Alien Mafia DP2

That is disgusting and also adds a layer of complexity to this that I really need to think on.

I know. Which is why I am really shocked I wasn’t the recruit.

A possible thought: Perhaps I was recruited but the recruit failed and Casey still died? Would this make any sense if I was jail kept or somehow blocked from being recruited?

unlikely based on how a role stopping mechanic would work. Role would only trigger if it was successful. At least it would be stupid if she killed herself and the action did not go off. I can't see a world where a Mod would process something in that order.

unlikely based on how a role stopping mechanic would work. Role would only trigger if it was successful. At least it would be stupid if she killed herself and the action did not go off. I can't see a world where a Mod would process something in that order.

this is fair. We will wait for others to claim

Based on math, if you are scum and are alive tomorrow. If there are no NK preventions, we lose. My gut is uneasy with that. But the fact you are so adamant about not being recruited and saying it so openly, makes me townread you for some reason. It's just odd to keep pointing it out as much as you are. It's like noob town.

If I claim, we should really look at just full claiming at some point and I am not claiming before pie does. It will give him leverage to wiggle out of something and I am not doing that.

Everyone should full claim today tbh. Idm going first, but my role loses complete utility if I do. As for who scum would’ve recruited, Kohai, if town, is the logical option since he would take a townie down with him.

fair point. TBH he is still my strongest scum read and it is not just because of flavor claiming

What else is it then?

Math wise, if hes scum and alive tomorrow the game is over. Check me, but I've checked it twice. Assuming there is no nk preventions.

yes you need to claim first because you should know I targeted you and that also makes me uneasy.

Nope. I am actually quite shocked tbh. I confirmed that with the mod. We could technically go to F3, I get lynched, and town can still win if I kill correctly. 

How? 2-1, you getting lynched puts scum at parity and win

Math wise, if hes scum and alive tomorrow the game is over. Check me, but I've checked it twice. Assuming there is no nk preventions. 

It’s 6-2 right now. If mislynch + NK, then 4-2. If we lynch Kohai and he’s scum, then 4-1 to 3-1, and then 2-1, so we still should be good. Best action is probably lynching Kohai tomorrow regardless of what we think his affiliation truly is.

yes you need to claim first because you should know I targeted you and that also makes me uneasy.

yes you need to claim first because you should know I targeted you and that also makes me uneasy. 

I’ll wait for Luna to respond he didn’t make a mistake, and then I’ll claim.

Nope. I am actually quite shocked tbh. I confirmed that with the mod. We could technically go to F3, I get lynched, and town can still win if I kill correctly. 

How? 2-1, you getting lynched puts scum at parity and win

Because I kill them when I die and there’s only town left. This was confirmed with the mod.

also another possibility is they purposely did not recruit me to make me a lynch target and hope I’d kill town so they’d get three townies at once.

Assuming 2 scum

we have 7 players so (5-2)

if mislynch 6 players (4-2)

If a Nk goes through 5 players (3-2)

if we kill kohai tomorrow and he is scum 4 players (3-1)

he shoots someone 3 players (2-1)

If a Nk goes through 2 players (1-1) Game over

is this not correct?

Math wise, if hes scum and alive tomorrow the game is over. Check me, but I've checked it twice. Assuming there is no nk preventions.

If you’re that paranoia then I’ll gladly volunteer to be the lynch today. Though I would want to have discussion on who I should take down with me. I’m not going to act without input

It’s 6-2 right now

Ngl this bothers the fuck out of me too. There is not even consideration of a TP, or some other scenario. It's an affirmative statement.

Ngl this bothers the fuck out of me too. There is not even consideration of a TP, or some other scenario. It's an affirmative statement.

I highly doubt there is a third party

A recruit role really fucks with the game. There has to be some balance to it.

I doubt there is a TP as well (with a mafia recruit) unless there is just 1 mafia, but it's the way people word things. The way he worded that was in the affirmative.

" It is 6-2" - Which there are only 7 players so that's odd off the bat. But the "it is" followed by 2 mafia can often imply knowledge that should not be there. Not saying that is definitive but that is typically a TMI post.

A recruit role really fucks with the game. There has to be some balance to it.

Yeah. Which is why I am thinking an anti recruit role could exist

What would be an anti recruit role? I don't think there is something that just makes a recruit die. Unless it's a pgo or something. Like in theory casey could have tried to recruit a pgo and just died but that seems not likely and someone would claim it. Kinda doing occams razor.

Assuming 2 scum

we have 7 players so (5-2)

if mislynch 6 players (4-2)

If a Nk goes through 5 players (3-2)

if we kill kohai tomorrow and he is scum 4 players (3-1)

he shoots someone 3 players (2-1)

If a Nk goes through 2 players (1-1) Game over

is this not correct?

Okay ya you’re right, the no NK threw me off. So we’re forced to lynch Kohai today

Ngl this bothers the fuck out of me too. There is not even consideration of a TP, or some other scenario. It's an affirmative statement. 

The “affirmative” statement was wrong. And why would I consider a TP in a 9p game

It just felt like it was worded as TMI.

Ok, Luna confirmed that he did not make a mistake, so either you’re lying, or you were fucked with, cause I’m not lying. I have no reason to lie

You are either scum or have a passive role then.

Can you ask if your kill after being lynched counts as a nightkill

I do have a passive role

I also dislike this. I know it's a possibility but the way you feigned saying not to protect you or whatever you said heavily implied you had a power role. Assuming you were saying that to make mafia not target you.

Can you ask if your kill after being lynched counts as a nightkill 

I don’t believe so. I’ll ask the mod

Confirmed it does not count