And yes, I claimed Prince while reference a post seeding my pronoun thing for being given a female flavor but a male role.
Pretty sure when I first made that pronoun comment people picked up on how out of place it was without making the connection.
And yes, I claimed Prince while reference a post seeding my pronoun thing for being given a female flavor but a male role.
Pretty sure when I first made that pronoun comment people picked up on how out of place it was without making the connection.
And yes, I claimed Prince while reference a post seeding my pronoun thing for being given a female flavor but a male role.
Technically the Coroner is listed as a Prince as well, though we now know that's not a mechanic in this game and it wouldn't matter anyway since they're both town, but yes.
A-Deirdre wrote:
And yes, I claimed Prince while reference a post seeding my pronoun thing for being given a female flavor but a male role.
Technically the Coroner is listed as a Prince as well, though we now know that's not a mechanic in this game and it wouldn't matter anyway since they're both town, but yes.
I’d honestly be very surprised if enthrone left was VT and there wasn’t a coroner.
I’d honestly be very surprised if enthrone left was VT and there wasn’t a coroner.
The Coroner assumes a Traitor is in the game. We know there isn't one because we know the roles of all 3 scum. So what purpose would a Coroner serve?
A-Deirdre wrote:
I’d honestly be very surprised if enthrone left was VT and there wasn’t a coroner.
The Coroner assumes a Traitor is in the game. We know there isn't one because we know the roles of all 3 scum. So what purpose would a Coroner serve?
To counterbalance the illusionist unless I am misunderstanding the set up
I expected one. The thing I believe this setup is based off of is called Chicago. A variant of mafia where janitors clean roles/last wills and coroners invest checking the dead to get info and learn who visited them (depending on the version.) I said something about it D1.
But no. Im just VT. Part of why I was trying to look like a PR flying under the radar. That did not work out apparently.
To counterbalance the illusionist unless I am misunderstanding the set up
I guess that's possible, but I doubt it. I think the goal of the Coroner is to counter the Traitor, and it makes the Illusionist kind of pointless.
This is also why I so strongly thought there would be a Godfather btw.
Off the top of my head there were multiple potential roles that could screw with last wills and such in the setup
A-Llewella wrote:
This is also why I so strongly thought there would be a Godfather btw.
There was. It was Fiona. Read the flip as Godfather
A-Deirdre wrote:
To counterbalance the illusionist unless I am misunderstanding the set up
I guess that's possible, but I doubt it. I think the goal of the Coroner is to counter the Traitor, and it makes the Illusionist kind of pointless.
Fair.
A-Deirdre wrote:
A-Llewella wrote:
We should wrap up claims before we move into votes imo
Agreed. I believe you, Random and Caine have all claimed VT if I remember correctly. We all know I'm the Regent. That leaves Brand and Bleys. You guys both need to step up and claim.
Sure, I actually meant to claim earlier this DP. I am... A VT. I was trying to act like I had a good PR that I didn't want to out in hopes of baiting the NK. Obviously, it didn't work.
It's also why I was sus of the other VT claims. I wasn't expecting such a Vanilla-heavy game.
A-Brand wrote:
It's also why I was sus of the other VT claims. I wasn't expecting such a Vanilla-heavy game.
Same. Honestly a vanilla heavy game is kinda refreshing
Alright, so since no one else has claimed to be the Jailor, is that your role?
I am also VT. I've been out and about getting a new monitor and desk. I'm just about home and I should have time to work on catching up more before work. Especially as I can use a keyboard now that's not in Cyrillic
So I’m guessing since no one claimed jailer then Julius was probably the jailer
I’ll give more of an analysis when I get home from work. I wanna put my vote and pressure here for now.
1) I really dislike his constant angle shooting, OGI, and blatant rule violations
Lowkey I am tempted to do the same. I appreciate and respect Mag for his leniency, but I personally would have modkilled for that post.
My intuition is that scum are between (Random, Caine, Bleys). I could see any possible pairing among the three. Bleys does look much better in my eyes since the replacement but I'm always a little bit wary of highly experienced players (which the new Bleys clearly is). Cf Cerulean in his first two scum games on DART.
For what it's worth, I asked Mago some time ago and the Mafia would not be informed of the contents of the redacted role pm. When I was questioning why we we assume the jailor was alive it became important to know if the Mafia would have been told if the jailor was dead. I also confirmed that the jailor could execute in the same night they were killed.
Just to confirm no jailer I’m wondering if it’s best to now claim jailed / not jailed
Just to confirm no jailer I’m wondering if it’s best to now claim jailed / not jailed
Unfortunately, we know how that would turn out. There goes two potential POE reductions. Scum clearly lucked out.
Sure, I actually meant to claim earlier this DP. I am... A VT. I was trying to act like I had a good PR that I didn't want to out in hopes of baiting the NK. Obviously, it didn't work.
Seems like baiting the NK is what everyone was doing, and yet scum still got a PR NP1 in a town pool with literally two PRs. Crazy.
I am also VT. I've been out and about getting a new monitor and desk. I'm just about home and I should have time to work on catching up more before work. Especially as I can use a keyboard now that's not in Cyrillic
Well, cool that you got the monitor and desk. Damn that is a lot of VTs. 7 VTs, 2 town PRs, and 3 scum. I have a very hard time believing there's a 3P in here.
Automated Vote Count
This vote count was generated by the mafia vote bot.
A-Random (1/4): A-Caine (p#175)
Not Voting (5): A-Bleys, A-Brand, A-Deirdre, A-Llewella, A-Random
With 6 players alive, it takes 4 to lynch. Day phase ends in 1 day, 10 hours.
PC is set up but running very slowly. Might need to make sure everything is wired properly. I'll deal with that later. For now I'm going to be present in the thread if anyone has questions while I continue my read of DP2
A-Bleys wrote:
PC is set up but running very slowly. Might need to make sure everything is wired properly. I'll deal with that later. For now I'm going to be present in the thread if anyone has questions while I continue my read of DP2
if you had to vote now who would you vote?
Random.
Llewella, may you elaborate more on the game balance point you made here?
I will say for a second time Jailor should never reveal. Take that shit to your death if Regent is alive. I think its highly likely they exist because game balance may not be possible without Regent/Jailor both existing.
Being back on mobile there will be less direct quotes and a bit more brevity.
In the 150s Llewella does a lot of mech analysis. Mech analysis is NAI for the most part, with a few caveats I'm holding onto until I think over it a bit more.
In the 160s they begin to look at the wagons in the same way I did. I wish there was more consideration of the Brand wagon that proceeded the EoD wagons, but I see why Llewella mentioned the mind meld today and I'm feeling it too.
205 from Random continues to reinforce a feeling I've been having. There's so much effort into making a big deal out of maybe frustrated with anonymity and now there's the attempt to turn that into scumhunting. It feels strongly to me that the frustration is fake and this is all an angle to avoid engaging in behavioral analysis.
Question to everyone, I know the game changed from when signups were originally posted to when it went live. How much notice did you have that it would be an anonymous game?
In the 220s my question is, if Random blackmailed Oberon, he would know the condition tied to the blackmail and he would know if it was broken already. Why would he push to lynch someone who he knows will die?