Suikoden Mafia DP2

No I think they got milich

and they had to make something work with it

skep did not write he is a healer in his pm. I can’t see any world where that is a justification

Scum getting one of the Great Generals as a fake claim is weird af

No I think they got milich 

and they had to make something work with it

That does make some sense. I got Pesmerga as my fake claim, but no fake role to go with him.

If you redirected me to poison somebody else or something crazy you should say so I can heal them

I did not do that.

What is your justification for healer.

It’s not. It’s a good fake claim. There are 5. Giving one to them makes perfect sense

This confirms it even more

if you got just a character. They got milich and wylted made that role up

Vtl wylted

fact check me. Milich does not heal posion. Liukan does

Skep writes 2 + paragraphs of justifications and you don’t have a reason why you heal?

I think healer was an afterthought to be honest because it says I am a master of botanical.arts which can be deadly and because of this mastery I am 1x poisoner and a 1x healer.

I didn't make the justification though.

I mean Milich is a botanist but he didn't create the antidote for the main poison he uses in the game.

I mean I could be wrong but this is so inconsistent with lore, I can’t buy it. It’s possible he did that but skep is way to into lore to just throw that in imo. Want to sit on it some more but lord it’s not consistent.

I'm having flashbacks to when everyone VTL'd Thoth in Alien Mafia because his character and role seemed sus af as reported, and he was innocent, so I'm not prepared to VTL just yet. Not when we haven't heard from everyone and collected all possible info from this DP.

When I outed my information from NP1, I was not as clear as I should have been, so let me clarify:

1. I learned that Shining was the night-kill.
2. I don't know whether or not wylted performed the night-kill.
3. I don't know whether or not wylted (tried to?) poison Shining, nor do I know what poisoning would have done, if it exists.
4. I cleared Mikal beyond a reasonable doubt.

I also don’t buy that. The only person who can heal this is Liukan and he’d be scum because he was a hermit.

JFC 5 pages in and it's not even been two hours? Going to try and do a quick catch up

Look at your pm And how in depth it is and tell me skep Fucked up. He’s also back tracking sayinf someone else could heal it in game.

Liukan isn’t in this game lol. I don’t even have to ask someone to claim cus it’s just not.

I mean debating if I want to kill him off that but it’s hella sus

I did some research on my role character and how it relates to Tir. I'm honestly no longer certain of Tir being a townie, but that's all what I will say for now.

I will consider this information unproven/uncorroborated, and thus null for now, but noted.

You don’t need to do a defense. It just whether I think skep made something inconsistent with the theme because of balance.

given how in depth all his pms are I’m struggling with this

The nk makes very little sense as shinning would have been a prime mislynch target.

Mikal, I'm not questioning your lore-lord credentials, but I think your lore-hammer is so strong that you are seeing everything as a nail. The idea of Milich having poison that can wear off makes enough sense without Liukan and a healing mechanic tied to him. A moderator can't perfectly align every game mechanic with a justification that sounds cool.

The nk makes very little sense as shinning would have been a prime mislynch target.

I had the same thought.

You need to claim your character today. You said you would if you were alive and we need some Claims or results.

chances are we get today and tomorrow so we all can’t just shit up. Need to start piecing stuff together.

and I was town reading you off your dp1 thoughts and now you are backtracking

Part of me has a hypothesis that the scum team cannot perform a NK and can only recruit but other townies /3p have the power to kill. This is something I"ll have to mull over

I’m not dismissing it. The posion does wear off

I’m just saying it’s very inconsistent