Stereotype Mafia DP3

Wryly wrote:

ILikePie5 wrote:

Wryly wrote:

Does anyone here really buy Pie just handing scum an early-game freebie on who his character is. Especially with them not being given fake claims. Like I'm really supposed to believe this is the first time in history that whimsy overpowered his practicality.

1) It wasn’t a freebie.

2) No one even guessed it

3) I gave up cause women have cooties

Come on Pie. You know even if scum's best guess is that you're feminists they're still not gonna risk fake claiming women after that, so you still effectively narrowed their fake claim POE, which isn't like you. Also #95 is not something I should've had to point out to you, you should've thought of it before me.

You also realize that I thought #3 was the lie. So character doesn’t matter anyways. Don’t gimme any town cred for it, don’t really care.

As to #95, whether Wylted is TP or not will make me reevaluate Whiteflame. I said that was the partial reason, but there are other reasons as well, which I will divulge to Helz when he joins the masonry tonight

Wryly wrote:

What's your read of Pie and Mikal from mason chat

I wouldn't say it's solid town on either front, but I'm townreading both of them.

wylted wrote:

I give my reasoning here. It felt easier than writing it

https://youtu.be/zoRBcVtRYyE

So 1) why don't you think Pie would do reaction tests as scum and 2) your read on MeowMix feels a little vague.

Otherwise agree on Rex and Mikal and Ultra.

Wryly wrote:

Does anyone here really buy Pie just handing scum an early-game freebie on who his character is. Especially with them not being given fake claims. Like I'm really supposed to believe this is the first time in history that whimsy overpowered his practicality.

I'd just like to understand your thinking here. Do you believe he's more likely to do this as scum or as town? Because yeah, it's a step outside of his norm, but if there's a reason to view it as scummy, I'd like to hear it.

ILikePie5 wrote:

You also realize that I thought #3 was the lie. So character doesn’t matter anyways. Don’t gimme any town cred for it, don’t really care.

This is what I was expecting you to answer with but saying FOMO first has just really thrown me.

As to #95, whether Wylted is TP or not will make me reevaluate Whiteflame. I said that was the partial reason, but there are other reasons as well, which I will divulge to Helz when he joins the masonry tonight

In Helz we trust.

wylted wrote:

Pie is going to lose us this game. Watch him get gas lit into thinking rex is scum..

I mean you’re scum at best, TP at worst. Don’t really care cause ur not the same affiliation as me

wylted wrote:

Before me claiming TP you did a random 180 on me and considered me a better lynch target than ultra at random deviating from the night before. Would you like to explain your mysterious change of heart

There's nothing mysterious about it and you know it. If you're ready and willing to ignore most of my posts from the early DP, I don't see much reason to revisit them.

whiteflame wrote:

Wryly wrote:

Does anyone here really buy Pie just handing scum an early-game freebie on who his character is. Especially with them not being given fake claims. Like I'm really supposed to believe this is the first time in history that whimsy overpowered his practicality.

I'd just like to understand your thinking here. Do you believe he's more likely to do this as scum or as town? Because yeah, it's a step outside of his norm, but if there's a reason to view it as scummy, I'd like to hear it.

It's just a complete 180 from us having to put him at L-1 in Chicago Bears mafia just to get him to go from "I am one of these three" to "I am an event". I'm poking at a behavioral inconsistency.

The the best thing about this game is the mason chat ngl. Watching this shit is just god awful. At least 2 other people equally agree that this is retarted.

Like the fact anyone is even considering any of his reads or thoughts when he claimed vanilla, said he lied, claimed tp, then claimed scum and when someone listened to him, went back to vanilla. Im not even sure what thoughts to have

Yeet him and move on

Wryly wrote:

whiteflame wrote:

Wryly wrote:

Does anyone here really buy Pie just handing scum an early-game freebie on who his character is. Especially with them not being given fake claims. Like I'm really supposed to believe this is the first time in history that whimsy overpowered his practicality.

I'd just like to understand your thinking here. Do you believe he's more likely to do this as scum or as town? Because yeah, it's a step outside of his norm, but if there's a reason to view it as scummy, I'd like to hear it.

It's just a complete 180 from us having to put him at L-1 in Chicago Bears mafia just to get him to go from "I am one of these three" to "I am an event". I'm poking at a behavioral inconsistency.

It's a fair question, I just can't say it really does anything to how I'm personally reading him.

wylted wrote:

Then why aren't you voting. Let's say I am TP or scum . Let's say it's 60/40 me being scum you still know it's 100% that ultra is scum. Just use your brain and take out the guaranteed scum first.

Because my master Helz says he doesn’t want to end it.

Why don't you also consider this. You put me at L2 in mylo with 2 scum still missing from the DP and this was before my "confession" why did you do that retarded shit when you knew for a fact ultra was scum and that a quick hammer ends the game? What changed between the end of last DP and the beginning of this one for you and whiteflame to shift on me randomly?

Helz said scum know he was a Jew and was powerful, and you were blatantly looking for Jews yesterday. Not really that had

Wryly wrote:

whiteflame wrote:

Wryly wrote:

Does anyone here really buy Pie just handing scum an early-game freebie on who his character is. Especially with them not being given fake claims. Like I'm really supposed to believe this is the first time in history that whimsy overpowered his practicality.

I'd just like to understand your thinking here. Do you believe he's more likely to do this as scum or as town? Because yeah, it's a step outside of his norm, but if there's a reason to view it as scummy, I'd like to hear it.

It's just a complete 180 from us having to put him at L-1 in Chicago Bears mafia just to get him to go from "I am one of these three" to "I am an event". I'm poking at a behavioral inconsistency.

The circumstances of that game vs this game are different. The mechanical difference with Luna’s conditions inherently is an intervening factor that you’re failing to consider in terms of behavior “change”

wylted wrote:

Prior to your vote how did my behavior change to make me randomly scum from your prior days scum read just a few hours before?

..."randomly"?

Dude, I spent a large amount of time digging into you behaviorally last DP and explaining why I found you scummy, just slightly less scummy than Ultra. If you want to pretend I didn't ISO you and dig through just about every post and determine that you were not just a viable lynch target, but a very close second to the most viable lynch target, then that's on you, not me. I fully explained my read of you last DP. Read it.

If you want the explanation for why I'm scumreading you more than Ultra now, look back at the beginning of the DP. I'll wait.

ILikePie5 wrote:

Who is scum and why

Wylted, Rex, Mikal, Wryly is what I have in my poe rn. I'm extremely doubtful you and Mikal are a scumteam but both of you have pinged me. He just pings me more.

Rex actually improved yesterday at EOD out of all people and I didn't expect that but eh. It's a drop in the bucket.

I am still reading/skimming. What's your PoE? Also no lunch?

You are alive cus helz wants to stoke his epeen and try and and go autistic mode. This is literally pages of you lying, trolling, and just posting spam after you got caught. This is boring as shit at this point

I asked for a mass character claim after half of town had already claimed and softed yes. Because yesterday was going no where and that moved it along. Given the situation it was a good idea.

wylted wrote:

So at this point, it's clear that you were trying to bait someone into outing that they were the Jew.

Is this the post?

Do you think it's more effective for scum to be that direct than do what Mikal did and ask for a mass claim.

In this case, given what we are aware scum knew about Helz's character and how well you could pass off acting like the Jew hunter Hanz Landa this DP, yeah, I'd say it's "more effective for scum to be that direct" when that scum is you.

MeowMix wrote:

ILikePie5 wrote:

Who is scum and why

Wylted, Rex, Mikal, Wryly is what I have in my poe rn. I'm extremely doubtful you and Mikal are a scumteam but both of you have pinged me. He just pings me more.

Rex actually improved yesterday at EOD out of all people and I didn't expect that but eh. It's a drop in the bucket.

I am still reading/skimming. What's your PoE? Also no lunch?

Could you explain why Ultra's not in your POE?