Islam and Secularism are mutually exclusive

Started by GajarMooli ·

You can't be a leftist, and support Islam. People in the west have made a point that supporting Islam is a left wing ideology, while right wing typically means white and Christian people. And this trend seems to be copied in other parts of the world including India, where right wing is Hindu, and left means someone fine with Islam.

Left is being looked at an ideology that says "don't care, let em do ANYTHING they want", by left, here I mean the particular branch Secularism. But on the contrary Secularism says "don't let em do ANYTHING they want"

Islam is a death cult, a barbaric cult. Death to the kafir is the law in Islamic scripture, polygamy, triple divorce, incest, women forced in Burkhas and reduced to objects, children subject to circumcision in the age they can't consent, Jihad, required reciting of prayer 5 times a day, which happens in all Muslim countries and even In India, using a loud speaker, beheading sheeps on Eid for the sake of sacrifice. Everything Islam does, Secularism says to do not. Secularism says let people be free, don't integrate your religion in the society, And Islam has volumes written on how the society should function.


Sometimes I think, who might be the idiot who even associated the left and islam together

Where do you stand?

Sign in to share your stance.

Your stance can change. Your earlier arguments stay where you posted them.

For 60% · 3 Undecided 20% · 1 Against 20% · 1

5 participating members

Arguments for (0)

No arguments for this motion yet.

Arguments against (2)

Islam is Incompatible with Heathenism, not Secularism

There have been plenty of overwhelmingly Muslim-majority yet secular countries. They also live as minorities in many such countries. Furthermore, Muslims were perfectly capable historically of living under the rule of other religions which don't practice shirk. The only systems of rule which Islam is fully incompatible with is heathen rule.

1 like

Exceptions aren't an argument against the general case.

Pakistan, Iran, Iraq, Palestine, Afghanistan, you can't live a secular life in any of these nations. In Saudi Arabia, recently a beheading happened because of 'blasphemy'

Islam dictates the way a person shall live, and how a society should function, that's an undeniable fact. Islamic studies consist of volumes of books of law, those books contain laws which aren't even compatible with Human rights.

0 likes

Replying to GajarMooli

There is no 'general case', you made the claim that they were mutually exclusive. That means that they cannot coexist. The very existence of Albania, Turkey, or Azerbaijan disproves that claim.

0 likes

Replying to RexFavilla

I don't consider a country that banned Hijabs in schools a muslim country. turkey ? The nation with highest rising atheist population? The society that has become mostly Apathetic? Lol

Your best argument is countries that don't even practise Islam, islam is living by the values of quran, and most people in these countries haven't even read a page of quran. I am not pulling data out of thin air, you can just google it. Identifying as a muslim just for the sake of ancestry and living by quran are different things, countries having laws against islamic practices are not Islamic countries

0 likes

Replying to GajarMooli

Turkey is at least 90% Muslim. 'Highest rising atheist population' doesn't mean much when they are still a tiny sliver of the population. No-true-scotsmanning and moving the goalpoasts are pretty pathetic at this point - maybe just admit that you were talking out your ass instead of furiously asking AI to come up with irrelevant facts?

1 like

Replying to RexFavilla

It's not a "no-true-scotsman" !

Seriously, over 1 billion people identify as Muslims, across all continents, they speak MANY MANY Languages, wear different cloths, have all the differences. When people have so much differences then separating a major fraction out of an exception is not at all a fallacy, a muslim from Pakistan lives a completely different life from a muslim in Turkey despite being the same branch of Islam.

No society is truly theistic or truly atheistic.

Why are you lying? Islam has clear laws on how a society shall function, those countries which don't even stick to those laws are Muslim countries to you ? And separating them is no true Scotsman fallacy ? Clearly not all people who identify as Muslims practice Islam. Islam requires 5 time praying a day, girls covered in Burkhas in front of every strange man(strange defined as not father, not real brother and husband), accepting polygamy, "triple talak" (say 'talak ' thrice to divorce a woman, can only be used by men to divorce women anytime). Plus, Turkey is mostly apathetic like India, Turkey is closer to India than Pakistan despite both following different religions, taking laws and stuff in account. No society just goes from religious to atheistic in a day, and turkey, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan are slowly picking up their pace with apathism, to become an atheistic state.

I am not falling for your stupid

"No true Scotsman" argument, which puts all people who identify as muslims in a bucket despite the muslims not agreeing themselves!

0 likes

HOW DOES RELIGION AFFECT POLITICAL IDEOLOGY

How can you religion determine what you are politically, I'm Christian, can I be a liberal though, or is there only a set ideology that I can have?

0 likes

Well, a religion could affect moral values and those could affect views on political policy. For example, a Muslim is unlikely to believe everyone should be forced to eat bacon or that Muslims should not have religious freedom. But yes, technically people in most religions can still hold a wide range of beliefs.

0 likes

Religion is basically respecting/believing in some certain God, and obviously some trash book, some thousands of years old. And those thousands of years old book contain shit about how the society shall function. And somehow it ended up being contradictory to human rights after some thousand years, either believe in the current political system or the older one. Or are you schrodinger's Muslim ? Islam says kill the non believer, fast, man can marry upto 5 women, women can't do the same, women be put in burkhas, public beheadings for blasphemy and shit. And no, if you don't believe in public beheadings and call yourself a modern muslim you don't become a modern person. Modern muslims are muslims who cowardly hide their scriptures' radical elements behind the veil of metaphors. And those walking contradictions still have retarded believes !

0 likes