Something other than the universe probably caused the universe

Started by linate

Replies
17
Posts
18
Page
1 / 1

Conversation

#1 •••

We have two propositions. Either the universe was caused by something else, or by itself as if it always existed. Thermodynamics show that entropy increases from lower states and the energy in systems always comes from a higher source. As far as we can tell, it's not possible for the system of our universe to be from itself because that violates thermodynamics as we know it. At the quantum level in a vacuum things can appear from nothing but we have nothing ever shown that could have caused the universe as we know it. The big bang occurred which begs the question what came before that.


Of course it's possible the universe came from itself but we have nothing to indicate that and plenty to contradict it.


Of course a third possibility is that the universe came from nothing but if there's not enough science to show the universe always existed then the best option is something caused the universe as this makes more sense than coming from nothing

Edit comment

Evidence of the afterlife

https://www.debatecraft.com/forum/c/religion/posts/10d/evidence-of-the-afterlife

#2 •••

I think you're presenting a recognizable and philosophically substantial version of the cosmological argument for a transcendent cause of the universe. Its strength is that you're not simply arguing that God must exist because science cannot explain something. You're making a positive argument based on the nature of physical reality, thermodynamics, and the origin of the universe.


I would organize your argument into four propositions:


1\. The universe requires an explanation. Everything we observe within the universe operates according to physical laws and has physical conditions that explain its existence and behavior.


2\. The universe cannot straightforwardly explain itself. Thermodynamics indicates that the universe is not an indefinitely self-sustaining system in the ordinary sense. Entropy increases, and usable energy is transformed and dissipated.


3\. Quantum events don't establish creation from absolute nothingness. Quantum fluctuations occur within a physical framework, with underlying fields and laws. They don't demonstrate that an entire universe can spontaneously emerge from philosophical nothingness.


4\. A transcendent cause is a reasonable explanation. If the universe cannot adequately account for its own existence, something beyond the physical universe may be responsible for it.


That is a meaningful argument. However, there are a few scientific and philosophical distinctions worth making to make it considerably stronger.


### 1\. Thermodynamics is a strong consideration, but needs qualification


Your argument about entropy is important.


The second law of thermodynamics tells us that the entropy of an isolated system tends not to decrease. This raises a legitimate question: if the universe has existed eternally, why isn't it already in a state of maximum entropy, with no usable energy remaining to sustain the structures and processes we observe?


This is sometimes called the thermodynamic argument against an eternal past.


There is an important qualification, though: cosmologists don't fully understand how entropy behaves in an expanding universe with gravity. Gravitational entropy, black holes, and the expansion of spacetime complicate the picture.


So I wouldn't say thermodynamics conclusively disproves an eternal universe. I'd say it creates a substantial explanatory challenge for certain models of an eternal universe.


### 2\. The Big Bang doesn't necessarily explain the ultimate beginning


The Big Bang theory describes the evolution of the universe from an extraordinarily hot, dense early state.


It doesn't, by itself, explain why that state existed.


There are hypotheses involving:


* A preceding contracting universe.


* A cyclic universe.


* Quantum cosmology.


* Inflationary cosmology.


* Models in which time itself has a beginning.


These are legitimate scientific investigations, but none has established a definitive explanation of ultimate existence. Harvard & Smithsonian +2


### 3\. Quantum nothingness isn't philosophical nothingness


I think this is one of your strongest points.


When physicists discuss particles emerging from a quantum vacuum, they aren't describing absolute nothingness.


A quantum vacuum still involves:


* Physical fields.


* Quantum laws.


* Mathematical structure.


* A physical framework in which quantum events can occur.


Consequently, saying that quantum mechanics demonstrates that something can come from nothing is misleading.


It demonstrates that our ordinary understanding of physical emptiness is incomplete. It doesn't establish that existence can emerge from absolute nonexistence.


### 4\. The philosophical question: which explanation is most reasonable?


I'd distinguish three possibilities:


| Proposition | Central difficulty |

| -------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

| The universe always existed | Must explain its thermodynamic history and why an eternal physical reality exists. |

| The universe came from absolute nothing | Must explain how nothing could produce something. |

| The universe was caused by something beyond itself | Must explain the nature and existence of that cause. |


The third possibility is philosophically interesting because it doesn't require the cause to operate according to the physical laws of the universe it explains.


However, one important distinction remains: establishing that the universe has a transcendent cause doesn't automatically establish that the cause is personal, intelligent, or identical to the God of Christianity. Those require additional arguments.


### 5\. How I would strengthen your argument


I would actually change one aspect of your original formulation.


Rather than arguing that the universe cannot have always existed, argue that the universe's existence remains unexplained whether it has a finite or infinite past.


Even an eternally existing universe would leave us with the question of why there is something rather than nothing.


An infinite chain of physical explanations doesn't necessarily provide an ultimate explanation for the existence of the chain itself.


This brings us to a particularly powerful philosophical distinction:


* Scientific explanation: What physical processes produced the universe's present condition?


* Metaphysical explanation: Why does physical reality exist at all?


Science has made extraordinary progress on the first question. The second remains unresolved.


### My proposed formulation of your argument


I think this captures your position particularly well:


> The universe either has an ultimate cause beyond itself or exists without an ultimate cause.The proposition that the universe has always existed faces serious questions, including the implications of thermodynamics and the observed expansion of the universe. Although eternal and cyclic cosmological models remain possible, none has established that the physical universe has an infinite past.The proposition that the universe came from nothing faces an even more fundamental difficulty. Quantum fluctuations do not demonstrate creation from absolute nothingness, because quantum vacuums already presuppose physical laws and structures.Therefore, while science has not conclusively established the ultimate origin of the universe, the possibility that physical reality depends upon something beyond itself deserves serious consideration. A transcendent cause offers a philosophically coherent alternative to the proposition that the universe simply exists without explanation.We cannot honestly claim that science has proven God. But neither can we honestly claim that science has explained why anything exists at all.


One final thought: I think your argument becomes especially interesting when combined with the principle of sufficient reason: the idea that contingent things require an explanation for their existence. That takes you beyond the Big Bang and thermodynamics and into the deeper question of why there is an existence-dependent universe rather than nothing whatsoever.


That is where the cosmological argument becomes a genuinely metaphysical argument rather than merely an argument about cosmology.


Edit post

Evidence of the afterlife

https://www.debatecraft.com/forum/c/religion/posts/10d/evidence-of-the-afterlife

#3 •••

I asked ai and it couldn't help but invoke the God debate but my thesis here doesn't even involve God necessarily... just that th we most likely explanation is that something caused the universe

Edit post

Evidence of the afterlife

https://www.debatecraft.com/forum/c/religion/posts/10d/evidence-of-the-afterlife

#4 •••
@linate

Of course something other than the universe caused the universe. By the light of Horus, atheists shall kneel before us.

Edit post

#5 •••

 Many theoretical physicists argue that our universe is one of many in a multiverse, where fundamental constants are determined by random chance. Under this view, we simply inhabit one of the rare universes where conditions allowed for life, making our existence a statistical accident or a "lucky draw" from a cosmic lottery. This perspective suggests that the laws of nature do not uniquely dictate our universe, rendering its specific features incalculable and accidental. 

Born-Blip-Die

Edit post

#6 •••

Op could replace "universe" with 'cause of the universe' or 'GOD' and every critique is still applicable.


The bottom line is that we dont know.

Edit post

Take the risk of thinking for yourself, much more happiness, truth, beauty, and wisdom will come to you that way. - Christopher Hitchens

#7 •••
@FLRW

"Theoretical physicists"


Sort of theoretically physicists just like anyone else who cares to have a stab at the universal question.


Hmmmmm...There's only one but there could be more than one...


No shit Sherlock.

Edit post

#8 •••
@SkepticalOne

What we do know, is that stuff is and therefore.


And stuff generates events and duration, which give the potentials of time and space meaning...Therefore a Universe.


The big question isn't the Universe...The big question is stuff.

Edit post

#9 •••
@FLRW, @SergeantLynch

Very well, I will play along. I will give these atheist snake charmers my answer.


By the power of Ra

So you think you got words in high places

With the power

To put me on the run

Forgive us the smile on our faces

You will know what power is when we are done


You are playing with the big boys now

Every spell and gesture

Tells you who is the best


Stop this foolish mission

Watch some true magician

Pick up your silly words boy

You are playing with the big boys now


By the light of Horus

You will kneel before us


Set, Horus, Anubis, Nut

You put up a spite

You put up a fight

You could be God's avatar

But first boy it's time to bow


Why? Why do your words bother me so much? Why? Why?

Wait, I don't need to believe your words

I don't need to believe them

Hahaha


I keep believing in God and not in your words.

Edit post

#10 •••

Before the Big Bang the universe was just a mixture of gases. The Big Bang cause the gases to mix and form matter. In time the matter developed into the different planets and galaxies. Because of the gaseous origin the universe is still expanding.

The Bible tells us God was the source of the gases . And because he was God, it was released with a Big Bang.

Edit post

#11 •••
@Debby
The Bible tells us God was the source of the gases


God is a girl. Those gases were her farts. Big bang was just a slightly bigger fart of the world girl. World stinks because its made of farts. God girl wants the farts to go away, far from her.

Edit post

#12 •••
@DoctorLied

That explains why the universe is expanding.

Edit post

#13 •••


The Bible tells us God was the source of the gases


OMG, is God a Trump?

Edit post

#14 •••
@FLRW
OMG, is God a Trump?


God loves people like Trump. God makes them rich, and forgives them all their crimes. Look at how many crimes Trump committed. Just look at it. You simply can't believe your eyes that God can forgive so many crimes. It's a miracle. All while a terminally ill child, guilty of no crime, lives a short and miserable life and painful death. God hates terminally ill children.

Edit post

#15 •••
@Debby


Debby wrote:
Before the Big Bang the universe was just a mixture of gases. The Big Bang cause the gases to mix and form matter. In time the matter developed into the different planets and galaxies. Because of the gaseous origin the universe is still expanding.
The Bible tells us God was the source of the gases . And because he was God, it was released with a Big Bang.


Which kiddies book of Christian science did you get that from?


Nonetheless, where did all the gas come from?...(And don't say God farts).


The theory still relies upon infinite existence.

Edit post

#16 •••
@SergeantLynch

There was high energy stored in space let out by God, which we call gas. That energy transferred into matter after God let out the Big Bang. That is why God needed to rest after a week of letting go.

Edit post

#17 •••


OMG, did Satan pull God's finger?

Edit post

#18 •••
@Debby, @FLRW

LOL.

Debby wrote:
There was high energy stored in space let out by God, which we call gas. That energy transferred into matter after God let out the Big Bang. That is why God needed to rest after a week of letting go.


You're a stand up comedian aren't you.


God must have existed on a diet of brussels sprouts and baked beans.

Edit post