From mafia - Game Over

Only 1 of us is scum (presumably). I know I’m not scum, so that just means it’s one of y’all. Question is who lol

Isoed pie and mago could be scum but lord it just looks like that was set up to mislynch him. Iuno

Magic over luna but luna is possible

And those 2 are still the only 2 that make sense to me

You are telling me that pie yakuzaed the above lol

Gtfo lol

Automated Vote Count

This system-generated vote count was posted on behalf of the main host.

Mag1cman (1/3): wylted (p#891)

Mikal (1/3): Mag1cman (p#862)

Not Voting (3): Mikal (p#839), Lunatic, Magoroth

With 5 players alive, the base elimination threshold is 3. Configured role modifiers may change vote power or an individual player's threshold. Day phase ends in 2 days, 20 hours.

If im wrong ill figure it out tomorrow but I dont see a world where he took mago.

Has to be magic or luna

Unvoting out of respect for a quick hammer but leave it there and ill go him after others give their thoughts.

Good its saying I unvoted. So declaring my intention with that in case I voted wrong

Wylted gun to your head. Mag or magic. Back peddling a bit and wana go luna first.

Magic as scum has no reason to not go for mago. Hes defending him

Scum magic goes with luna on that mislynch I think

This may just be luna and luna was watcher.

I still think we win if we shoot both but in good faith want to get the order right.

Luna or magic*

Did this same shit last game. My head says magic cus hes spazzy and the detract off pie

But my gut is screaming luna. Was like him and pie were tying to set up a mislynch on mago and luna will bus with a small on his face to win.

But magic defending mago makes no sense as scum

Do me a solid and iso pie and look to where he was claiming and what he did.

That just seems like something he would not do if magic was scum. Claimed a visiting role which tells me he went to magic. You think it could be luna. You are the only person im trying to solve with atm

Automated Vote Count

This system-generated vote count was posted on behalf of the main host.

Mag1cman (1/3): wylted (p#891)

Mikal (1/3): Mag1cman (p#862)

Not Voting (3): Mikal (p#839), Lunatic, Magoroth

With 5 players alive, the base elimination threshold is 3. Configured role modifiers may change vote power or an individual player's threshold. Day phase ends in 2 days, 19 hours.

Originally Posted by wylted on 9/1/2026 at 9:29 AM (post #831)

I think Pie was onto something tbh

VTL: Magoroth

I'm lowkey buying this as a real derp. If Wylted were scum he'd be more aware of that fact that his teammate is flipped scum. Instead it just looks like he thought Pie flipped town because he skimmed over something.

Originally Posted by wylted on 9/1/2026 at 12:54 PM (post #891)

Need you to help me solve. Cus i woild have picked luna or magic esp with luna behavior dp1

I will look closer when I get home. Your point about magic trying to throw off the pie lynch is a great point and he was waffling on voting the entire time. I think we definitely should punish that sort of thing tbh.

Pie also is going to put somebody in chat he enjoys interacting with. I will take your word that he likes magica company

UNVOTE

VTL: Mag1cman

Are you just ignoring the whole big ass post I wrote? #862 nigga come one now

I explained this already. I was gonna hammer PIe. Just wanted to get my thoughts out, plus I knew people sussing me for would ensure I made it to this DP, meaning I have a second result for my role.. At least you sussing me for it means it kinda worked.

Originally Posted by wylted on 9/1/2026 at 2:36 PM (post #904)

If Wylted were scum he'd be more aware of that fact that his teammate is flipped scum. Instead it just looks like he thought Pie flipped town because he skimmed over something.

I think you are misunderstanding my take.

My opinion is that his arguments don't cease to be good despite him being scum. It's a major issue that mago has an ability that banana who is generally on the lower end of active would give him a role that would require her to do a ton of extra unnecessary work

he’s throwing great shade on his own teammate then. I doubt it.

and if you think it’s Magoroth, why don’t you trust my results then?

Wylted wanting to lynch Magoroth is towny.

I would rather we just lynch Mikal straight-up, but btw, if we really want to we can force someone to hammer Magoroth. If we do this, you know my pick is Mikal.

And this idea is probably why Mikal wants to lynch Lunatic or I and why he doesn’t want to go with Wylted against Magoroth. Because then he has to position himself around not being the hammer which could look awkward. And someone else gets town confirmed, which shrinks his list of people he could get mislynched.

The more details I notice, the more I think Mikal is scum.

If you’re scum here, you don’t want Magoroth being lynched. The only two players who don’t want that are me (I would rather min-max shutting down Mikal’s ability 100%) and Mikal, who is hard pushing and Lunatic and I.

so it’s either Mikal or I. Lynch Mikal. And if it’s not him, you can lynch me.

Originally Posted by Mag1cman on 9/1/2026 at 3:09 PM (post #908)

Wylted wanting to lynch Magoroth is towny.

I would rather we just lynch Mikal straight-up, but btw, if we really want to we can force someone to hammer Magoroth. If we do this, you know my pick is Mikal.

And this idea is probably why Mikal wants to lynch Lunatic or I and why he doesn’t want to go with Wylted against Magoroth. Because then he has to position himself around not being the hammer which could look awkward. And someone else gets town confirmed, which shrinks his list of people he could get mislynched.

The more details I notice, the more I think Mikal is scum.

If you’re scum here, you don’t want Magoroth being lynched. The only two players who don’t want that are me (I would rather min-max shutting down Mikal’s ability 100%) and Mikal, who is hard pushing and Lunatic and I.

so it’s either Mikal or I. Lynch Mikal. And if it’s not him, you can lynch me.

Automated Vote Count

This system-generated vote count was posted on behalf of the main host.

Mag1cman (1/3): wylted (p#891)

Mikal (1/3): Mag1cman (p#862)

Not Voting (3): Mikal (p#839), Lunatic, Magoroth

With 5 players alive, the base elimination threshold is 3. Configured role modifiers may change vote power or an individual player's threshold. Day phase ends in 2 days, 18 hours.

Originally Posted by Mikal on 9/1/2026 at 10:22 AM (post #837)

Pretty sure luna is town but would never put it pass luna to bus.

My role is verified.

Want a claim list. Assumed wykted said Miller becajse someone said he means a cop is in the game

Question is who would pie yazkua.

David did not pick that pie did

Answer is luna or magic.

Magaroth I or wylted would never have been a yakuza target. I was casey and inactive pie would have picked someone to play with

Order should be magic and luna and game is solved

Bad argument. It was obvious Mikal was going to replace in for Casey the second Rex was lynched. One inactive + one replacement... you do the math folks.

Originally Posted by Mikal on 9/1/2026 at 1:30 PM (post #897)

Did this same shit last game. My head says magic cus hes spazzy and the detract off pie

But my gut is screaming luna. Was like him and pie were tying to set up a mislynch on mago and luna will bus with a small on his face to win.

But magic defending mago makes no sense as scum

Wasn't detracting from his wagon. Just exploring all the possibilities.

If I really wanted to defend Pie from a lynch, I would be pinging everyone with evidence, demanding we lynch someone not named Pie. Instead, Pie was basically pounding his fist wanting us to lynch Magoroth, and I didn't help him. His irritation with me is spew that reveals me as town. He thought I would eventually overthink my way into saving him. And when I didn't do it, he got upset.

Instead of trying to help Pie, I went on my own adventure, going out of my way to analyze the incentives of every player who could've possibly been OG scum. And had I died in the night phase, it would have been helpful to any townie paying attention to it.

Also, how does Mikal go from "I'm pretty sure Lunatic is town" to "my gut says it's Lunatic"

yeah, he's probably still gonna vote me first but

???

I said luna was town yesterday

Pie flipping and who he targeted makes me second guess that. I know pie didnt pick me. Think there is no shot he picked mago. Wylted is way less likley so its you its you or luna

You are doing the spazzy weird conspiracy theory shit and tried ti move off pie. You also would be at the top of who pie picked.

But looking back after pies flip and luna claiming vanilla (this dp) pie daid he watched you. Makes sense if he used a role on you and someone saw him go to you. Its a way to safe claim. So yeah luna seemed town but reading back with the flip and what we know, there is a possibility luna gave pie his claim after he was yakuzaed to see if they could get people off which is why luna is claiming vanilla. Luna would do that and bus. It also seems like he set up mago for a mislynch.

Im sure its one of you two. So dont care how we lynch. Just that it needs to be between you both.

Originally Posted by Mikal on 9/1/2026 at 5:15 PM (post #915)

I said luna was town yesterday

Pie flipping and who he targeted makes me second guess that. I know pie didnt pick me. Think there is no shot he picked mago. Wylted is way less likley so its you its you or luna

You are doing the spazzy weird conspiracy theory shit and tried ti move off pie. You also would be at the top of who pie picked.

But looking back after pies flip and luna claiming vanilla (this dp) pie daid he watched you. Makes sense if he used a role on you and someone saw him go to you. Its a way to safe claim. So yeah luna seemed town but reading back with the flip and what we know, there is a possibility luna gave pie his claim after he was yakuzaed to see if they could get people off which is why luna is claiming vanilla. Luna would do that and bus. It also seems like he set up mago for a mislynch.

Im sure its one of you two. So dont care how we lynch. Just that it needs to be between you both.

lol of course you would say you know Pie didn't pick you. But you don't have any argument against it.

And why would Pie be thinking about a watcher seeing him visit me? He claimed it so he clearly used one of his questions on it. At which point he has no reason to be concerned about it.

So from your pov you should be on me even more, but you're thinking about Luna because you need to keep your options open. We know you aren't going to have Magoroth as an option because that would town confirm someone with you dancing around not hammering him, or you

You're so scum it's painfully obvious. On results and behavior.

I'm shocked Magoroth and Lunatic haven't insta-lynched you. Wylted feels like a lost cause but I'll keep trying.

And yes, the thing about Pie was worth exploring. But I wasn't going to lead town off him. If that was my plan, boy did I get sidetracked analyzing literally everything else.

Call it spazzy all you want. I'm fine with people sussing me for it, but y'all need to recognize that it can be literally no one else but me or Mikal.

I have a role that makes sense. I have results that clearly incriminate Mikal. And Mikal has been doing everything he can to ally with Wylted and push Lunatic and me with bad arguments.

Pie won't recruit Magoroth bc Magoroth was already sussed DP1. He won't take Lunatic because he's signing up to bussed by Lunatic if he does that. With how hard he fought that, I doubt it.

His options are Wylted, Mikal, or myself.

We can rule out Wylted on behavior. No scum would want to mislynch Magoroth here because of his role.

Again, down to Mikal and I.

You can call a few of my posts sus, but that was by design to ensure that I survived into this DP, so I could get a result with my role. You can say that people appreciate, and sometimes double space, but you can't argue that those two things plus the writer of that message putting mikal as the 1 in the 1v4, amounts to nothing. It's way stronger than y'all are giving credit for. Just look where Mikal was last DP. Completely in the background. Look at what he's doing this DP, going for Lunatic and I specifically, trying to buddy with Wylted, avoiding Magoroth. Look at the fact that Pie blatantly copy-pasted a part of his post from the scum chat last DP, indicating that an experienced player like Mikal was helping him.

Please, do not ignore what I have to say here. Take the time to understand and appreciate it. And Wylted for the love stop letting Mikal snow you so easily.