Jim Carrey Mafia Dp3

Originally Posted by Banana on 10/11/2026 at 3:03 (post #115)

VTL: Magoroth

if I’m wrong I’m sorry guys but out of Wylted and mago I have more problems with mago. i don’t like that he tried to pass his activity issues off as trying to blend in, after his initial plan wasn’t to even claim soldier so it was a wierd strategy. his early lack of participation was sus and he only got active after getting in the hot seat for it. i also don’t like him passing the blame for wylteds hammer when he was voting wryly as well, and just as culpable. i just haven’t felt right about mago this game idk. if im wrong i guess we lose.

we can figure out helz tomorrow

Banana voting me what a surprise. Considering her claim is iffy as fuck I’m not surprised one bit.

@Rex vote Wylted or Banana if I die today and somehow. the game doesn’t end.

Automated Vote Count

This system-generated vote count was posted on behalf of the main host.

Magoroth (2/3): wylted (p#19), Banana (p#115)

Not Voting (3): Magoroth, RexFavilla, Helz

With 5 players alive, the base elimination threshold is 3. Configured role modifiers may change vote power or an individual player's threshold. Day phase ends in 2 days, 15 hours.
Day phase ends: (your local time).

Holy fucking mafia drama. Jesus Christ calm the fuck down guys

I guess we can all say Mag and Wylted are not WvW and snicker at that fact.

I am not going to vote for now. Wylted going full crash out melt down mode over their meta expectation of a role is pretty silly to me. I also think we should sit down and have a calm discussion of the other issues I raised about the mech positioning of role claims and the issue of Banana's potential TMI instead of hammering without conversation for yet another day.

Lets slow the fuck down and talk about things. The emotional hostility is making me uncomfortable at this point and its totally unnecessary. Its a fucking game. Lets play and enjoy the intellectual journey together.

Anyways. Will be around for another hour or so. If someone wants a total unfiltered response from me I was fed drinks in that meeting and I am comfortable explaining absolutely anything off the top of my head.

I very much think that the worst thing we can do is quick hammer. Very obviously there is a TvW between those two and if we choose wrong the game is over but lets not rush anything.

And again lets please dig back in the thread. Its a dead game with minimal posts. Digging is so fucking easy. Its absurd that even a fact like Banana claiming I was scum read by Pie D2 was not even called out.

Can we just calm down and start unpacking and looking at facts please? Calm examination of exactly what is claimed and what has been said is the path forward

Originally Posted by RexFavilla on 11/9/2026 at 8:35 PM (post #120)

Do not vote right off the bat, talk to me first and discuss things a bit.

Yeah, I will have time tommorow. I am unhappy with how this day phase has gone and very much intend to hold off and talk.

Wylted's screaming for action right now looks pretty scummy to me. As does their assertion that a PGO has to be compulsive and unlimited. That stuff is OP as fuck and I have only really seen in mashes on places like 2p2

To be constructive I would like to hear Mags reads. I also want to hear Wylteds thoughts on Banana that I outlined as well as Bananas response to the position they took.

I would like to understand what Rex is seeing.

But whoever wins and looses can we please chill the fuck out? This type of hostility is very unnecessary and I want to enjoy experiences with people. Not feel like I am getting called a retard when I have probably played more games of Mafia than every player in this entire lobby combined. Really, even if you beat me this game that kind of stuff is not appreciated. I think scum has revealed their hand and wants to rush a hammer to prevent conversation but its something I hope we can calmly discuss without insulting etchother as Rex and I talk things out. I would also like to see civil participation from other players and engaging in the issues raised.

I will chew on the interaction and how people put in votes but man.. This was one nasty day phase.

But whoever wins and looses can we please chill the fuck out? This type of hostility is very unnecessary and I want to enjoy experiences with people. Not feel like I am getting called a retard when I have probably played more games of Mafia than every player in this entire lobby combined.

wylted is jus a lil amped up right now, ignore him

Automated Vote Count

This system-generated vote count was posted on behalf of the main host.

Magoroth (2/3): wylted (p#19), Banana (p#115)

Not Voting (3): Magoroth, RexFavilla, Helz

With 5 players alive, the base elimination threshold is 3. Configured role modifiers may change vote power or an individual player's threshold. Day phase ends in 2 days, 12 hours.
Day phase ends: (your local time).

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 11/9/2026 at 7:46 PM (post #123)

Originally Posted by Banana on 10/11/2026 at 3:03 (post #115)

VTL: Magoroth

if I’m wrong I’m sorry guys but out of Wylted and mago I have more problems with mago. i don’t like that he tried to pass his activity issues off as trying to blend in, after his initial plan wasn’t to even claim soldier so it was a wierd strategy. his early lack of participation was sus and he only got active after getting in the hot seat for it. i also don’t like him passing the blame for wylteds hammer when he was voting wryly as well, and just as culpable. i just haven’t felt right about mago this game idk. if im wrong i guess we lose.

we can figure out helz tomorrow

Banana voting me what a surprise. Considering her claim is iffy as fuck I’m not surprised one bit.

@Rex vote Wylted or Banana if I die today and somehow. the game doesn’t end.

pot calling kettle black, vanilla is way less scummy than ur role

Scum pairings analysis

Wylted/Banana - possible

Wylted/Helz - impossible (Helz would lynch)

Wylted/Magoroth - possible

Banana/Helz - impossible (Helz would lynch)

Banana/Magoroth - possible

Magoroth/Helz - possible

From a neutral perspective:

Magoroth/Me - possible

Banana/Me - impossible (would have lynched Magoroth or Wylted)

Helz/Me - impossible (would have lynched Magoroth or Wylted)

so overall possible scum pairings from a neutral perspective are:

Magoroth/Me

Helz/Magoroth

Banana/Magoroth

Wylted/Magoroth

Wylted/Banana

Will reread later And expore all these options, specifically the Wylted/Banana one which is the only instance in which Magoroth is innocent.

Originally Posted by Banana on 10/11/2026 at 13:10 (post #137)

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 11/9/2026 at 7:46 PM (post #123)

Originally Posted by Banana on 10/11/2026 at 3:03 (post #115)

VTL: Magoroth

if I’m wrong I’m sorry guys but out of Wylted and mago I have more problems with mago. i don’t like that he tried to pass his activity issues off as trying to blend in, after his initial plan wasn’t to even claim soldier so it was a wierd strategy. his early lack of participation was sus and he only got active after getting in the hot seat for it. i also don’t like him passing the blame for wylteds hammer when he was voting wryly as well, and just as culpable. i just haven’t felt right about mago this game idk. if im wrong i guess we lose.

we can figure out helz tomorrow

Banana voting me what a surprise. Considering her claim is iffy as fuck I’m not surprised one bit.

@Rex vote Wylted or Banana if I die today and somehow. the game doesn’t end.

pot calling kettle black, vanilla is way less scummy than ur role

Soldier is less scummy than literally the only Vanilla claim in this game what are you on about

VTL: wylted

Since apparently my first vote wasn’t counted

@RexFavilla it should be extremely obvious to you there are only two teams possible if you are Town, either Helz/Magoroth or Banana/Wylted. I hard claim that I think Helz is Town here because I think he would put in more effort into claiming if he was scum, and someone would’ve told him PGO is a passive role and not an active one. So it is pretty clear to me the scum team is Wylted/Banana, you would’ve hammered if you were scum by now. Literally the game is in your hands. If Helz or you are dumbasses and vote me then it’s GG.

Originally Posted by wylted on 10/11/2026 at 13:34 (post #140)

you better hope it's not banana mago because I am not entertaining any discussion next dP. I am not even posting other than to call anyone still trying to figure out the game dumb. my first post will just be helz

I won’t even entertain any discussion today other than to discredit the discreditors - first Banana, then you.

Originally Posted by wylted on 10/11/2026 at 12:54 (post #136)

helz I don't for one second think you are town and refusing to hammer here is basically game throwing because anyone who is town other than rex would hammer here instantly. so it's a confession..

are you really going into the next LYLO situation and explaining that you thought Mago was town and wasn't on the lynch because wylted was skeptical of your role?

you are going to be asked about why you delayed or refused to participate in this lynch.

you realize that blaming my reads or claiming banana has too much inside information is not going to come across as a very good reason for why you are protecting mago right?

wah wah cry harder

I can not think of a world where Wylted is not scum. I get them having some super insane dedication to a site meta of a role. The confidence they are voicing is very off and its even more troubling that they are shoving people over and over to vote right now like they do not want people to sit down and talk about the game.

Their avoidance of my point on banana is also of note. Just flatly saying "Its not worth talking about" and utterly ignoring that at no point D2 did Pie suspect me at all. They only had 1 take that disagreed with me as they flatly said they did not think it was scummy. The extent they defended me very much made me assume they had checked me.

It really looks like a S! Banana and S! Wylted came up with a plan N2 and screwed up the order of it. Banana made points that were not possible without Wylteds claim first which is easy to see just looking at Pie's ISO. Now when its called out we have Wylted shoving everyone to speed vote and just ignore that. Not a good look. I would have expected any arrangement of TvW or TvT between Wylted and Banana to have a different reaction by Wylted.

That D2 hammer also looked bad for Wylted. Totally unnecessary.

Going back through the game this post from Pie is also of note-

Vibes based reads based on flow of what I’ve read (still depressed)

WF and REF are lean town.

Wylted, Mago, Helz are null

Wryly and Banana are tilt scum

Thoth is lean scum

Im going to take some time to go through everyone more but will be around. I am not sure if I will be voting outside of Wryly. Their position on me is just wrong, their constantly shoving people to vote right now and shutting down D2 before we could talk is awful, and their behavior on Banana is either TMI as a wolf or protecting their partner.

If they are not paired with Banana it gets interesting. A Rex pair does not make sense given Rex did not hammer Mag. And a Mag pair would mean its another wild ass bus situation but their interaction in the thread did not look at all like a puppet show. They looked genuinely pissed off at etchother to the point I have trouble seeing it.

Originally Posted by wylted on 11/10/2026 at 9:47 AM (post #146)

bro just self hammer. you were already caught and rex admitted it was 80% to be you. I think as scum I have more honor because I would just self hammer here

If your going to be active in the thread can you actually do something instead of just shoving everyone to vote right now? Everyone understands your ridiculous point. Nevermind that it would be self shading for me to even claim non-compulsive in that situation which does not make sense but if all your going to do is scream at people to end the game right now can you please do it into your pillow instead of on the thread? I would like to actually play the game and analyze the thread. I know looking back into prior days is not a big thing on this site but this is a small game and it does not even take that long right now.

Looks like I screwed up the quote function. But that was me quoting Pie's D1 #203. I feel its of note for 2 reasons-

1- They would be inclined to check their scum reads. So it is possible for them to have checked either Pie or Wylted in which case I am just wrong given they would have revealed with a red check immediately.

2- It also is of note going into D2 for Bananas point. Going all the way through Pie they never really pushed me this game. The assumption that Pie scum read me could not even be traced to anything in D1. This means the absolute only thing that suggests Pie suspected me is Wylteds check and is of note.

I get that I am tunneling a bit on that specific point potentially being TMI but I really do think a T! Wylted would have interest to look back and consider at the very least. While I keep re examining Banana just about every potential I see has Wylted as scum.

Magoroth/Me

Well I know this one isn't true and I think making I'm-not-scum cases for yourself when nobody is considering lynching you to be a waste of time plus I don't have too much time so I'll forgo this.

Helz/Magoroth

This is one of the main possibilities I've entertained. The claim is just sooooo bad and Magoroth hurriedly defending it just smacks so much as scum defending scum because you'd think in a town player from a neutral perspective would be at least a little bit skeptical. However I think his behavior indicts him more than it indicts Helz, as it could also be an instance of Magoroth desperately pandering to a town player stuck with a shitty claim on whose vote his fate depends.

In DP2 Magoroth jumped on the reaction test of me, which he could do as town but would be motivated to do as scum. He also floated a Wryly/Helz scum team while pursuing a lynch of Wryly, which if Helz was his scum partner could set him up to do an about-face once Wryly flipped town. Was also scumrading Pie. If his partner was Banana or Wylted it was an odd choice to not scum read either of them.

Banana/Magoroth

In this world Banana is choosing to bus Magoroth over pulling to lynch Wylted. I see this as an odd choice, as I feel up until that point Wylted's behavior was much more objectively scummy and I was more open to lynching him. I feel like by voting for Wylted, Banana could have easily secured my vote for him at that point in the game. I'm going to discount this one pretty much entirely.

Wylted/Magoroth

I think this is a long shot but not impossible. If they had rolecopped Wryly and Wylted's retarded hammer was a gambit, this DP could have been a set-up bus opening with setting up a 1v1 with Magoroth, and therefore letting Magoroth float to the endgame or Wylted no matter which dies. You remove the last protective, (as another had already flipped), ensuring that your NKs will go off unopposed, and sacrifice one scum to make it very unlikely for the other to be lynched the next DP. As the DP went on and Banana weighed in on the side of lynching Magoroth, Magoroth's mind-boggling defense of Helz's claim could be an attempt to indict him in the final DP. I that case they would be killing either me or Banana tonight, whichever one was most likely to lynch the surviving scum.

Seeing as we are lynching between Magoroth and Wylted today I will make a whole post for Banana/Wylted after doing some more rereading.