Locked

MAGA Mafia DP2

Started by ILikePie5

Replies
192
Posts
193
Page
4 / 7

Conversation

Total: 193
ISO #91 •••

ATM I feel inclined to trust Whiteflame and his results

Edit post

I still don’t know what to type!

ISO #92 •••
--> @Magoroth
I understand distancing but I literally tried to lynch him yesterday


He would just hard-bus me.


these 2 statements from u seem to answer the "mystery"

Edit post

ISO #93 •••

Also my reads have been ass this game and if it weren’t for Whiteflame’s results, I would be sussing Banana rn


I might be washed folks


In Wylted we trust

Edit post

I still don’t know what to type!

ISO #94 •••
--> @wylted
It legit appears that David was Larping as Donald Trump in the beginning because he was intending to make that claim and than maybe there was bad communication in scum chat or plans changed and mago just took the claim



ya a couple people including myself and whiteflame also thought he was hinting he was trump lol

Edit post

ISO #95 •••

Shining was the one who claimed Trump

Edit post

I still don’t know what to type!

ISO #96 •••
--> @Shining
I townread Magoroth. Anyway, I'll fullclaim. I'm the Soldier, if I am the last townie alive, town automatically wins. My justification is that Trump survived a shitload of scandals and won 2016 after being considered a joke.


hmm that makes a lot of sense

Edit post

ISO #97 •••
--> @Mag1cman
Shining was the one who claimed Trump

i kno im saying that koha was pretending to be trump before that tho which is why we thought he was hinting he was him

Edit post

ISO #98 •••
--> @Mag1cman
I said that was my town pile headed into NP1. Yknow, before Thoth died.


Misread that, my apologies.

Edit post

ISO #99 •••
--> @Mag1cman
Still trying to figure out why Thoth is dead

not that hard to figure out tbh kohai was voting him from early on plus most people seem to have town read him

Edit post

ISO #100 •••

so we need to find out if rex visited someone or if magic visited rex because all others have claimed not to visit him so magorath could be lying here. thoth was the night kill and wylted was turned into a vanilla so there isnt much room for mafia to have visited rex if there is only 1 mafia left right? so if no one claims to have visited him that could confirm rex

Edit post

ISO #101 •••

oh yeah magic claimed he visited thoth, so the only way there can be movement is if rex himself moved right?

Edit post

ISO #102 •••
--> @Banana
⚠️ This comment has been marked as offensive.

Edit post

ISO #103 •••
--> @Mag1cman
Also my reads have been ass this game and if it weren’t for Whiteflame’s results, I would be sussing Banana rn

i dont get why tho, also u wanted to give margo a pass for voting kohai, even though i was the second one to vote him behind whiteflame, so ur kind of inconsistent

Edit post

ISO #104 •••
--> @wylted
Yes but if rex didn't move that confirms mago as scum, if he did move we can safely lynch shiny

or it proves that rex is lying if he says he didnt move. but either way it would point to a 50/50 between him and margo so it would be good


also btw what do you think the theme split is if its rubio and trump? that one doesnt make a ton of sense to me

Edit post

ISO #105 •••
--> @Banana
⚠️ This comment has been marked as offensive.

Edit post

ISO #106 •••

but ref should be confirmed because of whiteflames results. more and more this is seeming like it can only be magorath

Edit post

ISO #107 •••
⚠️ This comment has been marked as offensive.

Edit post

ISO #108 •••
--> @wylted

i was litrly just typing that lol


am i missing something or doesnt that confirm mago is scum

Edit post

ISO #109 •••
--> @wylted
Who is Ted Cruz again?

Like Rubio was a 2016 opponent and Cruz also was


correct, him and trump also hated each other during the 2016 election and were back and forth calling each other liars.

Edit post

ISO #110 •••
--> @Banana
⚠️ This comment has been marked as offensive.

Edit post

ISO #111 •••

vtl magorath

Edit post

ISO #112 •••
--> @Banana

if you were an early adopter of the Kohai lynch, then I missed it.


At any rate, you’re town confirmed.

Edit post

I still don’t know what to type!

ISO #113 •••
--> @wylted
Yes but if rex didn't move that confirms mago as scum, if he did move we can safely lynch shiny


Not that I'm leaning towards him atm, but if REF did move, why couldn't it be Mag1c? I don't think he'd try this with his Messenger claim, and it's possible he confirms himself tonight (maybe reason enough on its own to leave him this DP), but you're saying you've been townreading him and I'm trying to get a bead on that.

Edit post

ISO #114 •••
--> @wylted
Like Rubio was a 2016 opponent and Cruz also was


Yeah, starting to look like former opponents-turned-allies. Cruz would fit that bill alongside Rubio.

Edit post

ISO #115 •••
--> @whiteflame
⚠️ This comment has been marked as offensive.

Edit post

ISO #116 •••
--> @wylted
It could be magic. I just realized mago is Ted Cruz which fits the 2016 primary theory as well.


Yeah, that makes sense. I can see the argument against Mago, mainly just looking for REF to say whether he did anything NP1 before making a call.


Magic feels town to me. It's a behavioral read and strong gut feeling but the only evidence I have is that I don't think that David makes that mistake with magic in the scum chat


Yeah, he's feeling more townie to me this DP. I also find that hard to believe.

Edit post

ISO #117 •••
--> @wylted
Magic feels town to me. It's a behavioral read and strong gut feeling but the only evidence I have is that I don't think that David makes that mistake with magic in the scum chat

10000000000000000000000000000000%

Edit post

I still don’t know what to type!

ISO #118 •••

Past teammates can attest that I tend to make fake claims for my teammates.


And those past teammates are... Austin, Cerulean, and Thoth. You're just gonna have to take my word for it.


Fun Fact: Pie modded all three of those games. And he's modding this one, so he can't confirm either.


I played with Whiteflame in MMA Mafia, but he did his own fake claim iirc.

Edit post

I still don’t know what to type!

ISO #119 •••

Official Vote Count:


Magic (2/4) - Whiteflame, Mago

Mago (1/4) - Banana

Edit post

ISO #120 •••

So here's a thought: What if Kohai claimed Cop because scum blew all their questions, and Kohai was left with nothing?


Shining claimed Trump. Magoroth claimed Motion Detector, plus his character irrc.


Both were forced to claim before Kohai. I want to say on numbers that Magoroth looks slightly worse than Shining based on this theory.

Edit post

I still don’t know what to type!