Amber Endgame

I did it fine for many comments, had a doc set up to auto replace the periods. But then I got too heated with arguing with Brand that I forgot to hit the button. So all 3 of you had a hand in my death.

We specifically chose Bullish for this because we noticed he frequently left sentences off without a period.

Bullish wrote:

I did it fine for many comments, had a doc set up to auto replace the periods. But then I got too heated with arguing with Brand that I forgot to hit the button. So all 3 of you had a hand in my death.

Haha. I knew it would be easy to fail

Lunatic wrote:

ILikePie5 wrote:

I didn’t “derail” it. I wanted the third person to be Brands. Luna was all gung ho about getting Pie

You tunneled that shit soooo hard just to be wrong. Like you focused so much on policy there for no reason, when we had an actual wagon on actual scum. The Banana mislynch was our only mislynch and it didnt need to happen, but it almost resulted in two town being mislynched. Though in hindsight that shit show was a treasure trove of behavioral analysis gold which could have resulted in us winning, who knows.

Bruh, I was right. There was one scum in Pie, Kohai, Banana. 2 scum if you didn’t force me to claim and we went with Brands, though that’s a different story.

If Thoth hadn’t replaced out, which allowing that was bastard, he would have been the lynch for sure

Bullish wrote:

The blackmail "you can't say you were blackmailed" rule is also another one of those rules that's basically unenforceable. This is part of why being a lawmaker is actually a hard ass job.

I am aware. Some soft hinting I allow. Hardclaiming is out of the question

If Thoth hadn’t replaced out, which allowing that was bastard, he would have been the lynch for sure

It's so unspeakably bastard that I was sick and wanted someone who would be more active in my spot

ILikePie5 wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

ILikePie5 wrote:

I didn’t “derail” it. I wanted the third person to be Brands. Luna was all gung ho about getting Pie

You tunneled that shit soooo hard just to be wrong. Like you focused so much on policy there for no reason, when we had an actual wagon on actual scum. The Banana mislynch was our only mislynch and it didnt need to happen, but it almost resulted in two town being mislynched. Though in hindsight that shit show was a treasure trove of behavioral analysis gold which could have resulted in us winning, who knows.

Bruh, I was right. There was one scum in Pie, Kohai, Banana. 2 scum if you didn’t force me to claim and we went with Brands, though that’s a different story.

If Thoth hadn’t replaced out, which allowing that was bastard, he would have been the lynch for sure

Yeah. Thank God he dropped out.

TBF y’all got Mestari who fucked up my entire game plan

The blackmail "you can't say you were blackmailed" rule is also another one of those rules that's basically unenforceable. This is part of why being a lawmaker is actually a hard ass job.

Are we out here pretending that we don't pirate movies and have read and agreed to the terms and conditions?

ILikePie5 wrote:

And I would’ve joined u

naw dude lmao, Brand's wagon was at 3/7, you and banana were at 4/7, All you had to do was make a deal with banana to vote Brand and you both get spared.

Thoth wrote:

If Thoth hadn’t replaced out, which allowing that was bastard, he would have been the lynch for sure

It's so unspeakably bastard that I was sick and wanted someone who would be more active in my spot

Whatever helps you sleep at night lol

Whatever helps you sleep at night lol

at night

Someone has forgotten all the whining about my schedule

Bullish wrote:

ILikePie5 wrote:

And I would’ve joined u

naw dude lmao, Brand's wagon was at 3/7, you and banana were at 4/7, All you had to do was make a deal with banana to vote Brand and you both get spared.

There wasn’t appetite to lynch Brands blind + they hadn’t posted in a while. The replacement basically ended that wagon, which is why scum got a major advantage from that.

Bruh, I was right. There was one scum in Pie, Kohai, Banana. 2 scum if you didn’t force me to claim and we went with Brands, though that’s a different story.

Brother that was such a vanilla heavy game that there was bound to be one scum among the vanillas. Choosing to random yeet a vanilla with like no behavior analysis makes no sense. Also why did you tunnel banana so much harder than Caine? Like your reasoning on her was so bad I couldn’t fathom you being town.

Kohai wrote:

Bullish wrote:

I wasn't going to explicitly say who I was, but it should have been obvious, idk why people were reading me as Magic. Part of why I sussed Mikal was also the fact he kept calling me Magic, felt like bait. I said 2 things that should have made it obvious Oberon was Bullish - "I play mafia once a year" and "I'm a coastal elite libtard"

I figured you out when you said you understand my d- behavior due to being a programmer as well

yeah that too, I forgot. I was not being subtle.

I really should have stayed on pie and enjoy the pie ML.

Mag1cman wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Mag1cman wrote:

Bullish wrote:

The reason I sussed Mikal is because I modded a live game where I gave him or somebody in the game a role where you're forced to say "lol" at the end of every sentence, or something like that.

Kohai came up the idea to make you do something tedious that you'd eventually forget to do, and I decided that two periods per sentence was the best idea within his idea.

Brother thats the easiest black mail to win ever. How did he fuck that up lmao

I mean, all you have to do is not pay attention for one sentence of one post and then you're dead. If I were more active, I would've pestered him throughout the DP to try and increase the odds.

I feel like if I was black mailed I would hyper focus on being careful lol that’s a whole mislynch we lost

Kohai wrote:

I really should have stayed on pie and enjoy the pie ML.

Could have set me up for a ML or made me look bad lol

Lunatic wrote:

Kohai wrote:

I really should have stayed on pie and enjoy the pie ML.

Could have set me up for a ML or made me look bad lol

I regret not staying on pie

ILikePie5 wrote:

Bullish wrote:

ILikePie5 wrote:

And I would’ve joined u

naw dude lmao, Brand's wagon was at 3/7, you and banana were at 4/7, All you had to do was make a deal with banana to vote Brand and you both get spared.

There wasn’t appetite to lynch Brands blind + they hadn’t posted in a while. The replacement basically ended that wagon, which is why scum got a major advantage from that.

I was 100% okay lynching brand. You tunneling the vanilla thing and refusing to back down from it is what made me switch to you.

Lunatic wrote:

Bruh, I was right. There was one scum in Pie, Kohai, Banana. 2 scum if you didn’t force me to claim and we went with Brands, though that’s a different story.

Brother that was such a vanilla heavy game that there was bound to be one scum among the vanillas. Choosing to random yeet a vanilla with like no behavior analysis makes no sense. Also why did you tunnel banana so much harder than Caine? Like your reasoning on her was so bad I couldn’t fathom you being town.

I told scum D1 there were many vanillas and that most people were Vanilla. Which in effect functions like being given fake claims.

The idea from the very start was for scum to claim Vanilla, disabling any PoE town could get from claims. You could have confirmed Town but massclaiming wouldnt break the game.

Magoroth wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Bruh, I was right. There was one scum in Pie, Kohai, Banana. 2 scum if you didn’t force me to claim and we went with Brands, though that’s a different story.

Brother that was such a vanilla heavy game that there was bound to be one scum among the vanillas. Choosing to random yeet a vanilla with like no behavior analysis makes no sense. Also why did you tunnel banana so much harder than Caine? Like your reasoning on her was so bad I couldn’t fathom you being town.

I told scum D1 there were many vanillas and that most people were Vanilla. Which in effect functions like being given fake claims.

The idea from the very start was for scum to claim Vanilla, disabling any PoE town could get from claims. You could have confirmed Town but massclaiming wouldnt break the game.

Tnis is why I prefer vanilla games - mass claiming won’t let you win

Magoroth wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Bruh, I was right. There was one scum in Pie, Kohai, Banana. 2 scum if you didn’t force me to claim and we went with Brands, though that’s a different story.

Brother that was such a vanilla heavy game that there was bound to be one scum among the vanillas. Choosing to random yeet a vanilla with like no behavior analysis makes no sense. Also why did you tunnel banana so much harder than Caine? Like your reasoning on her was so bad I couldn’t fathom you being town.

I told scum D1 there were many vanillas and that most people were Vanilla. Which in effect functions like being given fake claims.

The idea from the very start was for scum to claim Vanilla, disabling any PoE town could get from claims. You could have confirmed Town but massclaiming wouldnt break the game.

Being dubious of vanillas is fine. Blind lynching them and ignoring behavior analysis when there are 1000 post to read an analyze is another thing

Magoroth wrote:

Julian jailed flora and had a huge last will but it wasn't displayed on NP1.

Can we get that last will?

ILikePie5 wrote:

The problem is that you can’t ignore consideration of who people are. Because the pool of players is so small, it becomes very obvious based on posting who everyone is.

As for Mikal asking those questions to Mago. I see them as legitimate questions, and it’s up to the mod to consider the ramifications of answering questions. Mikal himself as mod doesn’t answer any questions, but when in doubt, No Comment is the best answer.

I disagree.

Yeah, its a small community. Being told you need to not say who you are and do not say who you think other people are is a very simple rule. How rapidly that devolved into people hard declaring who they were was not great. When Mikal was directly warned over and over and told they should not keep doing so and until the end of the game doing it was not great.

Them asking a question to angle shoot? Not great. Sure. Blame the host for answering.

The inexcusable bit was when they were trying to leverage a mod kill from their rule breaks to shift the result of the game.

I have played 2 games on this site. Both games I was disgusted at the amount of OOG and angle shooting by players. Take that for what it is.

Well, I don’t have much to add. Honestly didn’t clock Mag1c as Fiona. I get going for it under the assumption that the player they Janitored was the one who posted the message. Bold effort, didn’t pan out.

Agreed that Mestari did a great job managing that last DP.

Even end game threads are a beast to catch up on here

Helz wrote:

The inexcusable bit was when they were trying to leverage a mod kill from their rule breaks to shift the result of the game.

Helz wrote:

I have played 2 games on this site. Both games I was disgusted at the amount of OOG and angle shooting by players. Take that for what it is.

Agreed on both accounts.

Also people quoting the time they received their role pm is wild work.

Alr Mestari. You're pretty good when locked in. But I was not locked in this game. Was preparing/playing a pokemon tournament until mid DP2.

Locked-in Mag1c has not dueled locked-in Mestari yet. >:)

It will likely never happen. When I consistently play locked in I am just killed or copped NP1 every game.