1990s-2000s Nostalgia Mafia (Endgame)

Win con has always been something that we can discuss as it’s usually distributed to everyone. I can’t think of a time when this wasn’t allowed on here and I’ve been playing since ddo. None of that is confirmable. Him typing about it is confirmable and that’s a him issue. Along with responding to Luna. You let talk like that go on and don’t touch it. Even I was second guessing Thoth 

Yes I agree. I wouldn’t have cared if he had kept his mouth shut and answered about scum receiving the town wincon or not, but he never answered my question publically

if anything it’s a reaction test. If that is not allowed. You should clearly state it or just kill me for starting it.

I agree. But keep in mind Max was also mod confirmed because of the whole day faction thing. That was also unfair imo.

balancing that by giving you guys an extra kill is retarted. Period. 

I would’ve just redone the game imo. Otherwise one side would’ve been unduly harmed.

it’s like he goofed and it just tanked the game and punished town for his mistake. I knew singning up for this that it was going to be goofy but just changing how the game works mid game to compensate for a mistake is next level bastard

im Harry Potter

perma vanilla. 

Based.

I also think the whole anti claim stuff is bullshit in general. If you want to punish town for claiming, give scum actual roles to counter them instead of relying on some arbitrary anti claim. Or just give fake claims to scum. Anti claim just adds an unnecessary feature imo

Ya I think that’s all largely shit I started . Him confirming max in the op is a him issue. Him typing is a him issue, him confirming Luna is a him issue. I get starting as a new mod it’s tough but effectively just making it so we have no shot at winning to counter balance that is just more poor choices on top of it. I think me engaging in angling is whatever. I do it all the time and no one responds or really listens. It’s him confirming it that made it bad.

but literally at mylo all of town would have been perma vanilla if it went through cus everyone had to claim. And the extra kill just just sets us at mylo off the rip.

mistakes happen but you don’t respond to mistakes by making it nearly impossible for a faction to win. He also just changed hoe role blocking works because he thought my role should not know if I was roleblocked.

meh. Everytime I type about it I just get more pissed. I never give a fuck about results but this just felt like it was largely not winnable because of mistakes he made and over compensation

Tbf you guys played it perfect. With my result on awesome that invalidated wf it was all but over. Never would have guesses all that fuckery happen. All pie had to do was say inno child cus he’s been softing in and the extra kill made it safe cus no dp3

You guys should just start policy lynching him every time he claims it. What are the chances he actually even gets randomly assigned that role as town?

I also think the whole anti claim stuff is bullshit in general. If you want to punish town for claiming, give scum actual roles to counter them instead of relying on some arbitrary anti claim. Or just give fake claims to scum. Anti claim just adds an unnecessary feature imo

This is actual sort of what I'm doing in my next game. Anticlaim is more baked into the theme, roles, and mechanics.

It was a fair claim. Would have been more interesting if it went to dp3 and 4 people didn’t die after the first day

also excited for yours and praying theme is a big part in it.

To clarify I’m not an actually mad. I’m football mad. It’s like I went to play poker and someone rigged the deck. Dealers fault not the players but Christ I needed to vent cus it’s dumb

Now you know how I felt last game lol

yeah

granted yours was a bad decision. This was just bastard modding but it is what it is.

ready for my jrp game

Both bad decisions was my point lol

Fair

Aside from scum's nasty anti-claim mechanic, which was what I guessed it was except that I figured it could likely only target one person per night, my ability was something of a town anti-claim mechanic, hence why I suggested the possibility in day 1.

I love the intelligent exchanges we have on here.

I love the intelligent exchanges we have on here.

V vf fhcre vagryyvtrag naq abg n ovt qhzo qhzo

My head is too square to be oblong.