Giving reads as I said I would
1.Vader - I know I said I was sus of him before. Looking back, that was kind of dumb of me. I feel like he's been towntelling all over the place today, and being the un-CC'ed doc looks good for him. Town
.Whiteflame - One of the harder players to read, but I have been getting good vibes from him, and with him now claiming SJW, I think he's likely town or 3P, and I don't really care which tbh
3.Kohai - I kind of flip-flopped on him earlier. I think his claim is okay, but he hasn't been active today. Also not a huge fan of how he was trying super hard to get credit for the Thoth wagon
4.Banana - I'm going to be honest, I just do not see the case against her. Pie's push based on the evade/avade thing is utterly inane imo, though it is in-character for him. Other people have mentioned some DP3 stuff about her defending Helz. I didn't see that so I have no opinion there, I can only speak to what I've actually seen, and based on what I've actually seen, her behavior is very towny to me.
5.iLikePie5 - mechanically confirmed
7.Shining - has given me no reason to townread him, plus he's also claiming to be the silent one. Tbf he is, but I also know that I am called the silent observer in this game. I've seen him try to argue that this isn't how he plays as scum, but from what I've seen, his scum play and town play are very similar. I'm curious what he thinks the difference is.
8.Mestari - I'm actually inclined to believe the silencing is real, partially because I don't know why he'd fake being silenced here as scum, but also because of the reference to Transformers Mafia in DP1. I remember asking him about it and him giving me a really curt response.
9.Awesome - Has been flying under the radar and hasn't said anything this DP. Kinda nothing there for me to read.
10.Wryly - I've been liking her behavior all game. Well-reasoned, engaged, general good play, plus the cop claim kinda seals the deal for me. Town.
1 1.MagicMan - a little hard for me to read. I do think he's likely right about my injury coming from a fellow townie tho. I want to trust him, but I'd like to see more.
12. Skep - I wasn't there for what happened with him DP3 and him revealing Wryly as an investigative, but from the sounds of it, it's a pretty solid reason to townread him, and from what I've seen of his behavior, he looks town to me.
So yeah, PoE for me is Kohai, Shining, Awesome, and Magic, the last of these being less scummy than the others