MAGA Mafia DP2

You know what? The vanillizer might be meant to counter the soldier

Official Vote Count:

Magic (2/4) - Whiteflame, Mago

Mago (2/4) - Banana, Shining

I did not move. My role is actually incapable of movement during the NP. So either someone was redirected to me, someone is lying about visiting me, or Magoroth is lying about being a smoke detector.

Motion Detector, but yes, otherwise that's accurate.

I'm good with this lynch, though honestly, if people would rather lynch me to confirm my result first, I'd respect that. Just make sure you take out Magoroth next DP.

Also, should've removed this:

Unvote

Motion Detector, but yes, otherwise that's accurate.

lol i think hes just making a joke

Kohai - You are Marco Rubio. 

Wait Kohai straight claimed his character

If the scum theme is actually closet cases I'm going to howl.

Stop calling Magoroth "Mag" lol

Every time I think you're talking about me for .25 sec

I'll call you Mharm to avoid confusion 😉

cringe!

Ted Cruz + Marco Rubio?

Former Trump opponents? I think someone already suggested this but the fact that he straight claimed his character tells me that a teammate could have as well. But they have questions. Why try this? I think the chances are high that scum really mismanaged their questions.

It's possible they felt they could get away with claiming their real characters- but that's a big misplay because if it's Magoroth, Ted Cruz + Kohai, Marco Rubio, they made themselves super obvious.

Honestly? Neither has experience being scum in this format. I can kinda buy it.

But Magoroth's old community had characters and theme splits. Surely he'd know better, no? Overconfidence?

Apparently you cant discuss it on some other sites, so it could be a blind spot.

soldier and motion detector are both cringe but I kinda trust Pie that this is balanced somehow

you can't on MU

before that he was on SC2. I'm not sure on SC2 rules but good point

I'm going through ISO's on both hold on

Official Vote Count:

Mago (2/4) - Banana, Shining

Magic (1/4) - Mago

alr so, there's not much going on with Magoroth's ISO, outside of him picking Kohai over Rex. That's townie imo

His justification for Ted Cruz = Motion Detector is horrid, nonexistent even

I don't think we're in a mass claim type of position, so that was weird from him

Outside of that, nothing special

Shining is behaving like he normally does as town. Lazily and almost nonexistent. Actually kind of a scum tell for him when he does try a bit harder (This wouldn't be a scum tell if you tried a bit harder as town!). So, town points there.

And tonally, he just seems honest in everything.

Soldier is such a crazy role. The justification for Trump + Soldier does track.

I kinda townread behaviorally but it's so micro and therefore not something I'm super confident on

alr so, there's not much going on with Magoroth's ISO, outside of him picking Kohai over Rex. That's townie imo

well kohai did just claim cop and it makes sense that they probly thought he was going to die anyway to expose the real cop, so if that was the logic they would have likely thought a bus was smart. when i asked him why he voted for kohai he said it was because he doubted there was 2 cops but he voted him before the cop counter claim happened, so he really still hasnt answered why he suspected kohai. i think it was a bus

At the end of the day, Pie did something weird in this setup. Pie doesn't strike me as a three investigators type of guy, we discussed this privately after I got mislynched in Vader's game.

Honeslty I will respect that Soldier is hard to win with. You're forced to claim it at some point, scum could kill you at any moment (especially after you claim), the claim can get you mislynched, and this game has a vanillizer to dodge.

Shining's refusal to claim soldier last DP checks out with the role... and as for him being forced to claim... the role is ironically kinda garbage, despite seeming so strong, so I can understand his complaint here

we have a tracker/watcher on a confirmed townie, and Magoroth's justification is garbage.

normally this is where I'd say there's one thing I can't get around (here it'd be the vote for Kohai when he could've voted Rex), but honestly, screw it. Failing to get around that one thing has made me consistently wrong recently. Last DP I couldn't get around post 51 and was just wrong.

I see nothing towny about anything else, NAI at best, outside of the push for a mass claim, which I scumread

Outside chance he bussed Kohai knowing he was in no position to have a good claim. Kohai's cop may have been a premeditated risk because of the precarious position. I can see the partner avoiding looking paried with Kohai like the plague if that were the situation, and it really does look like it was.

So my decision's been made.

VTL Magoroth

Anyone have a problem with me hammering this? Figure you guys can lynch me next DP if he somehow flips town.

It's him or Shining. I don't care.

unless you want to hear his defense that badly

I'm not sure what he even has here though

like he can talk about his vote on Kohai, but looking at the situation, scum is basically forced to bus. so now what

the outside chance looking pretty likely actually

Pie doesn't strike me as a three investigators type of guy,

Motion Detector has a lot more conflict with Wylted's JOAT than a Dreamer would. Basically the same role, his is just weaker.

Whiteflame had a clearing idea on Shining last DP.

I don't think it's accurate. There's a chance Shining used all of his questions to find Trump.

It's actually common for Pie to leave a major character out of his games so scum can fake claim it

not gonna move my vote just yet but this is worth noting

I’ve seen his defense against much of this already, and I just can’t see him being town here. Wylted’s JOAT coupled with my Dreamer already seems like a lot of town investigative roles.

Anyone have a problem with me hammering this? Figure you guys can lynch me next DP if he somehow flips town.

i personally am pretty sold it is him, but do what u feel is best

Official Vote Count:

Mago (3/4) - Banana, Shining, Magic

Magic (1/4) - Mago