Alien Mafia DP2

The only reason I’m not insta voting you is because you are named in the pm. But your justification almost directly matches Casey’s flip and it’s why I disliked the idea of you saying you had a passive role earlier. Felt like you were hard softing a power role

its literally quite possible, you could have roled scum as that character and adjusted the role.

but the thing that’s making me second guess that is because you said Lina told you the split was hard. How would the split be hard if when Casey’s characters dies. It outright names your character.

talking out loud but I really don’t like that claim

This seems akin to the Martyr role you gave me in that Indian Politicians game a while back. Am I remembering that correctly?

The two that are sticking out like a sore thumb is skep and pie.

but one of them have to be true as they both could not roll mafia

skeps claim seems weirder so if he’s scum. Pie can’t have started scum so the only way that he would be scum if he’s recruited.

Shower thought: Whiteflame is extremely dangerous, possibly far more dangerous than I am. If whiteflame is scum, either original or recruited, they could obtain my vengeful status and use it the next day phase if they are lynched!

Also, I confirmed with the mod they would not block me from being recruited.

That is fine. Just a waste 

only other reason to do that is if you are baiting a nk. You aren't claiming pgo so we have to assume the recruit went through and if you come out and claim bomb or beloved, I am prob death tunneling you.

Im none of those 3 roles

this literally is red flags all day.

Character: Ellen Ripley

Role: Martyr

Justification: I am the protagonist of the original Alien moves and have faced Xenomorphs the most. In the third movie I was impregnated by an Alien Queen and jumped in a lava pit to kill myself so that Weyland couldn’t use my offspring as a weapon

From MS:

A Martyr's death negation may only work when the Martyr is eliminated. Alternately, a Martyr's death negation may only work when the Martyr dies during the night.

A Martyr may instead cause the next day's elimination to fail when the Martyr dies, this makes the Martyr similar to a Beloved Princess.

@Ilikepie, are you saying that if you die, either through lynching or nk that there will be no deaths during the night phase?

Also, if that's the case then maybe pie is the best lynch. If pie was original scum or was recruited then there won't be a NK. There's a high probability of him being recruited, far more so than other players like vader.

NP1 I tracked Kohai. I had lingering questions about the “two Xenomorphs” thing and I needed to know if the Vengeful role was true as it seemed hella swingy. Kohai visited no one, consistent with Vengeful. Then I read DP2 and realized it didn't matter because he could be scum now anyway. My results only really contraindicate that he was the original scum, unless he waived his power or had a passive scum role (if that's even a thing).

I buy that Wendy would be a Tracker from what I read, kind of assumed a protective role but it fits too. This result does strongly suggest that at least David didn’t start out as scum (could be a Ninja, but I doubt it). I don’t believe he was converted, at least not based on what I’ve seen from him this DP.

The only reason I’m not insta voting you is because you are named in the pm. But your justification almost directly matches Casey’s flip and it’s why I disliked the idea of you saying you had a passive role earlier. Felt like you were hard softing a power role 

How does it “match” Casey’s. Speaking of passive roles. Based on MafiaScum, Developer only bestows passive roles. And you’re getting active roles?

its literally quite possible, you could have roled scum as that character and adjusted the role. 

Anything is possible lol

but the thing that’s making me second guess that is because you said Lina told you the split was hard. How would the split be hard if when Casey’s characters dies. It outright names your character. 

Exactly. Im town.

talking out loud but I really don’t like that claim

but the thing that’s making me second guess that is because you said Lina told you the split was hard. How would the split be hard if when Casey’s characters dies. It outright names your character. 

Exactly. Im town.

Exactly why I believe pie to be original town. Again, the question is whether or not he was recruited.

Yes it’s active. I had to ask Luna what it did cus I had never seen it and he described it as a delayed JOAT

Shower thought: Whiteflame is extremely dangerous, possibly far more dangerous than I am. If whiteflame is scum, either original or recruited, they could obtain my vengeful status and use it the next day phase if they are lynched!

I do love shower thoughts, though this one doesn’t work. I can acquire a role during the NP from a dead townie. I’ll have to ask how that would work if it’s a passive role, but if it’s active, I either use it or lose it.

Well tbf just re read it and he didn’t say active

“you get a role every night phase”

I guess it could be either.

this literally is red flags all day.

How is it red flags. I didn’t lie to you

I had a long day and I'm too burnt out to follow this and look up all the roles I don't know. I'mma take a nap and do a late night catch up.

It’s basically a beloved. But trying not to read into it to much. I was just heavily implying a passive role that justifies baiting a nk when you seemed like you were softing a power role last dp erks me.

It’s basically a beloved. But trying not to read into it to much. I was just heavily implying a passive role that justifies baiting a nk when you seemed like you were softing a power role last dp erks me.

Again, why is what I did a bad play?

I’m not staying on much longer myself, taking my wife out to dinner shortly. I’ll give these claims some thought and hopefully post again later tonight.

Town to scum

myself

supa

castin

wf

Pie - seemed like he was softing a power role then back peddled after I said he could verify me. Also said he wasn’t beloved and had a role that basically does the same thing

David - because of the potential recruit and his role being op to scum. Don’t think he was og scum. It’s possible but unlikely

skep - delayed us for like a day with claiming and is a even night role cop. Only thing that gets me with this is he delayed so long that this is a uniquely shitty role to claim after how long he had. But we did all post at the same time so fake claiming seems very risky

Maybe Casey skep

and Casey inted to get David after he claimed.

I do love shower thoughts, though this one doesn’t work. I can acquire a role during the NP from a dead townie. I’ll have to ask how that would work if it’s a passive role, but if it’s active, I either use it or lose it.

Just checked with Luna on this. I can take on a passive role. If I do, it lasts for the following DP.

And now I’m going before my time on my phone becomes a problem.

its not a bad play if that’s your actual role. Cus you claiming a power role to bait is logical. But this only came up after I said you could verify me

thought is you were softing a power role and had to adjust after I mentioned you had to be passive or you were lying

I’m just saying it’s convenient

Town to scum order

Town to scum order

Town to scum order

Town to scum order

Wryly

Mikal

RexFavilla

Vader

iLikePie5

Whiteflame

Im retarded, typed that on my phone while running out the door. It's not roles, it's characters. I can test characters on even nights. A role cop would indeed be shitty but this means that I can essentially nail a fake claim.

What’s your actual role called

town to scum list

Justification is that people ask me questions over intercom and I answer, so I can basically ask if a character is actually in the game and will then visit that character if it does.