DebateCraft Players Mafia - Day 3

NGL if she would have claimed vanilla I think that would have been more believable but would be sus when one else claimed VT.

The theme split was supposed to be that town played on DART or DDO and scum started on DebateCraft. I had Wryly as scum because I thought she hadn't played Mafia on DART even though she was active on the site. Kohai told me that he thought Wryly played on DART as Castin. I asked Wryly, and she told me that her first Mafia game was Terraria, which started on DART and moved to DebateCraft as DART died. I guess the theme split kind of works out, but I wouldn't have had Wryly as scum if I knew about that. Magoroth was McDonaldsReal, who only played in Casey's Deltarune game. He was a Mafia JOAT with abilities based on McD's abilities in that game.

Funny enough, the scum players ended up being Wryly and Magoroth, who were the only players who didn't play on DART or DDO minus the kinda-sorta in Wryly's case. Random.org gave us a double theme split.

Shining was guaranteed town though. Why would wryly put her scummate in a fake carol with Pie and I? And he sent that message to you. And he said he wouldn't move tonight. And Wylted was the juicy lynch target.

Shining was pretty town anyway imo didn’t see him fake claiming as scum first post

Fun fact i was going to sub in for Magoroth since he didn’t show up but showed up before the end of the night phase so I backed off.

One of the suggestions I made was to fake claim Kohai as the Ban hammer - incapable of casting any non hammering votes and any other votes would result in a modkill. The justification being my love of ban hammers and my reputation of having more strict standards.

Them again I think that would also be a fairly retarded role.

What did the JOAT have

One of the suggestions I made was to fake claim Kohai as the Ban hammer - incapable of casting any non hammering votes and any other votes would result in a modkill. The justification being my love of ban hammers and my reputation of having more strict standards. 

Them again I think that would also be a fairly retarded role.

definitely would not have believed that lol

Bus Driver, Strengthener, Tracker/Watcher (Magoroth's choice of either, but only one), and a custom ability where he became a perma-Commuter if a randomly chosen Townie was lynched the next day.

meaning he was told a random Townie that night and then got the perma-Commuter if they were lynched

Huh, no TP? GG y'all.

What was I for the DPs?

Yeah, I put all the info about a possible 3P there just so I can include 3Ps in my future games and give info about them in the day 1 OP without confirming that there is a 3P. Sorry to misdirect y'all like that.

I had a hard time deciding whether or not the Caroler or their recipient could show up in a Carol. How would y'all handle it?

IMO once the caroler claims the POE goes from 3 to 2 very quickly.

Hated, Hated, Popular in that order.

I feel like that would be pretty powerful. What we have now is fine.

Also Thoth said that Pie proved his justification of Pie to be right on how Pie sometimes leads town off a cliff lol.

Neither should imo

Also Thoth said that Pie proved his justification of Pie to be right on how Pie sometimes leads town off a cliff lol.

I sometimes do. I don’t deny that I’m wrong sometimes. But more often than not, I’m right

I ran the Caroler as anyone who was alive after all other night actions had been processed could show up in the Carol.

Also Thoth said that Pie proved his justification of Pie to be right on how Pie sometimes leads town off a cliff lol.

Yeah, but he also proved the justification that he's good at Mafia, and boy howdy did he ever prove the justification about pinging people to hurry the fuck up!

Mass claim really worked out here for once

lol.

Yeah, but he also proved the justification that he's good at Mafia, and boy howdy did he ever prove the justification about pinging people to hurry the fuck up!

I totally called that this would be a justification for pie lol.

Pie did well too but come on I was cooking this game too lol

Definitely, you kept me sane in DP2 lol

Thread closed. I'll put up the endgame later tonight, but I'm not sure exactly when.