State Attorneys General Mafia DP2

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 10/25/2026 at 10:10 AM (post #78)

Btw @Ref why are you saying it’s my meta to act scummy? You haven’t played with me in a while so how can you know this is still true?

Because I've wanted to lynch you in literally every game I've ever played as far as I can recall. You and Kohai both have that effect on me - you just always come off as scummy to me.

The fact that Mago, Kohai, Noah, and Banana have all been the big lynch discussion targets does make me think that the scum team might be experienced players who are just sniping off the easier players.

Luna kill points to that too - either points to extreme caution or a fear kill.

I'll be able to reread a bit more tomorrow during my commute but that's where I'm at right now.

I’m just wondering if WF could be scum Governor with some crazy modifier like “You are only allowed to target Town"

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 10/25/2026 at 8:15 PM (post #96)

I’m just wondering if WF could be scum Governor with some crazy modifier like “You are only allowed to target Town"

If you want to believe something absurd like that is possible, that’s up to you. That would start to get into bastard modding territory from where I’m sitting, but I get the paranoia.

Anyway, I know I’ve been absent for a bit here, don’t plan to keep that up. I’ll catch up on what I’ve missed shortly.

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 10/25/2026 at 4:47 PM (post #86)

I was trying to provoke a reaction because this game is so damn dead ;/ I am happy Luna replaced in but sad Kohai died, they both drive activity. Luna has been inactive thus far but that’s unusual for him and I assume he’s just not feeling it.

I’m gonna claim. My role is useless. Or almost useless. I have the insane ability to steal someone’s vote at night, and use it anonymously, Vote Thief. Sounds great but it doesn’t work at MyLo.

There are a lot of mechanics this game that deal with votes.

Yeah… that’s concerning. It’s a role you could use to confirm yourself, though Vote Thief is generally more common for scum. They’d be more likely to keep that hidden, though, so that’s at least something in your favor.

Have you used it yet?

Originally Posted by RexFavilla on 10/25/2026 at 7:37 PM (post #93)

The fact that Mago, Kohai, Noah, and Banana have all been the big lynch discussion targets does make me think that the scum team might be experienced players who are just sniping off the easier players.

Originally Posted by RexFavilla on 10/25/2026 at 7:38 PM (post #94)

Luna kill points to that too - either points to extreme caution or a fear kill.

The Luna kill is just confusing. Maybe because he was quiet, they thought he was hiding something? Luna was null to basically everyone last DP and dude would not have been in a great position this DP beyond proving his role.

I don’t get how that list makes the scum team experienced. Scum could be in that pool, being a big lynch discussion target doesn’t make them town. Noah is confirmed and Kohai (Luna 2.0) basically is from where I’m sitting, but Mago and Banana sure aren’t.

Originally Posted by whiteflame on 26/10/2026 at 2:09 (post #98)

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 10/25/2026 at 4:47 PM (post #86)

I was trying to provoke a reaction because this game is so damn dead ;/ I am happy Luna replaced in but sad Kohai died, they both drive activity. Luna has been inactive thus far but that’s unusual for him and I assume he’s just not feeling it.

I’m gonna claim. My role is useless. Or almost useless. I have the insane ability to steal someone’s vote at night, and use it anonymously, Vote Thief. Sounds great but it doesn’t work at MyLo.

There are a lot of mechanics this game that deal with votes.

Yeah… that’s concerning. It’s a role you could use to confirm yourself, though Vote Thief is generally more common for scum. They’d be more likely to keep that hidden, though, so that’s at least something in your favor.

Have you used it yet?

I have not. I considered using it on Wylted, quite seriously, but decided that on the off-chance he is scum I want to see how he votes

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 10/25/2026 at 9:14 PM (post #100)

Originally Posted by whiteflame on 26/10/2026 at 2:09 (post #98)

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 10/25/2026 at 4:47 PM (post #86)

I was trying to provoke a reaction because this game is so damn dead ;/ I am happy Luna replaced in but sad Kohai died, they both drive activity. Luna has been inactive thus far but that’s unusual for him and I assume he’s just not feeling it.

I’m gonna claim. My role is useless. Or almost useless. I have the insane ability to steal someone’s vote at night, and use it anonymously, Vote Thief. Sounds great but it doesn’t work at MyLo.

There are a lot of mechanics this game that deal with votes.

Yeah… that’s concerning. It’s a role you could use to confirm yourself, though Vote Thief is generally more common for scum. They’d be more likely to keep that hidden, though, so that’s at least something in your favor.

Have you used it yet?

I have not. I considered using it on Wylted, quite seriously, but decided that on the off-chance he is scum I want to see how he votes

Alright. I’m asking more out of curiosity than anything. Regardless of your affiliation, I don’t think you’d claim it if you didn’t have the role.

Banana is really pinging me. It's wierd seeing her on pure defense, not really pushing the day phase, her answers seem all over the place, her claim is weak, I think I want a full claim from her.

vtl banana

Official Vote Count:

Banana (2/4) - Wylted, Lunatic

I don't have a problem seeking Banana's claim here. Thoth has said that he has pertinent information should enough people claim, and I'm expecting him to provide it soon. Apart from that, let's hold off on further claims.

Originally Posted by whiteflame on 26/10/2026 at 3:53 (post #104)

I don't have a problem seeking Banana's claim here. Thoth has said that he has pertinent information should enough people claim, and I'm expecting him to provide it soon. Apart from that, let's hold off on further claims.

I don’t either.

Originally Posted by whiteflame on 26/10/2026 at 3:53 (post #104)

I don't have a problem seeking Banana's claim here. Thoth has said that he has pertinent information should enough people claim, and I'm expecting him to provide it soon. Apart from that, let's hold off on further claims.

The worst part thing, I completely believe Banana when she claims she didn’t know about Noah being scumread for being a Democrat. I just dont think it’s alignment indicative.

Also, if Banana is Town Wylted is Scum nearly 100%.

I rescind my town read of wylted, I have no idea why I townread him.

Unrelated but, y’all said you scumread me every game? I take this to be some kind of an insult, and to this I say, SKILL ISSUE @Rex

Originally Posted by wylted on 10/25/2026 at 4:44 PM (post #91)

Everyone has chined in essentially. Can you provide the information now?

Let me read up and then I will think about it

Originally Posted by Thoth on 26/10/2026 at 6:07 (post #107)

Originally Posted by wylted on 10/25/2026 at 4:44 PM (post #91)

Everyone has chined in essentially. Can you provide the information now?

Let me read up and then I will think about it

A few hours later

Originally Posted by Lunatic on 10/25/2026 at 7:47 PM (post #102)

Banana is really pinging me. It's wierd seeing her on pure defense, not really pushing the day phase, her answers seem all over the place, her claim is weak, I think I want a full claim from her.

vtl banana

kind of hypocritical to say im on defense u barely even post this whole game. how is my claim weak, u havent even claimed either. im not gonna claim unless u give me a good reason to, and i already char claimed

Originally Posted by wylted on 26/10/2026 at 11:51 (post #110)

You need to role claim. Nobody is going to wait 24 hours to hear your response after you are out at L1 given your frequency of posting

You are at L2 right now

Why don’t we make you claim?

VTL Wylted

Banana wanna follow me on Wylted? He d esperately wants other people to claim and is “threatening” people for not claiming, how about we hear his claim.

Just reread DP1 and the Banana wagon seems sus to me now. Everyone should reread especially the last few pages. People are saying she's sus for being apologetic about the lynch/hammer when it's literally in response to Kohai talking about how he's going to kill himself irl if he gets lynched. It's not an 'oh I feel bad if you're town' deal.

Banana, just claim so we can move on.

Originally Posted by wylted on 26/10/2026 at 12:37 (post #114)

Why don’t we make you claim?

That's not really up to me if people make me claim. That's on them.

What a cop-out, same way you make people claim under threat it can be done to you. So why don’t you claim?

Originally Posted by wylted on 26/10/2026 at 12:38 (post #115)

Banana wanna follow me on Wylted? He d esperately wants other people to claim and is “threatening” people for not claiming, how about we hear his claim.0 Like

Why are you trying to coordinate actions with somebody who is likely to be scum?

What makes you likely Town?

Also I don’t think Banana is likely scum. There simply isn’t enough information to be certain of *anyone’s* alignment this game.