Madoka Magica - Episode 4

VTL Kohai

VTL Rex

Sorry man. Castin really sold you out.

Castin really should have just claimed commuter and would never have been lynched

I’m sorry you’re not gonna get your mislynch on me

Alright here we go

I got the Rolecop last night and rolecopped Rex as mafia

he is Kyubey and he is an escape wolf

I got his card and all that

Alright here we go

I got the Rolecop last night and rolecopped Rex as mafia

he is Kyubey and he is an escape wolf

So unless someone CCs you it’s Rex + whiteflame.

easy game is easy

also I was right all the way back at d1 that there was scum on my early wagon

Just curious why have you been so fixated on me this entire game?

Vote Count

RexFavilla (1/3) | Kohai

Kohai (1/3) | RexFavilla

Not voting: whiteflame, ILikePie5, Vader

Also I redirected Kohai onto Pie. Since Pie is the BP if there was no NK in the night it would indicate Kohai is scum and I blocked the kill

Rex and WF gg ez

Well I'll hold off on the GG ez but logic was simple

POE was WF, Rex, Kohai and I wanted to choose the redirect to Pie to at least get a 50/50 shot. What I didn't expect was to get a choice between a Permanent 1x RB and a Rolecop I could use. So I chose the rolecop and used it on Rex, while redirecting Kohai onto Pie.

Rex is 1000% scum at this point. I got his card and anything. He is Kyubey, and his role was if he gets lynched in the DP1 he survives and his recruitment role is revealed. It also talks about how he recruits magical and ignores the fact they are doomed to fight witches. He also accquired a 1x Perma Roleblock as well. He gains abilities based on who he does and does not recruit.

He got an accquired ability so he has recruited at least 1 person to the mafia.

I’m pretty sure the game is easy as pie (no pun intended)

We lynch Rex and then whiteflame. Pie hates being scum so unless he accepted the contract he can’t be the recruit.

He also is a confirmed BP at this point based on the CC. So he's 100% lock town

VTL Rex

Also I think the insta 1v1 between Kohai and Rex is pretty indicative of Kohai town, don't think scum would jump to that 1v1

If we lose we lose at this point, but I'm like 100% certain we won this game unless WF has some god ability

The only way he’s not town is if he accepted the contract and not knew what it was and then was like “oh shit”. But still I think common sense says the game is just whiteflame

I also don't have any redirects left. Realistically if we assume WF is the last scum he can't kill Pie, so he's either going to have to kill me or Kohai, which I think will likely be me. I was thinking about saving the redirect for next NP even when I got the ability, but we can at least get some form of an idea who scum is at this point

That's probably the only way IMO and tbh I could easily see him do that. I don't rule him out of being scum but he hates being scum and his reactions last DP to the 2 BP seem way too townie. Whenever he's scum at something and people complain he'll usually step aside but if he's town he goes at it hard, so he aligns behaviorally

Pie and Vader for MVP

Anyway going to come back in an hour. Don't think I have too much more to say atp so want to see what Pie thinks

Though I should get some credit for having outted castin by asking her to clam. If I didn’t she would have flown under the radar this entire game.

It was obvious at the end of the last DP that Rex was scum based on the info that Wryly provided, so I guess the TP gave him up. That also makes Kohai locktown since Wryly also said that one of the characters on that list was real, which at this point can only be him. Rex has pretty clearly given up defending himself, so he's going to be the given as a lynch this DP.

As for the second scum, it comes down to Vader for me at this point. Claiming he used the Role Cop on Rex is pushing the bus pretty hard, but makes a lot of sense when it was already obvious that Rex was scum. He clearly came into this DP knowing that much, as did his partner. Scum killed Mharman, so they could just have eliminated the Role Cop target and Vader just claimed it to push my lynch next DP.

Regarding the read on me, I'll point out that I could have won this game for scum just by choosing to lynch Pie instead of Wryly last DP. You guys put that up to me entirely to make the decision, and scum apparently shared the fake character claim list with Wryly so they would have known Wryly was lying about her character claim at minimum. All I would have to have done is hammer Pie and then Wryly would have been the auto-lynch when Pie's flip was confirmed this DP. It would be a baffling choice to give up my chance at an easy win.

As for the second scum, it comes down to Vader for me at this point. Claiming he used the Role Cop on Rex is pushing the bus pretty hard, but makes a lot of sense when it was already obvious that Rex was scum. He clearly came into this DP knowing that much, as did his partner. Scum killed Mharman, so they could just have eliminated the Role Cop target and Vader just claimed it to push my lynch next DP.

LOL

Are you CC’ing Vader?

I also don't have any redirects left. Realistically if we assume WF is the last scum he can't kill Pie, so he's either going to have to kill me or Kohai, which I think will likely be me. I was thinking about saving the redirect for next NP even when I got the ability, but we can at least get some form of an idea who scum is at this point

So, wait, did you use the second redirect or lie about having it?

Are you CC’ing Vader?

...Where did I say I was CCing him? I'm saying scum could be aware that they took out the Role Cop when they killed Mharman last night and just decided to claim Role Cop to look townie in the aftermath.

A random town person got an action last night. Since you’re not CC’ing unless pie CC’s then it’s obvious Vader is confirmed scum.

Unless pie counter claims he’s lock town.