Magic has an effect on reality

Started by SatanLucy ·

Enemies of magic say there is no scientific evidence for magic rituals having any supernatural effect on reality.


Practitioners of magic say magic has observable scientifically verified effects on reality, such as affecting minds of those who practice magic, increasing their confidence, altering their thoughts and behavior, reducing their anxiety, reducing stress, affecting the way they form relationships, affecting their surroundings as some magic rituals require creating ritual spaces, all which affects reality directly, all while supernatural effects remain undisproved and possible.

Where do you stand?

Sign in to share your stance.

Your stance can change. Your earlier arguments stay where you posted them.

For 20% · 1 Undecided 0% · 0 Against 80% · 4

5 participating members

Arguments for (1)

Actual verified effects

1. Psychological effects

Rituals can influence the person performing them:

  1. Increase confidence.
  2. Reduce anxiety.
  3. Change expectations.
  4. Influence decision-making.
  5. Produce placebo effects.

These psychological changes can indirectly affect real-world outcomes.

2. Physical effects

Some rituals involve actual physical actions:

  1. Burning substances produces chemical reactions.
  2. Drinking ritual preparations can affect the body.
  3. Repeating actions can establish habits.
  4. Group rituals can influence social relationships and behavior.


1 like

The results you attribute to magic can be explained without appealing to mystery. For instance: placebo effect, 'hope-doping', chemistry, and physics. What need have we for "magic" as an explanation?

1 like

Replying to SkepticalOne

You need magic as explanation because to achieve those effects, person must believe in magic.

0 likes

Replying to SatanLucy

You need a magic for "magic" to be an explanation. You're creating explanations out of whole cloth to explain what has already been explained. I remain unconvinced magic is a real thing much less that it has any effects on reality.

0 likes

Replying to SkepticalOne

Magic doesnt need to be real in order to have effect on reality. Thats why its supernatural. Even if it wasnt real, person who believed its real would be affected by magic.

0 likes

Replying to SatanLucy

This is equivocation. You're conflating supernatural magic with the mental construct of magic. The mental construct is real and can drive behaviours. Real magic has not been established to exist and a direct causal link to effects on reality is equally unsubstantiated.

0 likes

Arguments against (2)

Idiotic Take

Promotes Superstitions


Prove it, or it's Superstition.

As simple as that


Even kicking a rock has an effect on reality, so we can even say that kicking a rock has an effect on reality and post it on debatecraft, but talking about magic and rituals it's all bullshit to say that the rituals are having an effect


In India many people are taking "homeopathic-Pseudoscientific tablets", and getting well too, but they aren't getting well due to the medicine, but placebo effect.


I hope whoever wrote this article is getting the difference I am trying to establish

1 like

Rituals having effects is not the same as magic having effects

Rituals may have effects, but since they can presumably be studied, whatever the cause is would be science, not magic. Even if we could summon spirits from the underworld, presumably we could then form hypotheses about the spirits, test those hypotheses, etc. Magic that exists is no longer magic, so these effects are caused by science, not magic.


The description mentions magic rituals, but I'm taking the resolution at face value, which talks about magic itself having an effect.

0 likes

Magic rituals are part of magic. Also, magic being scientifically verified is still magic. It doesnt stop being magic just because science proves it true.

0 likes

Also, topic isnt "magic has supernatural effect on reality", just an effect.

0 likes

Replying to SatanLucy

But it still needs to be magic having the effect even if the effect isn't supernatural. What exactly makes something magic in your opinion?

0 likes

Replying to Savant

It doesnt matter what makes something "magic". Mere existence of concept has effect on reality. Mere belief in supernatural has effect on natural. In fact, you merely arguing about magic already proves magic affected reality by making you argue about it. So supernatural even if it doesnt exist still affects natural.

0 likes

Replying to SatanLucy

The idea of magic affected reality, but the idea of something is not the thing itself. Maybe magic affected the idea of magic, but not if it doesn't exist.

0 likes