1990s-2000s Nostalgia Mafia (DP2)

Thoth I was not sold on as town. Was backtracking my read last dp

it will all make sense because there are portions I’m not saying yet. Just need to hear from the other 3 and I will type an essay then

Thoth I was not sold on as town. Was backtracking my read last dp 

it will all make sense because there are portions I’m not saying yet. Just need to hear from the other 3 and I will type an essay then

I’ll be really interested to read it because this is some baffling as shit logic and backtracking.

Vote Count

Not voting: (6/6): ILikePie, Awesome5000, Airmax1227, Rex, Mikal, Whiteflame 

With 6 players alive it takes 4 to lynch.

Day phase 2 will end on Saturday 9/20/2025 @ 6:00 PM EST unless there is a majority. 

Will all make sense

I’ll make sure to have some notes handy for this one, should be interesting to see what you claim your actual role is.

I’m here

Damn wtf happened last night

Why target awesome again?

Preliminary thoughts:

1) It’s likely that Unsaid targeted a townie, which is why he’s dead. I’ll look back in a bit to see who who he was sussing. Don’t know how there were 2 additional kills. 1 seems like the NK, don’t know how there is another

2) Whoever Luna targeted didn’t execute the NK, so that could provide some evidence in someone’s favor. Again, going to have to look back to see who he was sussing

3) A Caroler/Dreamer? (Mikal), Tracker (Vader), possible Watcher (Unsaid), and Lie Detector (Thoth) seem like wayyy too many town investigative roles.

4) With 6 players it’s either 3-2-1 or 4-2. If the TP can joint win, we’ve already lost. If they can’t joint win it’s LYLO. If there is no TP, it’s MYLO. Regardless I’ll reiterate what I’ve been preaching. PLEASE DO NOT VOTE UNLESS YOU ABSOLUTELY SURE

Role cus you said your affil lock. What names did you get.

could be a third faction, but this game is dumb. 

I’ve maintained since the beginning there’s a good shot there’s a TP in a 10p game

I had a way to lock scum and the way david processes results made it impossible. On god im just willing to yolo lynch to get to the next game. 

I’m confused as to what this means? What processes do you need to ask about as a Popular/BP/Caroler?

I need everyone to post and I’ll info dump. Same answer I gave wf.

Also will help to solve with your results

Might as well. 

I’m Dexter’s Laboratory. Justification says there’s almost nothing I can’t create or solve.

I’m the Doc/Cop. I copped Awesome innocent.

So a Doctor as well? Definitely don’t like this claim at all. At this point it’s a direct CC to Vader, Thoth, Mikal, and Unsaid

interesting, the game is solved

Care to explain for the slow ones like me?

Why target awesome again?

From DP1:

"As for Awesome, I don't love that he came back on, took his time claiming, posted that there was something up with the wording of his claim, and then just kind of dipped after dropping a pretty unique role. No doubt it fits with the rules of this game, and he seems to be relying on that entirely for his survival this DP, just peacing out as soon as he could rather than explaining himself at all aside from providing some light reads and a couple of responses to other points. It's weird and it sticks out."

Based on the OP, I believed his role was real, so if he was scum, it ruled him out as the GF. His role was non-alignment indicative, so he would only ever be in POE. I wanted to either have good reason to push him or take him out of my POE.

Seems to have been a crazy NP... I'll catch up on that in a bit...

For now just wanted to say that I recruited Mikal, got a "No results" reply... I asked if that means I was roleblocked and got essentially a "can't answer" reply... So it's probably fair to say I was RBd

Also, why the fearless claim? We just had three deaths in one night after being warned about a strong anticlaim mechanic, with much of town claiming DP1 regardless of that. Personally, I'm incredibly leery about further claims. I have no role which could account for the extra deaths. That's the first question that should have been asked. I've tagged Pie as well to ask him that question. If he also answers no, the onlyexplanation for those extra deaths is anticlaim. In that case full claiming this DP could lose us the game.

I can confirm that my role would not cause an additional death. Agree with the analysis that anti claim has to be responsible.

I think it's possible to solve this game without more full claims on the table. Given the circumstances, I think that full claiming may lose us the game even if we hit scum this DP by doing so if the mechanic is so strong that it can create extra deaths in the NP.

It really depends on which of the 3 scenarios I mentioned is here. I’ll say that I was hoping this game would go to at least DP3 for the best use of my role. Lunatic dying really was bad though.

i already had you locked for other reasons I will explain later but this further confirms it given David’s wording to you. It’s consistent with why I was bitching at the start of the dp

you said you were afill lock, I need you to tell me exactly why you are affil lock and like now. 

It’s because of my role

So a Doctor as well? Definitely don’t like this claim at all. At this point it’s a direct CC to Vader, Thoth, Mikal, and Unsaid

Yes, so obviously I'd make the very smart choice as scum to fake my claim in such a way that I would partially CC two flipped players and two other claims on the table. Certainly doesn't make me stand out as obvious. I understand not liking the CC, but come on man. Do you seriously think I'd give a fake claim as scum that CCs this many people and then decide to use it in full after that flip?

can you claim this. As it will contribute the solve.

also just need awesome now

What is your justification?

Any reason why you haven’t claimed your character and posted your justification?

Cus anti claim. I think I have a solve and don’t want to risk anything till we lock it in. I don’t need your character. What role are you ?

Can you confirm you got my list ?

I did not receive any list

hmmm

waiting on awesome and then I’ll actually post info dump

And since you seem to be saying you sent your Carol to Pie, why did you choose him? You had two players you showed were mod confirmed. Why Pie?

+1

Max was also solid town to him

What is your justification?

As I said before, the justification is that there’s almost nothing I can’t create or solve. I largely just assume the doc is because Dexter wears a lab coat. Can’t explain the cop at all.

Seems to have been a crazy NP... I'll catch up on that in a bit...

For now just wanted to say that I recruited Mikal, got a "No results" reply... I asked if that means I was roleblocked and got essentially a "can't answer" reply... So it's probably fair to say I was RBd

Interesting.