Yes, people who drink are happy.
And most jury people drink.
Yes, people who drink are happy.
And most jury people drink.
When do they take the leap of faith before passing a verdict?
@Debby wrote in post #489: Redshift is critical to the Big Bang theory because it provides direct observational proof that the universe is expanding.
Your champion, Mr. MIT nuclear scientist degree holder @FLRW, continues to neglect to post scientific method based fact as his argument against the “Coup de Grâce: Einstein’s Relativity Theories with the Minkowski Spacetime Model” as enumerated in post 258. Debby, you demonstrated your inability to comprehend posts like this, but I included you because this relates to red-shift. I quoted detailed scientific data from Rowland’s article in post #61 which culminated with Rowland writing about Eddington, Dyson, and Commelin’s sloppy work in application of Einstein’s Relativity to the 1919 solar eclipse “The readings themselves were also questionable because of (a) errors in parallax from varying angles of measurement and atmospheric conditions at the respective points of observation, and (b) equipment failure. Results were inconclusive because the error factor was as large as the deviation the experimenters were trying to prove [3]”. Notice the closing [3] reference in that quote which is the “What Einstein did Not Consider about Gravity” in which Rowland detailed:
In 1908, attempting to better explain his former student’s theory of special relativity (E=mc2), mathematics professor Hermann Minkowski expressed it in terms of a mathematical model that fused time and the three dimensions of space into a single four-dimensional continuum (later known as Minkowski spacetime). Notice two things about this model:Figure 1: Hypothetical Minkowski 4-D Spacetime
Source of Figure 1: Wikipedia [9].
That’s just a small portion of the logic and rational reasoning in Rowland’s article exposing Einstein and Minkowski’s leap of faith about Einstein’s Relativity theories.
Essentially, Einstein’s General Relativity, Einstein’s Special Relativity, Minkowski spacetime, and related gravitational lensing are fictional fantasy faith, not fact, just faith.
Therefore, your E=MC2 is a leap of faith as support for the Big Bang.
Gravitational red-shift depends on Einstein’s Relativity theories. Since Einstein’s Relativity theories are demonstrated to be a leap of faith, then gravitational red-shift is a leap of faith!
Your community’s “Redshift is widely” believed “as a primary method for determining cosmic distances and lookback times (the age of the universe” is a leap of belief!
Lord Jesus says “the gate is wide and the way is broad that leads to destruction, and there are many who enter through it” (Matthew 7:13), and the Big Bang way is wide!
For more “red-shift is merely red-spectral” proofs, see post #376. This current post builds upon post #709’s demonstrated scientific fact that red-shift is your leap of faith. Lack of Scientific Method process leaves your Big Bang evidence in a state of science fiction, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.
Three kinds of redshift:
1} Doppler i..e occupied space EMRadition/photon moving toward or away from our visual/instrumental observation
2} Cosmological, i.e. spacetime is expanding on its own? This would be Dark Energy and to me it means that spacetime is an occupied space medium, and Dark Energy is Bosonic Force, that, typically is what exchanged/mediating between two Fermionic Matter particles.
3} Gravitational i,e, gravity warps spacetime? I thought it was mass that warps spacetime. Either way that means to me, that spacetime is an occupied space medium that can be warped/twisted like lumber, or a spoon/metal etc.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fermionic Matter >< Higgs field > Higgs Boson/particle > --- Glueball Bosonic Force that may gives rise to its own mass is still questionable--.
3 kinds of electron and 3 kinds of anti-electron --elementary Fermionic particle --
3 kinds of neutrino and 3 kinds of anti-neutrino --elementary Fermionic particle--
18 combinations of quark and 18 combinations of anti-quark --elementary Fermionic particle--
These aggregate as more massive existence as protons, neutrons, Earth Suns Galaxies ergo, these latter have greater mass that warps spacetime.
....space.....Gravity>( reality )( reality )<Gravity....space.. simplistic scenario via space and time/reality torus
( ) = invisible/non-quantized and non-quantified, geodesic Gravity in my Cosmological book { pending }
)( = invisible/non-quantized and non-quantified, geodesic Dark Energy in my Cosmological book { pending }
^v^v = physical reality/observed time is what we quantize and quantify in my Cosmological book { pending }
@Debby wrote in post #717: The broader astrophysics community tested Burbridge’s hypothesis …snip
Why modern cosmology rejects Burbridge’s redshift claims.
appearing next to a nearby tree.
The Big Bang model remains the standard framework because it accurately predicts observations that steady-state models cannot explain.
@ebuc wrote in post #725: @FLRW @SergeantLynch @Sidewalker Three kinds of redshift …snip
Types of red-shift are irrelevant because you’re only seeing red-spectral as exhibited in post #376. Red-shift leads you to a Big Bang leap of faith.
First, I introduce you to an examination of red-shift, which scientist sorcerers base on the so-called doppler effect of light, in the light of the scientific method:
Red-shift adherents abysmally failed to completely apply the scientific method. Red-shift as a distance or direction determinant is bad science.
Astronomer astrologers, such as Hubble and Lemaître, engaged in circular reasoning between their hypothesis and conclusion, so their logic is flawed.
This circular reasoning is nonsense nonscience with scientist sorcerers conveying “I correctly science the Big Bang proof because I correctly science Big facts, and you are wrong because I science the Big Bang right”. All the while, those deeply confused people don’t science (know) with the scientific method.
JWST suffers from the same malady as NASA’s COBE and ESA’s Planck which I outlined in post #421, but you blindly post your belief without proof (assumptions).
For more “red-shift is merely red-spectral” proofs, see post #376. I plan to reply to your post, again, with more scientific fact showing the ridiculousness of red-shift.
Lack of Scientific Method process leaves your Big Bang evidence in a state of science fiction, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.
Mainstream science does not rely on redshift in isolation.Instead astronomers apply the scientific method by testing redshift against completely independent distance measurements - known as cosmic distance ladder.
@Debby wrote in post #727: Why modern cosmology rejects Burbridge’s redshift claims.
Your “modern cosmology” is defined by people like astrophysicist professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California San Diego astronomer astrologer Geoffrey Burbidge and scientist sorcerer RCC priest Georges Lemaître (see post #684) who died in 1966.
Your beliefs are hypocritical because you believe your preferred set of “modern cosmology” scientist sorcerer’s “observations” supercede your disfavored set of “modern cosmology” scientist sorcerer’s “observations”.
I demonstrate your fact deficient leap of faith for your antichrist 13,800,000,000 billion year old-ish universe in the following.
@Debby wrote in post #727: 1. Line of sight alignments. High resolution telescopes like the Hubble Space Telescope reveal …snip… They simply happen to line up along our line of sight from billions of light years apart …snip….
Your champion, scientist sorcerer @FLRW, used your “line of sight” argument as recorded in post #481 for his attempt to discredit the Burbidge with an international team of astrophysicist and astronomers “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper published in The Astrophysical Journal (issue 1, volume 620). First, your camp says “line of sight” is bad, second, your camp says “line of sight” is good. You engage in hypocrisy and doublespeak and confusion and deception.
@Debby wrote in post #727: 2. Gravitational lensing. …snip…
Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift disrupts your “Gravitational lensing” (see post #361 for details).
Furthermore, you preach circular reasoning as evidenced by you conveying “Gravitational lensing” (aka red-shift aka electromagnetic spectrum shift) proves red-shift (aka “Gravitational lensing” aka electromagnetic spectrum shift), so your “Gravitational lensing” constitutes your Big Bang leap of faith.
@Debby wrote in post #727: 3. Host galaxies Advanced imaging successfully detected faint host galaxies surrounding quasars, and those host galaxies share the exact high redshift as the quasars inside them. …snip
You provide no scientific method based analysis.
The NGC 7319 host galaxy is reportedly 300 million light years away from Earth while the quasar within the heart of the NGC 7319 host galaxy is reportedly several billion light years away from Earth, and you unscientifically, delusionally discard the reputation of the noted astrophysicist Burbidge who said of NGC 7319 quasar that “its redshift cannot be due to the expansion of the universe” and of quasars in general “too many of them are being found closely associated with nearby, active galaxies for this to be accidental”, and these quotes were issued by astrophysicist Geoffrey Burbidge, noted professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences (source for Burbidge quotes), who with an international team of astrophysicists and astronomers produced the “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper published in m The Astrophysical Journal (issue 1, volume 620).
Your “father of the Big Bang” RCC priest Lemaître served the Big Bang Queen of Heaven (see post #684), and you are right there doing as your “father of the Big Bang” RCC priest Lemaître did.
The Big Bang is a leap of faith.
Belief is futile, and faith leapers believe in magic men.
@Debby wrote in post #729: Mainstream science does not rely on redshift in isolation …snip…
Your “Mainstream science” (knowledge) for reading the heavens is truly your service to your and your “father of the Big Bang” RCC priest Lemaître’s Queen of Heaven (see post #684 for details),
@Debby wrote in post #729: cosmic distance ladder …snip
Your “cosmic distance ladder.” logically proved a leap of faith way back in post #53 and elsewhere in this thread.
Your complete absence of scientific method procedure indicates your nonsense nonscience.
Your intentional application of the word “predictions” (foretell, see post #82) puts you into the position of a false prophet, and Lord Jesus says “Beware of the false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly are ravenous wolves” (Matthew 7:15).
Your Cosmic Microwave Background is disrupted by astrophysicist Pavel Kroupa, professor at the Helmholtz Institute for Radiation and Nuclear Physics at the University of Bonn and Charles University in Prague, expressed “According to our calculations, it may not exist at all” regarding the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR) as per his study published in the journal Nuclear Physics B (source: “Goodbye to the Big Bang theory: a university challenges everything we thought we knew and suggests that the creation of the universe may have been something else” (Austin Caldwell; MARCA; 2025-06-28) (see post #451 for more details), so your absolutist “confirm” is your science (knowledge) Big Bang leap of faith.
In essence, you spent your post conveying that you have Big Bang fact because you have Big Bang fact, yet, you without the scientific method is you in a Big Bang leap of faith.
Kermos wrote
Your Cosmic Microwave Background is disrupted by astrophysicist Pavel Kroupa, professor at the Helmholtz Institute for Radiation and Nuclear Physics at the University of Bonn and Charles University in Prague, expressed “According to our calculations, it may not exist at all” regarding the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR) as per his study published in the journal Nuclear Physics B (source: “Goodbye to the Big Bang theory: a university challenges everything we thought we knew and suggests that the creation of the universe may have been something else” (Austin Caldwell; MARCA; 2025-06-28) (see post #451 for more details), so your absolutist “confirm” is your science (knowledge) Big Bang leap of faith.
In essence, you spent your post conveying that you have Big Bang fact because you have Big Bang fact, yet, you without the scientific method is you in a Big Bang leap of faith.
Expanding universe still acknowledged. Even in their press materials, Kroupa states that the universe has been expanding since the Big Bang.
@ebuc wrote in post #725: Three kinds of redshift …snip
You are using the nonsense nonscience doppler effect of light based on your assumptions, not the scientific method.
Sound waves are atmospheric tightly localized particle vibrations passed from particle to particle; on the other hand, light waves are projectile particles.
As an example of the doppler effect, when a fast moving train blows it’s whistle while passing a person, then the pitch increases on approach to the person (sound wave compression) and the pitch decreases as the train races toward the horizon (sound wave decompression) as the train leaves the person; however, red-shift conjecturers have no such scientific method proof for the doppler effect of light except for their hypothesis revealing their conclusion joined with their conclusion revealing their hypothesis which puts such scientist sorcerers in an infinite loop of circular reasoning.
The Doppler effect of sound is based on the scientific method.
The Doppler effect of the electromagnetic spectrum is science fiction without any scientific method proof.
For more “red-shift is merely red-spectral” proofs, see post #376. This current post builds upon post #728’s demonstrated scientific fact that red-shift is your leap of faith. I plan to reply to your post, again, with more scientific fact showing the ridiculousness of red-shift.
Lack of Scientific Method process leaves your Big Bang evidence in a state of science fiction, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.