Also why I am saying I do not care about some specific take and I just want reads with reasoning.
I am less worried about who gets lynched today and much more worried about what information we have to work with tomorrow
Also why I am saying I do not care about some specific take and I just want reads with reasoning.
I am less worried about who gets lynched today and much more worried about what information we have to work with tomorrow
@Pie, Wryly, WF
Which 3 players do you trust the least?
Catching up
I'll post a full read list tomorrow, but for tonight, I'm just going to keep it to who I have the most attention on.
Thoth and Ultra are in similar territory here. The latter is getting a little more credit for claiming and at least responding more often, but not much. Both need to be present this DP, both need to give thoughts, no matter how indecisive or uncertain they are.
I also just can't seem to get a bead on Mikal, and that's bothering me. I still don't really get the sudden pressure on Helz, which came in part from just sheeping Pie and leaning into the TMI argument for identical reasons, nor do I understand the sus he's throwing at Wryly over similar TMI, but this time with less certainty in the statement (she used the word "could"). I don't doubt that Mikal would overfocus on this stuff as any alignment, but it's getting excessive and feels more unwarranted than usual.
Helz wrote:
@Pie, Wryly, WF
Which 3 players do you trust the least?
Lol, didn't even see this post before I posted it, but see the above. Can't say I have strong opinions on Rex, Wylted or MeowMix, but they all look better so far.
Helz wrote:
@Pie, Wryly, WF
Which 3 players do you trust the least?
Ultra, Wylted, Thoth
Wylted's activity is hitting my as a little off. For example he says he states town should have let Kohai self confirm but he was the one to bring down the hammer, and though active he's contributed overwhelming fluff since his arrival
Well between us Thoth seems to be a common factor. I would favor going there
Automated Vote Count
This vote count was generated by the mafia vote bot.
Thoth (3/6): ILikePie5 (p#263), whiteflame (p#268), Helz (p#269)
Helz (2/6): Mikal (p#131), Ultracrepidarian (p#143)
wylted (1/6): MeowMix (p#216)
Ultracrepidarian (1/6): wylted (p#264)
Not Voting (3): RexFavilla, Thoth, Wryly
With 10 players alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Day phase ends in 1 day, 10 hours.
In loving Memory of Lannan and Ajab, fallen debaters.
Automated Vote Count
This vote count was generated by the mafia vote bot.
Thoth (3/6): ILikePie5 (p#263), whiteflame (p#268), Helz (p#269)
Helz (2/6): Mikal (p#131), Ultracrepidarian (p#143)
wylted (1/6): MeowMix (p#216)
Ultracrepidarian (1/6): wylted (p#264)
Not Voting (3): RexFavilla, Thoth, Wryly
With 10 players alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Day phase ends in 1 day, 10 hours.
In loving Memory of Lannan and Ajab, fallen debaters.
As stated Thoth isn't my first choice but I'm on board
VTL: Thoth
My lizard brain is thinking that there is 1 power wolf among town really playing but shooting into the lurkers has greater odds.
Ultracrepidarian wrote:
As stated Thoth isn't my first choice but I'm on board
Who is your first choice?
For that matter who is your 2nd and 3rd and 4th and 5th if you do not mind answering with reasoning.
I'm away from a computer right now give me a while
Ultracrepidarian wrote:
I'm away from a computer right now give me a while
Take your time but please do really respond. Not some random list of town/scum but talking about how you view players with real reasoning.
My first choice is Wylted by a substantial measure.
"What's wrong with losing two town players?"
That comment is a little peculiar.
"I feel like I should have given Kohai more opportunity to self terminate so we didn't lose the town kill"
Wylted was literally the person to bring down the hammer on Kohai
Combine that with his posting which is predominantly fluff, looking through ISO he's not really provided anything helpful
Oh crappers I somehow managed to misread is second quote 🤦♂️
wylted wrote:
I expressed a bit of regret about the hammer. It's NAI
As far as saying losing two town players is not a big deal it's consistent with my philosophy of the game. Which is that what matters is town directed kills and narrowing the scum pool for the end game if Kohai self deleted and we lynched ultra and he turned out town I would indeed see it as a positive because it narrows the scum pool. With that said I think ultra is scum
Eyhhhhh. Now that your here what are your reads and reasoning for them?
Do we still allow reworded PMs?
Gotta ask Luna (host) for that piece
I am just asking for reads and reasoning for those reads.
Gut is telling me 1 scum is prob between wylted and ultra. I dont think wylted would bus when this day phase is convoluted.
Really dislike how ultra keeps saying brb and going away
Atm my pool is
Ultra
Wylted
Castin
Helz
I also feel like wf is bullshitting his claim
Mikal wrote:
Gut is telling me 1 scum is prob between wylted and ultra. I dont think wylted would bus when this day phase is convoluted.
Really dislike how ultra keeps saying brb and going away
Atm my pool is
Ultra
Wylted
Castin
Helz
Can you give reasoning for each position?
Reading back on a iso he said he made a soft.
But I thought he was British. Someone thought he was jews and then he claimed Christian. Gut is telling me that soft claim was broad intentionally. Debating how I feel about that
Wylted is still the top of my list. His activity definitely feels different then what I'm used to with him, though I guess it's been a while since I've last played.
Obviously Thoth is number two on my lynch list.
The only other person I have as a scum lean is Pie. He's very known for being an aggressive player but he's been trying to fish out a full claim for the tinniest things at every single opportunity.
I still have no idea who MeowMix is but behaviorally I have a small town read on them, they have thus far been a considerable asset for town. Helz's strong activity also puts them on my no lynch list for today