Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith

Started by Kermos

Replies
726
Posts
727
Page
25 / 25

Conversation

#721 •••
@Debby

Yes, people who drink are happy.

And most jury people drink.

Edit post

#722 •••
@DoctorLied

When do they take the leap of faith before passing a verdict?

Edit post

#723 •••
@Debby


Debby wrote:
When do they take the leap of faith before passing a verdict?


Red shift.

Edit post

#724 •••
@Debby wrote in post #489: Redshift is critical to the Big Bang theory because it provides direct observational proof that the universe is expanding.


Einstein’s Relativity Theories with the Minkowski Spacetime Model fall apart under the logical consistency principle


Your champion, Mr. MIT nuclear scientist degree holder @FLRW, continues to neglect to post scientific method based fact as his argument against the “Coup de Grâce: Einstein’s Relativity Theories with the Minkowski Spacetime Model” as enumerated in post 258. Debby, you demonstrated your inability to comprehend posts like this, but I included you because this relates to red-shift. I quoted detailed scientific data from Rowland’s article in post #61 which culminated with Rowland writing about Eddington, Dyson, and Commelin’s sloppy work in application of Einstein’s Relativity to the 1919 solar eclipse “The readings themselves were also questionable because of (a) errors in parallax from varying angles of measurement and atmospheric conditions at the respective points of observation, and (b) equipment failure. Results were inconclusive because the error factor was as large as the deviation the experimenters were trying to prove [3]”. Notice the closing [3] reference in that quote which is the “What Einstein did Not Consider about Gravity” in which Rowland detailed:

In 1908, attempting to better explain his former student’s theory of special relativity (E=mc2), mathematics professor Hermann Minkowski expressed it in terms of a mathematical model that fused time and the three dimensions of space into a single four-dimensional continuum (later known as Minkowski spacetime). Notice two things about this model: image Figure 1: Hypothetical Minkowski 4-D Spacetime
  1. It is not possible to assign co-ordinates to the hypothetical time axis; and
  2. Because E = mc2 does not include any time variable, there is nowhere said equation fits into this four-dimensional model.
Source of Figure 1: Wikipedia [9].


That’s just a small portion of the logic and rational reasoning in Rowland’s article exposing Einstein and Minkowski’s leap of faith about Einstein’s Relativity theories.


Essentially, Einstein’s General Relativity, Einstein’s Special Relativity, Minkowski spacetime, and related gravitational lensing are fictional fantasy faith, not fact, just faith.


Therefore, your E=MC2 is a leap of faith as support for the Big Bang.


Gravitational red-shift depends on Einstein’s Relativity theories. Since Einstein’s Relativity theories are demonstrated to be a leap of faith, then gravitational red-shift is a leap of faith!


Your community’s “Redshift is widely” believed “as a primary method for determining cosmic distances and lookback times (the age of the universe” is a leap of belief!


Lord Jesus says “the gate is wide and the way is broad that leads to destruction, and there are many who enter through it” (Matthew 7:13), and the Big Bang way is wide!


For more “red-shift is merely red-spectral” proofs, see post #376. This current post builds upon post #709’s demonstrated scientific fact that red-shift is your leap of faith. Lack of Scientific Method process leaves your Big Bang evidence in a state of science fiction, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Edit post

#725 •••
@FLRW, @SergeantLynch, @Sidewalker

Three kinds of redshift:


1} Doppler i..e occupied space EMRadition/photon moving toward or away from our visual/instrumental observation


2} Cosmological, i.e. spacetime is expanding on its own? This would be Dark Energy and to me it means that spacetime is an occupied space medium, and Dark Energy is Bosonic Force, that, typically is what exchanged/mediating between two Fermionic Matter particles.


3} Gravitational i,e, gravity warps spacetime? I thought it was mass that warps spacetime. Either way that means to me, that spacetime is an occupied space medium that can be warped/twisted like lumber, or a spoon/metal etc.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Fermionic Matter >< Higgs field > Higgs Boson/particle > --- Glueball Bosonic Force that may gives rise to its own mass is still questionable--.


3 kinds of electron and 3 kinds of anti-electron --elementary Fermionic particle --


3 kinds of neutrino and 3 kinds of anti-neutrino --elementary Fermionic particle--


18 combinations of quark and 18 combinations of anti-quark --elementary Fermionic particle--


These aggregate as more massive existence as protons, neutrons, Earth Suns Galaxies ergo, these latter have greater mass that warps spacetime.



....space.....Gravity>( reality )( reality )<Gravity....space.. simplistic scenario via space and time/reality torus


( ) = invisible/non-quantized and non-quantified, geodesic Gravity in my Cosmological book { pending }


)( = invisible/non-quantized and non-quantified, geodesic Dark Energy in my Cosmological book { pending }


^v^v = physical reality/observed time is what we quantize and quantify in my Cosmological book { pending }

Edit post

#726 •••
@Debby wrote in post #717: The broader astrophysics community tested Burbridge’s hypothesis …snip
  1. Your astronomer astrologers have a vested Interest in preserving red-shift with the Big Bang. Your astronomer astrologers make their living and careers out of red-shift with the Big Bang. Your people have science bias (also known as a leap of faith).
  2. You cited no scientific method based paper for your post, so you posted generalized emotion (a.k.a. a leap of faith)
  3. Your astronomer astrologers utilized circular reasoning instead of the scientific method as per the following:
  4. Phase: activity
  5. hypothesis: red spectral light emits from a star in space indicating the star recedes away Earth and the star’s great distance from Earth.
  6. experiment: no test cases.
  7. observation: none of experiments.
  8. conclusion: a star receding away from Earth with distances of monumental proportion emit red spectral light.
  9. confirmation: no experiments to repeat.

  10. Red-shift scientist sorcerers abysmally failed to completely apply the scientific method. Red-shift as a distance determinant is not science.

  11. Astronomer astrologers, such as Hubble and Lemaître, engaged in circular reasoning between their hypothesis and conclusion, so their logic is flawed as is is your logic by extension.

  12. This circular reasoning is nonsense nonscience with scientist sorcerers saying “I correctly science the proof because I correctly science facts, and you are wrong because I science facts”. All the while, those nonsense nonscience scientist sorcerers don’t science (know) with the scientific method.
  13. I use your science (knowledge) against you. You do not believe scientist sorcerer Geoffrey Burbidge, astrophysicist professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California San Diego, who indicated disruption of your red-shift as a measure of age and distance (see post #697 for details), but you believe other scientist sorcerers, so you have a Big Bang leap of faith.


Edit post

#727 •••
@Kermos

Why modern cosmology rejects Burbridge’s redshift claims.

  1. Line of sight alignments. High resolution telescopes like the Hubble Space Telescope reveal that quasars and nearby galaxies are rarely physically connected. They simply happen to line up along our line of sight from billions of light years apart , much like a distant aeroplane

appearing next to a nearby tree.


  1. Gravitational lensing. In cases where quasars are directly behind galaxies, the foreground galaxy’s gravity bends and magnifies the quasar’s light. This optical effect proves the quasar is strictly behind the galaxy confirming its greater distance.
  2. Host galaxies Advanced imaging successfully detected faint host galaxies surrounding quasars, and those host galaxies share the exact high redshift as the quasars inside them.


The Big Bang model remains the standard framework because it accurately predicts observations that steady-state models cannot explain.

Edit post