Locked

1990s-2000s Nostalgia Mafia (DP1)

Started by Kohai

Replies
728
Posts
729
Page
19 / 25

Conversation

Total: 729
ISO #541 •••
--> @Mikal
2) wf claimed he’s affiliation confirmable by role. Don’t really buy this


That is not what I said. I said my role is affiliation-specific, i.e. it is solely a town role. I haven't said anything about confirmation. It's fine if you don't buy it, but at least be accurate to what I've softed.

Edit post

ISO #542 •••
--> @Mikal

You defended Thoth saying that the OP could imply town having an anticlaim role, yet you attack me for making an inference that’s less of a reach



Edit post

ISO #543 •••

that is either the best fake claim I’ve ever seen or it’s basically mod confirmed in the op.


I have to assume that’s Bible.



question is could scum have that.



i want to leave awesome alone for today and don’t want to say why.

Edit post

ISO #544 •••
--> @Mikal

Quite frankly, I forgot what your role did, and it seemed scummy to me when I first looked at it, if anything

Edit post

ISO #545 •••
--> @awesome5000

you have to see the difference.



the OP literally states word for word there are anti claim mechanics but only you know your role is in the game.

Edit post

ISO #546 •••
--> @awesome5000

I can confirm myself in multiple ways. One of which is already confirmed. So unless you think the mod just gave scum a pretty useless role for them. I’m at least role confirmable on multiple fronts.

Edit post

ISO #547 •••
--> @whiteflame

i am okay with backing off awesome. Whether he is town or not will solve itself.



now I’m at wf or supa



vtl

supa

Edit post

ISO #548 •••

.Vote Count

Awesome5000 (4/6) Airmax, ILikePie, Vader, Unsaid,- > L2

Vader (2/6) Lunatic, Mikal

Whiteflame (1/6) Thoth

Mikal (1/6) Awesome5000


Not voting: (3/10) , RexFlavius, Mikal, Whiteflame


With 10 alive it takes 6 votes to lynch! .


5 hours remain in day phase! Day phase ends at 6pm est

Edit post

"Kohai, your entrance to the thread was legendary, you had a solve and a winning PoE right when you showed up, super impressive stuff, even more so considering it wasn't even your objective!!" - Zrein

ISO #549 •••

Alright well I’m the tracker and I’m Steve from blues clues


tough shit if I die atp. Town deserve it for forcing claims in an anti mass claim mechanic

Edit post

Kick logic to the curb and do the impossible!

ISO #550 •••

Okay going to take a bit to read over this and think.


we now have a lot out and if we target someone else it’s just going to force another claim.



i can see awesome role being town sided or scum sided but I’m okay with leaving it because of the op and it’s mostly useless to mafia. Seems the intention is for mafia to kill him so the only thing we can do is vote? What does a Dayphase being disabled look like. Can we even vote. There is a specific reason I want to leave him alive.


supa as tracker is something to sit on

Edit post

ISO #551 •••
--> @Vader
Im not claiming my actual role because of the anti claim utility but I have confirmation utility in the next DP that will confirm my role

Normal mafia I would claim this but with the anti claim mechanic that is strongly advised against doing, I will not be claiming this DP. If I’m lynched well, I don’t really care


Explain this to me. How do you go from posting this to claiming after you have two votes on you?

Edit post

ISO #552 •••
--> @whiteflame

This also just had alarm bells for me.


issue Steve as a tracker is a damn good justification.

Edit post

ISO #553 •••
--> @whiteflame

Because they claimed a role where they actively disable chats, and that would imply what the OP is saying about claiming and such to a certain extent about being weary. At that point I’m going to be forced to claim at this point because we feel it’s going to be better to claim when there’s a literal statement that says to not claim versus holding off claims or even, not lynching. So if I die it’s not my fault and I don’t want to have the burden of getting lynched for not wanting the claim

Edit post

Kick logic to the curb and do the impossible!

ISO #554 •••

I keep mulling over awesome and I feel like I have to believe that cus of the op. Would the mod give that role to mafia?

Edit post

ISO #555 •••

I love this.



this is a hard Dayphase

Edit post

ISO #556 •••

What the hell is day chat? Can they mute people in the DP?

Edit post

ISO #557 •••
--> @Mikal
issue Steve as a tracker is a damn good justification.


I mean... it makes sense, I agree, but it also comes off as a pretty safe bet for character claims. And I don't know about you, but my role and character are not that cleanly aligned.

Edit post

ISO #558 •••
--> @Vader
Because they claimed a role where they actively disable chats, and that would imply what the OP is saying about claiming and such to a certain extent about being weary. At that point I’m going to be forced to claim at this point because we feel it’s going to be better to claim when there’s a literal statement that says to not claim versus holding off claims or even, not lynching. So if I die it’s not my fault and I don’t want to have the burden of getting lynched for not wanting the claim


...none of that answers my question. You said you were vehemently opposed to claiming, willing to be lynched rather than claim. Why did you change your mind and why was two votes enough to do it?

Edit post

ISO #559 •••

Myself - can give a list of 3 people at least one of which is scum to anyone in game, popular (tested), can’t be killed by any night actions


wf - his role can only be town (according to him)


supa - Steve / Tracker


awesome - if he dies he disables day chats


mac - Mr Roger’s - neighborizer (I do think this almost locks awesome as telling the truth cus of op wording “all faction day chats”



pie - affiliation confirmable


Luna - got pm 7 mins before game started -??????


unsaid -?????


skep -??????


Thoth - ?????

Edit post

ISO #560 •••
--> @RexFavilla
What the hell is day chat? Can they mute people in the DP?


Pretty sure it's in reference to the Discord chats, so the Neighborizer chat and even the scum chat might be mutable.

Edit post

ISO #561 •••
--> @whiteflame

Mine isn’t either. The singing portion is but only that. The popular and BP make literally 0 sense with my character

Edit post

ISO #562 •••

Wait is daychat newspeak for DMs?


Disable them. Depriving scum of daychat is worth way more than an alignment-neutral hood, which iirc is what Airmax has.

Edit post

ISO #563 •••
--> @whiteflame

Because I’d rather die not at fault than die by being at fault

Edit post

Kick logic to the curb and do the impossible!

ISO #564 •••
--> @Mikal
Mine isn’t either. The singing portion is but only that. The popular and BP make literally 0 sense with my character


It's not completely off-base for my character in a vague sense, but it's not obvious.

Edit post

ISO #565 •••
--> @RexFavilla

I don’t think Airmax and him are scum



I think it’s likely they are both town



Airmax having that role as scum is useless because it’s confirmable. So that would be his role vs other utility mafia would need. The only thing as a scum role that has going is it’s viewed as a town role


awsomes role is in the op and kinda validates that role being in the game. Which to be fair he did say off the rip



I think it’s very likely they are both town given how the roles interact. But this will solve itself

Edit post

ISO #566 •••
--> @Vader
Because I’d rather die not at fault than die by being at fault


So you changed your mind because you realized being obstinate would be a bigger problem. OK.

Edit post

ISO #567 •••

Town pool


max

awesome (if this is a fake claim. It’s gorgeous)

myself

Luna

likely Thoth (am second guessing this a bit now)


Edit post

ISO #568 •••
--> @whiteflame

Sure

Edit post

Kick logic to the curb and do the impossible!

ISO #569 •••

I still think the more I think about this. It’s wf or supa. But wf basically said he had a power role that is town specific.

Edit post

ISO #570 •••
--> @Mikal

Yeah I'm coming around on this. My issue is why, as town, would you not disable PM communications? He should do that ASAP if its within his power. Max can confirm that it works. That way, unless they are both scum and lying (brazen gambit), we can basically confirm them while depriving scum of PMs.

Edit post