fact banana would ever care about and then hammers?
I would say if banana is scum it clears Kohai/lunatic2 and it's a strong possibility here.
I'd say it's more likely Magoroth is scum than Banana. Checking in at the end of the DP and seeing your vote is needed to push a lynch through isn't necessarily suspicious. I do that all the time cause I hate no lynches on principle; I've hammered players I've townread before because I think getting into a no-lynch slump is deadly for town. Besides if Kohai is innocent it's not like he's a hard mislynch, she could easily have convinced me for instance to hammer him and I was logging on to do just that - hammer if needed, no matter who it was. Magoroth on the other hand was hard defending Kohai in a way that made little sense to me - literally nothing in his behavior screamed town. And now he seems to want to lead town over having 'called it correctly' - that seems way more like scum leveraging inside knowledge. So if Mago is scum all his behavior makes sense and it would also confirm Kohai as town, as there was no way he could know the governor would come into play and so it couldn't possibly be a distancing gambit between scum/scum. If he's town he's just acting bizarre and scummy, which tbf is kind of his meta, and Kohai's affiliation remains up in the air. At least that's where my brain is right now. Could Banana be scum? Yeah my town read on her is pretty weak. But I think the events of last DP make Mago look way worse. But I have also been busy all day and am just going off of memory, will have to reread tomorrow night.
I did not defend Kohai. I literally logged on to see the vote move off of Noah to Kohai, who nobody really scumread and wasn’t even thought of as a serious lynnch target when I was awake. I have yet to see how any of Kohai’s behaviour screams scum, either prior or to after he became the top vote. It literally looks like normal Kohai to me lol
Aamirus, have you been Hitler recently?
- Kenny, 2019 (actual Mafia quote)
Originally Posted by wylted on 25/10/2026 at 5:31 (post #48)
Your logic is pretty solid, despite you being a bit dismissive of my reasonings of banana. I agree that Kohai should have been hammered by somebody and they shouldn't be punished for it based merely on it being a hammer, even with little justification
UNVOTE VTL MAGO
I honestly think you are town and being bull-headed rn. Like the comeback and “you were useless last day” doesn’t seem like a scummy thing to say, it’s from a town perspective even if I heavily disagree with what you’re doing lol
Aamirus, have you been Hitler recently?
- Kenny, 2019 (actual Mafia quote)
I agree Banana needs pressure. Inb4 me voting her makes people not wanna vote her because you won’t follow scum or some shit.
VTL Banana
@Wylted if you wanna look at someone who reason to be scum, I did in fact express surprise/extreme discontent at Kohai being the Lynch. You are right I had no reason to town read him, but I had no reason to scumread him either. Kohai for me is a player that is hard to read either way, his alignment takes a while to gauge. Banana’s response to Kohai being the Lynch was more subdued than mine, scum have to temper their disagreement lest they be seen as scummy and Banana is pretty good at scum, she is hard to read and plays her Town meta quite well so I could see her doing this.
This is not to say she has to be scum, but could be a valid direction in which to investigate since I think you are Town. I was town reading Rex last night too but idk how much stock to put into that. If I’m being honest I don’t really have much of a read on most of the people who are alive which is kinda scary.
Aamirus, have you been Hitler recently?
- Kenny, 2019 (actual Mafia quote)
I agree scum Governor seems OP, I just wonder if it could be a different mechanic in play. Whiteflame’s reasoning and his action makes sense, Noah was widely scumread and him overturning the lynch onto Noah is valid, but I’m slightly uneasy at town reading a player merely because their role would be OP for scum.
Aamirus, have you been Hitler recently?
- Kenny, 2019 (actual Mafia quote)
Originally Posted by Thoth on 24/10/2026 at 21:14 (post #27)
Originally Posted by Magoroth on 10/24/2026 at 1:40 PM (post #22)
We could do a mass claim. With the amount of bizarre roles we have in play it may actually be hard for scum to come up with reasonable role claims.
My role is not one I have seen on here, or at least not under this name, but calling them bizarre is rich coming from a guy who played with this:
You have near unlimited control over your environment. These insects have no idea what they truly are, you have an infinite advantage.
Each night, you may create a new mechanic. It may be from the list I provided, or you can make up your own! I will have to approve it however.
You can choose to remove any of these mechanics during the night as well.
Upon being lynched for the first time, the lynch fails. And instead lynches the last person to vote for you.
You cannot die at night by any means. (Hidden Information: you may still die from being launched into the Sun).
You are immune to disruption, and roleblock.
You receive additional information at game start.
That’s fair xD.
Aamirus, have you been Hitler recently?
- Kenny, 2019 (actual Mafia quote)
Originally Posted by RexFavilla on 10/24/2026 at 9:16 PM (post #43)
Yeah bit of busy weekend. Strange kill. Mass claim sounds retarded. WF is town. I think if Mago is scum then Luna (Kohai) is town as his bizarrely impassioned defense is a bit much and seems almost like inside knowledge. Vig is also a textbook scum fakeclaim.
Luna, who were you scum reading last DP? Figure it's easier to just ask you rather than doing an iso.
I would say bananas hammer then trying to play up the guilt was a little scummy to me. She looked like she was trying to garner town cred and hammed it up a little too much for my liking.
In loving Memory of Lannan and Ajab, fallen debaters.
Banana is at L-2 please be careful with who you vote
Aamirus, have you been Hitler recently?
- Kenny, 2019 (actual Mafia quote)
