Kermos
@linate wrote in post #55: @Kermos Thank you …snip… However, I don’t think your objections actually overturn the evidence for the Big Bang or require belief in a 6,000-year-old Earth. …snip


Thank you for coming back with what apoears to be your own words.


Please notice the difference between the thread title “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith” versus that you wrote “overturn the evidence for the Big Bang”. I’m making the case that the Big Bang is a belief, not fact.

1. Redshift is merely an untested assumption.

The Doppler effect for light is specifically for light. Scientists teach that light is massless thing called a photon which travels at 186,000 miles per second without anything exceeding that speed.


Review your writing for a massless thing called “light” being affected by the Doppler effect for light in “…snip…The Doppler effect for light has been tested countless times in laboratories. We routinely measure Doppler shifts from moving atoms, lasers, satellites, spacecraft, police radar, binary stars, and galaxies. Modern GPS systems even require relativistic corrections involving frequency shifts.” Binary stars and galaxies must be removed from the list as they are under scrutiny as the debated matter (you inserted them into your argument as if they are in fact red-shift):

  1. “atoms” are not massless, so atoms are excluded as proof of the Doppler effect for light.
  2. “lasers”, or more specifically, laser is an acronym for “light amplification by stimulated emission of radiation”, and they are “Any of several devices that emit highly amplified and coherent radiation of one or more discrete wavelengths. One of the most common lasers makes use of atoms in a metastable energy state, which, as they decay to a lower energy level, stimulate others to decay, resulting in a cascade of emitted radiation.” (See American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fifth Edition. Copyright © 2016 by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. Published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. All rights reserved. on www.thefreedictionary.com/laser, so a red laser radiates red light as per an instrument’s calibration, but lasers are not emmitting light that is the Doppler effect of light. Lasers are excluded as proof of the Doppler effect for light.
  3. “satellites” measure not the Doppler effect for light. You failed to show your work as support for your belief, so satellites are excluded as proof of the Doppler effect for light.
  4. “spacecraft” measure not the Doppler effect for light. You failed to show your work as support for your belief, so spacecraft are excluded as proof of the Doppler effect for light.
  5. “police radar”, or more generically radar is an acronym for “radio detection and ranging”, so they measure not the Doppler effect for light. You failed to show your work as support for your belief, so police radar are excluded as proof of the Doppler effect for light.
  6. “Modern GPS systems”, or as class of device, GPS is an acronym for “global positioning system”, so they measure terrestrial locations not the Doppler effect for light. You failed to show your work as support for your belief, so Modern GPS systems are excluded as proof of the Doppler effect for light.


I showed my work in section “1. RED-SHIFT … RED-SPECTRAL” of it’s second subsection “Waveforms, it gets worse for red-shift conjecturers” of post #53 which demonstrates that red shift is merely red spectral.


All of your enumerated proofs failed to manifest the Doppler effect for light, so you have shown that Redshift is merely an untested belief without proof (assumption).

You neglected to address section “1. RED-SHIFT … RED-SPECTRAL” of it’s first subsection “Redshift collapses under the Scientific Method” in post #53.


You wrote “…snip…Furthermore, the cosmological redshift is not simply “the Doppler effect.” General Relativity predicts that as space itself expands, the wavelength of light stretches. That prediction matches observations extremely well”, so I point you to post #61 which demonstrates - even according to Stephen Hawking - the error of General Relativity based observations.


In your writing of “…snip…You also mention a quasar apparently embedded in a nearby galaxy…snip…none has overturned the overall redshift-distance relationship that is supported by millions of galaxies rather than one disputed example…snip…If one bridge has a crack, that doesn’t prove every bridge in the world is unsafe”, you convey as distinct “fact” (please see the Pharmakeia Principle outlined in post #71) there is only one such quasar, but the authoring team of “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper including Geoffrey Burbidge, noted professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences, discreetly enumerated far greater number of such quasars in the referenced paper than your one such quasar.


It’s not one bridge that has a crack for the Big Bang, @linate, your bridges are riddled with cracks and collapsed. The red-shift cracks. The CMBR cracks. The quasar-galaxy bridge is a thing according to astronomer and astrophysicist astrologers.

2. The Cosmic Microwave Background was not predicted


You wrote “…snip…The Cosmic Microwave Background was predicted before it was discovered” about your original words of “In 1965, astronomers accidentally discovered faint microwave radiation coming from every direction in space”, yet McKellar documented (potentially discovered (there may have been someone before McKellar)) the microwave radiation in 1941 before Gamow before Penzias and Wilson in 1965. You are doubling down on the false “fact” that, in your words, “…snip…A prediction being made before an observation is exactly what scientists hope for”.


The section “2. Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR)” of it’s first subsection “Scientist’s, er, philosopher’s public CMBR deception” stands intact as previously demonstrated here and in post #53.

3. The McKellar measurements were measurements of the CMB


Read this first sentence of the abstract from “A Review of the 1941 to 1961 CMBR Temperature Measurements” (by Patrick Bruskiewich of the Vancouver Institute for Advanced Studies)

In this paper I will review the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR) Temperature Measurements collected by the Canadian Astronomer Dr. McKellar in 1941


You dismissed through salacious statements like “…snip…The McKellar measurements were not measurements of the CMB…snip…Comparing those numbers as though they were repeated measurements of the same thing is not valid…snip…sets doesn’t tell us whether two experiments measured the same physical quantity” reveal your belief is errant because McKellar measured the same thing, CMBR, as Penzias and Wilson. By the way, Dicke et al (1965) were the party who claimed to calculate the existence of the unknown known (scienced) CMBR (you call their work “prediction”).


The section “2. Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR)” of it’s second subsection “CMBR UnSETtling Theory” stands intact as previously demonstrated here and in post #53.


Your wrongful dismissal of McKellar’s CMBR work leads to you neglecting to address section “2. Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR)” of it’s third subsection “CMBR Average Disformity” in post #53.


You neglected to address section “2. Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR)” of it’s fourth subsection “CMBR Logical Conclusion” in post #53.


Your CMBR decreasing in temperature over time is disproven by the data leaving you with a leap of faith for your Big Bang.

4. Linguistics: two mutually exclusive types (1) of truth (2) of deception


Scientists abnormally use words in order to sound authoritative as well as to project their beliefs as scientific fact.


The word predict is composed of the prefix “pre” meaning before and the root “dict” meaning speak. The technical basic meaning for the word “predict” is “speak before”. The normal definition of predict is:

v.tr.
To state, tell about, or make known in advance, especially on the basis of special knowledge: predicted an active hurricane season because of warmer ocean-surface temperatures.
*v.intr."
To foretell something
American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fifth Edition. Copyright © 2016 by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. Published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. All rights reserved. on www.thefreedictionary.com/predict


Scientists do not “foretell” (predict) a past event. Your dinosaur bone location example is akin to the hurricane formation prediction example in the definition of predict. Both are based on existing human witness of a thing (thing=dinosaur aka dragon aka behemoth aka Loch Ness monster footprints) (thing=warm ocean) and the potential future human witness of a related artifact (artifact=bones) (artifact=hurricane). The 13.8 billion year past Big Bang fails to qualify for prediction (foretell) because the Big Bang is not a future event.


You wrote ‘…snip…“Prediction” is not limited to future events’ which is a false statement and abnormal linguistically, and you extended your Pharmakeia Principle (see post #71) exhibition with your “…snip…Likewise, cosmologists predicted that if the universe began in a hot dense state, then today we should observe a microwave background with specific properties. That prediction was later confirmed” which, by definition, is not a prediction.


Your whole ‘4. “Prediction” is not limited to future events.’ section is your display of the Pharmakeia Principle (see post #71).

5. Your broad Scientific Method description converges in faith/belief


Your “…snip…You repeatedly state that because nobody can recreate the Big Bang in a laboratory, it isn’t science” is not what I have written. Please do not misrepresent my writings. I distinguish between the Pharmakeia Principle (see post #71) grandiose term “science” and the scientific method.

Distinguishing between historical conjecture and the scientific method.


A person either believes or disbelieves the historical record of human witness; in other words, one either believes a historian or not. Where there is no human witness, there is historical conjecture. Things in the classification of historical conjecture are not the scientific method. The Big Bang is in the historical conjecture (guesswork) class because no human observed a natural phenomenon called the Big Bang.


The scientific method’s first phase is a hypothesis. A hypothesis requires an observed natural phenomenon as part of the hypothesis. The original post’s reference to LiveScience indicates as such even going so far, in essence, to exclude belief/faith. Without that human witness, you have a belief/faith which is specifically disallowed for the scientific method.


Your objections in your “5. The Scientific Method is broader than your description” section are outside the Big Bang as belief scope of this thread with the potential exceptions of “…snip…astronomy” and “…snip…supernova”, so I discard your other objection points.


If you want to delve into a detailed explanation of your objections embedded as per your “astronomy” and “supernova” arguments, then you will need to elaborate to me.


As it currently stands, your complaint that “if this is true, then that is broken” fails to show that your red-shift is anything more than red-spectral and fails to show that your CMBR was a lesser temperature in 1941 as compared to 1965.


In a similar vein, you claiming “…snip…The Big Bang has survived many such tests” lacks scientific fact explanatory support from you in this thread. You making an unsupported claim does not make the claim a scientific fact.

6. The amount of data and the amount of time are important

Your detective case disected

Crucially, the entirety of your detective example is in human witness timeframe.


Whether a murder victim corpse was found makes a difference. Two competing alternatives exist:

  1. with a corpse: identification of perpetrator(s) may proceed through investigation of means, morive, and opportunity, but the original detective(s) didn’t build a case with all the evidence 20 years prior, and the vast majority of cold cases remain unsolved.
  2. without a corpse: qualifies as a missing person case. Again, the original detective(s) didn’t build a case with all the evidence 20 years prior, and the vast majority of cold cases remain unsolved.


The “with a corpse” bullet point represents a realistic scenario.


The “without a corpse” bullet point is closer to the Big Bang Theory, but the second bullet point represents you making an unsubstantiated claim.


Nonetheless, both bullet points are in human witness period, so both bullet points are substantively divergent from the Big Bang.


Your statement “…snip…Every distant galaxy is effectively another data point” applies to belief. I believe every galaxy points to God. You believe every galaxy points to the Big Bang.


The Zenith Model of post #53 remains intact.

7. Your faith-based cosmic distance ladder


This current post’s first few sections demonstrated your error regarding the nonsense nonscience red-shift as well as your CMBR deception of decreasing temperature as time progresses; in other words, major rungs of your cosmic distance ladder are broken thus a leap of faith, but it gets worse for you!

I provided triangulation angle deficiency for parallax over purportedly massive distances in the Episcopic Model of post #53.


Now, the debate moves on to yet another rung of the cosmic distance ladder, and this shows the rung is missing.

Cepheid variable; faith not fact


Astronomers believe Polaris is the nearest Cepheid variable star to Earth, at 445.5 light years (2,673,000,000,000,000 miles). Polaris is commonly referred to as the North Star.


Polaris’ minimum and maximum diameter in miles at Polaris is unobserved by astronomers, and any temperature change for Polaris is not measurable at Polaris by astronomers.


Astronomers possess no luminosity data at the source for Polaris, but astronomers do possess brightness data at Earth.


And, finally, astronomers never accurately measured the distance from Polaris to Earth - see the Episcopic Model (spatial limitations, too vast a visage) in post #53.


Astronomers do not collect sufficient, complete, and accurate data at 2,673,000,000,000,000 miles (2.6 quadrillion miles) from Polaris, the nearest Cepheid variable star, nor any other Cepheid star for comparative parallax measurements which astronomers believe are more distant from Earth.


Astronomer Henrietta Swan Leavitt published a 21-page account of her work “1777 Variables in the Magellanic Clouds” in 1908 with more astronomical work before her death in 1925. She believed that observing a Cepheid star’s pulsation period results in astronomers knowing the luminosity at a Cepheid star thus astronomers believe they possess sufficient information to determine fantastic Interstellar distances. Based on Leavitt’s work, astronomers believe they can use the luminosity of a Cepheid star in the inverse square law, which requires knowing either the distance or the luminosity at source, to determine the distance to Cepheid variable stars, and they further believe that they can hopscotch hugely gargantuan distances using these “known” (truly unknown) luminosity (of a star at the star) illogically based on observed brightness (of a star at Earth) calibrated with parallax distance to Polaris (or another Cepheid star with a “known” distance from Earth) which results in the distance to another star.


Cepheid variable nonsense nonscience is your prophetess Leavitt and her progeny preaching the abundance of light and parallax of your star bible’s millions and billions of light years away with millions and billions of years in the past.


Rewind to the foundational star bible contribution by Leavitt in which astronomers use an unobserved luminosity to calculate a star’s distance. Astronomer astrologers cannot determine the luminosity, which requires measurement at the source star, of a Cepheid by observing the change in the star’s brightness, which is a measurement at Earth - such brightness-to-luminosity extrapolation is a leap of faith.

Your cosmic distance ladder bullet list is a bust list


Your bullet list contains several points that range from duplication to absurdly fictitious (i.e. “Radar inside the Solar System” - radar is a man-made instrument); furthermore, you wrote “…snip…If one rung failed, the ladder could collapse”, and I have shown multiple failed rungs (red-spectral, CMBR increase, Cepheid light error), so the cosmic distance ladder collapsed into a leap of faith for the Big Bang - the cosmic distance ladder is busted.

8. The Big Bang is evolution religion

Please stop changing my words to “science” and “cosmology”.


Big Bang adherents have a god that they call universe.


I heard people say “it’s what the universe wanted”.


You and others dogmatically push your god named universe.

9. Jesus Christ is Maker of all the Heavens and Earth and all that is in them, seen and unseen

In your closing paragraph, you started with “…snip…As Christians, we”.


If you are a Christian, then you believe that all occurrences of six days in the fourth Commandment exclusively refer to 24 hour per day literal six days. Lord Jesus Christ is the Word of God (John 1:14), and the Word of God commands:

Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy. Six days you shall labor and do all your work, but the seventh day is a sabbath of the LORD your God; in it you shall not do any work, you or your son or your daughter, your male or your female servant or your cattle or your sojourner who stays with you. For in six days the LORD made the heavens and the earth, the sea and all that is in them, and rested on the seventh day; therefore the LORD blessed the sabbath day and made it holy.

(Exodus 20:8-11)


If you are a Christian, then you believe that Adam and Eve were there at the beginning of creation when the six days of making all the stars and planets and Earth culminated with God creating man. Lord Jesus Christ is the Word of God (John 1:14), and the Word of God declares:

He who created them from the beginning “made them male and female”

(Matthew 19:4).


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #54: Redshift is a valid and tested scientific method …snip


I’m introducing you to the Pharmakeia Principle, as introduced here in post #71, because you practice the principle in your post by failing to address the scientific facts laid out in post #53’s:

  1. RED-SHIFT … RED-SPECTRAL
  2. Redshift collapses under the Scientific Method
  3. Waveforms, it gets worse for red-shift conjecturers
  4. Astronomical Observations, red shift sinks further into the abyss
  5. History, red-shift rapidly morphs into blue-shift
  6. Conclusion for your pillar of red-shift


I would be happy to engage in debate with you in this forum, but you will need to intelligently respond to the arguments.


Your state aa a matter of fact that which is truly faith for you and GIGO (garbage in, garbage out) for your AI (abased intelligence).


Kermos
@Skipper wrote in post #51: What made you change your mind?


The Living God Jesus Christ’s work in me (Ephesians 2:8-10) changes not that the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Let’s take a look at the evolutionist’s belief system. Moral relativism forms a defining factor of evolutionism. For example, Big Bang philosophers believe their Big Bang proves there is no God, so they think that they may disregard God’s Commandments without consequence, such Commandments as when Jesus said “‘You will not murder, you will not commit adultery, you will not steal, you will not bear false witness, honor your father and your mother, and you will love your neighbor as yourself.’” (Matthew 19:18-19) and do not forget the foremost and greatest commandment “You will love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind” (Matthew 22:37), but God’s Commandments do govern every evolutionist, and this Grand Creator God’s everlasting justice is certainly meted out on His creatures.


Kermos
@Double_R wrote in post #33: I didn’t ask you anything about where the ball was 13 billion years prior …snip… Now add to the analogy, imagine you discovered that there were 7 other balls also rolling in different directions and speeds, and when …snip


@Double_R wrote in post #34: @Kermos The question I asked you was whether your observation, and the information you can easily extract from it (such as its speed and direction), can be put together to determine its path before your observation began.The answer is common sense.


@SkepticalOne wrote in post #39: You’ve twisted this analogy to avoid an easy answer which is applicable to our expanding universe.I think it is telling you won’t answer my question. You have no explanation for an expanding universe do you?


@Double_R wrote in post #46: @Kermos You could, but that would be pointless since those variables were your invention, having nothing to do with the analogy you were presented with. Focus. A ball is rolling, first observed at point A, moving at 5 mph towards point B. Q1: Can you deduce the backwards path in which that ball rolled prior to your initial observation at point A? Q2: Can you calculate where in that path the ball would have been 5 seconds earlier given that you have observed both its path and its speed? These aren’t trick questions, nor are they rocket science. All you have to do is go back to fourth grade. I believe in you.


@Double_R, you engaged in doublespeak and hypocrisy.


First, @Double_R, you originally wrote “If a ball rolls across your foot and you noted what direction it was moving in and what speed it was moving, would you not be able to tell where it was 5 seconds before you first saw it?” as the entirety of your personal composition in post #10.


Second, I addressed your post #10 in scope of this thread with “You confused human observation (rolling ball) with the absence of human observation (Big Bang)” (my post #24).


Third, @Double_R, you responded to @SatanLucy with “Now add to the analogy, imagine you discovered that there were 7 other balls also rolling in different directions and speeds” (your post #33); afterward, I posted “Consider three balls in a park” (my post #35).


Fourth, @Double_R, you wrote “You could, but that would be pointless since those variables were your invention, having nothing to do with the analogy you were presented with” about my analogy extension with three balls in a park inside of your post #46, but, as is clearly evident, I added to the analogy that you added to in a manner similar to you.


Fifth, @Double_R, as is evident, you permitted yourself to expand the scenario to more than one ball, but you rejected my expansion of the scenario to more than one ball. You engaged in hypocrisy!.


Sixth, @Double_R, as is further evident, your doublespeak appears upon your implication that your original analogy is more than your mere invention when you conveyed that mine was a “pointless” “invention” as shown in the “Fourth” paragraph, above.


I demonstrated that the ball analogy requires that someone initiated the rolling ball.


The rolling ball analogy failed as a scientific fact in support of the Big Bang just as I pointed out to you that “You confused human observation (rolling ball) with the absence of human observation (Big Bang)”.


You believe without proof (assume) that the universe is expanding as part of your Big Bang, and you conject (guess) that the one ball over foot analogy as evidence for your fantasy Big Bang.


You presented poor evidence for the Big Bang, and the Big Bang is a leap of faith.

Kermos
Skipper wrote: @Kermos The Big Bang Theory does not necessarily contrast Christianity. God could have started Creation from a single point of light–in reference to the first words of the Bible–and let the universe expand from that. The BBT can still reconcile with a Young-Earth worldview. God starts the universe from a singularity and adds to it in order with the six days of Creation.


I specifically mentioned the 13,800,000,000 year old purported Big Bang in the original post because more people heard of the Big Bang expressed in that timespan as compared to the fewer who are aware of Hubble’s law V=H0D where scientists believe the Hubble (variable) constant falls in the range of H0=50 (a 10B y.o.u.) and H0=100 (a 20B y.o.u.) (where y.o.u. is “years old universe”).


I was clear about my faith in YHWH God in the original post.


Big Bang philosophers deceive by using linguistics of fact (like “this is that”), yet they mix in words of faith/belief, such as confidence and evidence, which they try to minimize the impact of faith while they try to maximize sounding authoritatively factual.


Man spends trillions on evolution religion. NASA, Caltech, SpaceX, etc place vehicles, instrumentation, and laboratories in space. The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) even reaches in people’s personal computers with SETI@home with Astropulse. Lucrative careers are built around evolution religion, and this leads into the next paragraph.


The Pharmakeia Principle holds that certain persons merge “scientific” model (illusion) and “scientific” theory (opinion) and “scientific” fact (observation and repeatability) with a potential for financial gain into what the philosophers Illegitimately call science (legitimate science is knowledge governed by Truth (John 14:6). Illusion and opinion spoil that which those philosophers call science; in fact, the philosophers defend their position with a religious zeal, yet they disclaim any religious affiliation for their belief structures. The philosophers speak in an authoritative manner. When the philosopher’s deeply held religious beliefs are exposed as fallacious in a systematic manner, then the philosophers engage in condescension or censorship or even on some occasions progressing into violent tactics toward the people who itemize the philosophers’ errors.


Kermos
SergeantLynch wrote: @Kermos No one knows…That is a fact.


So, you admitted to a leap of faith for the nonscience Big Bang.

SergeantLynch wrote: And some of the stuff that we do know rules out the 6000 hypothesis as a universal creation event.


So, now, magically, the “fact” that “No one knows” suddenly transmuted into the “fact” that you “do know”.

SergeantLynch wrote: “Big Bang” is simply a metaphor that represents a more logical hypothesis…


So, now you downgrade the Big Bang from science to metaphor.

SergeantLynch wrote: Faith is irrelevant…


Since the Big Bang is faith based as demonstrated in post #53 about Big Bang adherents deep faith in red-shift with more and post #61 about Big Bang philosophers MASSive faith in E=MC2 error, then you wrote the Big Bang is irrelevant in essence.

SergeantLynch wrote: Whereas confidence is based on sound scientific reasoning.


You used the word “confidence” in an attempt to imply a non-faith based system for the Big Bang. The definition of confidence contains variations of belief/faith along with the tightly-coupled concept of “trust” (which is the firm belief in the integrity, ability, or character of a person or thing) in every single numbered definition. Here it is:

n.
1.
a. A belief or conviction that an outcome will be favorable: I have every confidence that we can find a solution.
b. Belief in the certainty of something: The engineers determined with confidence that the ship could withstand heavy seas.
2. Belief in the effectiveness of one’s own abilities or in one’s favorable acceptance by others; self-confidence.
3. Trust or faith in a person or thing: We are placing our confidence in you to get the job done.
See Synonyms at trust.
4. A trusting relationship: I took them into my confidence.
5.
a. That which is confided; a secret: A friend does not betray confidences.
b. A feeling of assurance that a confidant will keep a secret: I am telling you this in strict confidence.
adj.
Of, relating to, or involving a swindle or fraud: a confidence scheme; a confidence trickster.
American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fifth Edition. Copyright © 2016 by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. Published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. All rights reserved. Obtained from www.thefreedictionary.com/confidence


The bottom line is that your use of the “confidence” concept includes faith/belief/trust in the Big Bang.


In fact, Big Bang adherents can be called confidence men. Big Bang confidence men swindle souls.

Your “confidence” in the Big Bang indicates your leap of faith, so your “sound scientific reasoning” in the Big Bang is not the scientific method!

SergeantLynch wrote: Nonetheless, in the absence of ears there wouldn’t have been a bang…Just a significant moment.So in homage to biblical mythology it’s perhaps best to say…Once upon a time there was a significant moment…No faith required…No angst necessary.


On the contrary, you do have a huge leap of faith required for your significant moment, a.k.a. Big Bang.


Kermos
@linate wrote: @Kermos I posted two long posts of evidence. You didnt refute a single point of it. Even if my position is said to be based on faith, that doesn’t mean all faith positions on this are equal. . I think you might be mentally ill, otherwise your position here is completely irrational and sinful.

LIBEL ALERT


Your “I think you might be mentally ill, otherwise your position here is completely irrational and sinful” is libelous. Libel is a crime, or sin.


Now, linate, pay careful attention. I was proceeding through the posts chronologically Which means I addressed your posts in the following order, your post #2 (my response post #13 link), your post #11 (my response post #25 link), your post #14 (your first post with relevant evidence) (my response post #53 link), your post #15 (my response post #58 link), your post #17 (your irrelevant evidence) (my response post #59 link), your post #18 (my response post #60 link), and your post #27 (the post to which I’m responding). Notice, that my response post #53 was posted after your post #27 (the post to which I’m responding).


linate, I showed you good evidence.


Kermos
SkepticalOne wrote: Thats not a leap of faith, friend. It is an inference to the best explanation. Applying general relativity and thermodynamics in reverse, an initial hot dense state best accounts for the expansion of the universe and the cosmic microwave background.


General Relativity is a leap of faith as demonstrated in the following.


Scientists (sorcerers) promoted Einstein unseated Newton in an edge case scenario, so let’s review Einstein’s Theory of General Relativity with E=MC2 circumstances with some commentary by astronomer astrologers:

Frank Watson Dyson, Astronomer Royal of Britain, conceived the perfect experiment to test Einstein’s theory [5]. A total solar eclipse on 29 May 1919 would occur just as the Sun was crossing the bright Hyades star cluster (about 151 light-years away). Light from these stars would have to pass by the Sun’s gravitational field on its way to Earth and would be visible during the darkness of the eclipse.

Arthur Eddington photographed reference positions of the Hyades stars during January and February of 1919 from Oxford, England (51.7520°N, 1.2577°W; temp 40°F). Then, in May he went to the remote island of Principe (1.6139°N, 7.4057°E; temp 80°F) to photograph the stars’ positions during the eclipse.

Andrew Commelin went to Sobral, Brazil (3.7015°S, 7.4057°E, temp 80°F) in May to photograph the stars’ positions during the eclipse and stayed there to photograph reference positions two months after the eclipse. Both teams superimposed reference photos over the eclipse photos to see how much the Sun’s gravity may have deflected light from these stars.

Eddington’s results from Principe showed an average deflection of 1.61 arcseconds. Crommelin’s results from Sobral showed an average deflection of 1.98 arcseconds. The average of these two readings, 1.795 arcseconds, was consistent with Einstein’s prediction [6]. In his Brief History of Time, Stephen Hawking says of the 1919 deflection results: “Their measurement had been sheer luck, or a case of knowing the result they wanted to get, not an uncommon occurrence in science” [7]. The errors in data were as large as the effect they were trying to prove, thus making these results inconclusive.

(Rowland D (2024) Mistaking Refraction for Gravity is the Error that Launched Einstein’s Career. OSP Journal of Physics and Astronomy 5: JPA-5-157)

The Solar Eclipse of 1919 made Einstein an overnight celebrity for his theory of general relativity. Both Newton and Einstein had predicted that light passing close by the Sun would be deflected slightly towards the Sun, but for different reasons. Newton’s prediction was based on refraction as light passes through the dense photosphere of the Sun. Einstein’s prediction was based on the mistaken notion that gravity can bend light. Einstein had predicted a degree of deflection that was twice as much as Newton’s prediction. The results from the 1919 Solar Eclipse appeared to support Einstein’s theory [3].

The measurements of deflection from this 1919 event were based on a statistically insignificant sample size of before-and-after readings from only five stars. The readings themselves were also questionable because of (a) errors in parallax from varying angles of measurement and atmospheric conditions at the respective points of observation, and (b) equipment failure. Results were inconclusive because the error factor was as large as the deviation the experimenters were trying to prove [3].

(Rowland D. (2020) Physics and Logic Often Conflict. OSP J Phy Astronomy 1. JPA-1-106)


Your vaunted Hawking said “a case of knowing the result they wanted to get, not an uncommon occurrence in science” regarding the 1919 solar eclipse General Relativity Theory investigative team of Dyson, Eddington, and Commelin.


Rowland sufficed that team’s findings by writing “errors in parallax from varying angles of measurement and atmospheric conditions at the respective points of observation”.


Between Hawking and Rowland, that team’s findings about Einstein’s General Relativity Theory is a leap of faith.

Cosmic microwave background radiation


Please see the detailed explanation of CMBR in section “2. Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR)” of post #53.


CMBR tracing back in time leads to a leap of faith for the Big Bang.

SkepticalOne wrote: You didn’t answer the question (I am genuinely curious). How does your ideology explain the expanding universe?


First, you must have belief (faith) that the universe is currently expanding.


Second, if the universe is currently expanding, then the answer is that the Jesus Christ Lord and God stretches out the heavens like a curtain (Psalm 104:2)!

Kermos
linate wrote: Ive provided plenty of evidence. Even if i use faith, its based on the best fit for the evidenceNow, repent of your heresy. Or tell us why you have such contempt for truth, and why you choose to remain in your sin.


You wrote “its based on the best fit for the evidence” which is a false concept as comprehensively demonstrated in post #53, and this is your fourth post in which you repeated your false concept within the first 18 posts of this thread. Repetition doesn’t make your concept into a factually true concept.


Kermos
linate wrote: The case against a 6,000-year-old Earth is very strong from both mainstream science and from many biblical scholars. Interestingly, these are two independent lines of evidence that converge on the same conclusion: the Earth is much older than a few thousand years.## Scientific Evidence### 1. Radiometric dating (the strongest single line of evidence)


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


Your post extensively deviated from the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. You have no good evidence for the Big Bang.


Kermos
linate wrote: Also …snip


You wrote “even if the big bang theory requires faith”, which the Big Bang Conjecture does require a leap of faith.


And, you wrote “its still based on the best available evidence” which is a false concept as comprehensively demonstrated in post #53, and this is your third post in which you repeated your false concept within the first 15 posts of this thread. Repetition doesn’t make your concept into a factually true concept.

Kermos
linate wrote: If a skeptic asked for the strongest evidence for the Big Bang, I’d focus on the observations that are difficult to explain any other way. …snip

AI For Your Mind


With a little scientific investigation, I discovered your use of the so-called artificial intelligence (a.k.a. AI) data processor, OpenAI, to compose your response. For example, your images are hosted on the images.OpenAI.com Internet server (sampling list of your visible first 3 and last image’s links: image 1, image 2, image 3, and last image). Since you employed augmented intelligence (a.k.a. AI) to your own intellect, then you incorporated that AI into yourself. That first personal pronoun “I” in your post becomes you joined to AI. Your evolution religion and transhumanism are tightly coupled!

1. RED-SHIFT … RED-SPECTRAL


Red-shift is one of your star bible’s pillar foundations.

Redshift collapses under the Scientific Method


First, let’s look at a examination of red-shift, which you base on the so-called doppler effect of light, in the light of the scientific method:

  1. Phase: activity
  2. hypothesis: red spectral light received from a star in space indicates the star’s direction of travel away and great distance from Earth.
  3. experiment: no test cases.
  4. observation: none of experiments.
  5. conclusion: stars receding away from Earth with distances of monumental proportion trail longer red spectral light.
  6. confirmation: no experiments to repeat.


Red-shift conjecturers abysmally failed to completely apply the scientific method. Red-shift as a distance determinant is not science.

Waveforms, it gets worse for red-shift conjecturers


You are using the nonsense nonscience doppler effect of light based on your assumptions, not science.


Sound waves are atmospheric tightly localized particle vibrations passed from particle to particle; on the other hand, light waves are projectile particles.


As an example of the doppler effect, when a fast moving train blows it’s whistle while passing a person, then the pitch increases on approach to the person (sound wave compression) and the pitch decreases as the train races toward the horizon (sound wave decompression) as the train leaves the person; however, red-shift conjecturers have no such proof for the doppler effect of light except for their hypothesis pointing at their conclusion joined with their conclusion pointing at their hypothesis.

Astronomical Observations, red shift sinks further into the abyss


Astronomers discovered a quasar with an enormous redshift embedded inside a nearby to Earth spiral galaxy with far lower red-shift, so these two celestial objects that need to be the same distance away from Earth due to the collocation are simultaneously greatly separated because of red-shift (both conditions cannot be true). The galaxy is reportedly 300 million light years away while the quasar within the heart of the galaxy is reportedly several billion light years away (source “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper readily publicly available from Table of contents for issue 1, volume 620, The Astrophysical Journal). Red-shift as a distance calculator is falsified.

History, red-shift rapidly morphs into blue-shift


Sirius was known as the Star of Isis in ancient Egypt and was described as red, but Sirius is blue, now. This change describes a stellar u-turn.

Conclusion for your pillar of red-shift


Stellar red-shift is really stellar red-spectral frequency production.


Red-shift is an observed phenomena without a scientific explanation of “why”.


I didn’t even dig into your ridiculously miniscule observational window in terms of space and time,.. yet.


The evidence contradicts your section “1. The expansion of the universe (strong evidence)”. You have very bad evidence for your faith in the Big Bang.


Your star bible’s red-shift massive star distances doctrine is a leap of faith.

2. Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR)


You opened your second section with a discreet lie of “In 1965, astronomers accidentally discovered faint microwave radiation coming from every direction in space”, and here is the proof of concept.


I present to you the history which reveals CMB was a known quantity decades before 1965. This directly derails your “fact” leaving a mere residual called “faith”.


Andrew McKellar used W. S. Adams’ spectroscopic instrumentation during 1941 to measure background temperature of 2.3 K of a B type star.


In 1948, cosmologist George Gamow led a group that calculated cosmic microwave radiation.


The vaunted Bell Telephone Laboratories had a facility atop Crawford Hill in Holmdel, New Jersey where Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson experimented in 1964. They detected a homogeneous, constant radiation. They were awarded the Nobel Prize in 1978 for their CMB work.


Robert H. Dicke, Jim Peebles, and David Wilkinson, astrophysicists at Princeton University believed the Big Bang emitted a tremendous radiation blast resulting in cosmic microwave background radiation (CMBR), and they prepared to investigate microwave radiation levels in the year 1964.


But, Bernard F. Burke, professor of physics at MIT, introduced the two groups working a mere 40 miles from each other.


The two groups agreeably jointly published in Astrophysical Journal Letters. Two notes were published, (1) Dicke et al substantiated the Big Bang based on CMBR, and (2) Penzias et al noted the existence of 3.5 K CMBR universally.


In essence, your history of

In 1965, astronomers accidentally discovered faint microwave radiation coming from every direction in space. The Big Bang predicted decades earlier that if the universe began in an extremely hot state, it should leave behind cooled radiation filling the cosmos. That’s exactly what was found

deceives people, including you.

Scientist’s, er, philosopher’s public CMBR deception


It is time to compare and contrast these data collections:

  1. McKellar (1941): (2.5 +0.9/-0.7) K
  2. Penzias and Wilson (1965): (3.5 +/- 1.0) K


Your manipulation of statistics (mathematical nonsense) to arrive at “It has almost exactly the predicted temperature (2.725 K)” is a deeper lie and malevolent representation.


The astrophysicist Stephen Hawking said of astronomer astrologers, “a case of knowing the result they wanted to get, not an uncommon occurrence in science”, so you keep his words in mind while reading the following.

CMBR UnSETtling Theory


Set theory is fascinating, and set theory is destructive to your argument.

  1. McKellar (1941): M = {x ∈ R | 1.8 ≤ x ≤ 3.4}
  2. Penzias and Wilson (1965): P = {x ∈ R | 2.5 ≤ x ≤ 4.5}


M and P represent two mutually exclusive, independent and discreet studies.


M=P is false.


M∩P is a range of real number temperature elements that potentially one set can be greater than or lesser than the temperature in the opposing set (except for the boundaries which would be equality on one side), so M∩P elements are excluded from this evaluation because these cancel each other out. This leaves the elements represented in MΔP.


MΔP is the range of real number temperature elements that uniquely qualify as exclusively greater than or less than the temperature in the opposing set, so MΔP is included in this evaluation.


Proof samples:

  1. M∩P and M>P, M=3.2 and P=3.1
  2. M∩P and M<P, M=3.1 and P=3.2
  3. MΔP and M>P, nonexistent
  4. MΔP and M<P, M=1.8 and P=4.5
  5. MΔP and M<P, M=2.4 and P=3.5


The exemplary intersection (M∩P) elements of 3.1 and 3.2 sufficiently illustrate the cancelation effect of the corresponding intersection elements.


The result is M<P.


The CMBR temperature increases going forward in time according to this logic demonstrated using set theory which indicates a lower temperature in the past.


Set theory applied to your star bible data upends your “the universe began in an extremely hot state” writing.

CMBR Average Disformity


Scientists like averages (mean), or medians, or blind faith guesses, such as your “2.725 K” CMBR temperature, so I present the mean temperature values to test your conclusion that there has been a decrease in the temperature over the years.


The data averaged:

  1. McKellar (1941): 2.5
  2. Penzias and Wilson (1965): 3.5


2.5=3.5 is false.


2.5<3.5 is true.


1941<1965 is true.


3.5-2 5=1.0 is true.


1965-1941=24 is true.


The five factual statements directly above show a 1.0 K increase of heat on average over a period of 2 dozen years starting in 1941 AD until 1965 AD.


A decrease in heat temperature from 1941 to 1965 is the Big Bang adherent’s requirement, but it’s just not there, so your CMBR is very bad evidence for your Big Bang.

CMBR Logical Conclusion


The above dissection of your data shows that these are each distinctly different surveys:

  1. McKellar (1941): (2.5 +0.9/-0.7) K
  2. Penzias and Wilson (1965): (3.5 +/- 1.0) K


McKellar (1941): (2.5 +0.9/-0.7) K is not isotropic agreement with Penzias and Wilson (1965): (3.5 +/- 1.0) K.


Statistical consolidation of the points is unreasonable because reasonable doubt has been cast by the potential for decreased temperature in earlier time thus anyone claiming increased temperature is a person defying the logical conclusion from the data; in other words, you cannot logically claim that there was a high heat temperature deep in the past around your Big Bang timeframe which would make the differences in points statistically insignificant. The differences in points are statistically significant as a function of the recorded increase in temperature over the decades, yet astronomer astrologers exhibit Stephen Hawking’s quote, recorded above.


In other words, these measurements are in agreement with one another that the Big Bang is a leap of faith/belief.


Deception of the CMBR is a very poor method to present your case.


Various sources of material for this whole CMBR section include “cosmic microwave background” of Encyclopedia Britannica, “Cosmic microwave background” of Wikipedia, and “A Review of the 1941 to 1961 CMBR Temperature Measurements” on ResearchGate.


Your section ‘2. The Cosmic Microwave Background (the “afterglow”) (arguably the strongest single piece)’ is very bad evidence for the Big Bang. Logically, “strong evidence” represents strong grounds for disbelief in the Big Bang.

3. Prideful man sees light in the heavens and says to himself, “there is no god”


A prediction exposes a future person, place, or thing. The Big Bang purportedly existed as a thing of the past.


In your “3. The abundance of the light elements” section, your broken linguistics wrongly utilize predict for your past thing (Big Bang).


I present a real example of a prediction. Unless you think differently after an encounter with the Word of God, you will surely die in your crimes against the Living God who created you. See, I’m referring to the future.


Your section 3 fails to adhere to the Scientific Method in all aspects. Your hypothesis and conclusion are the same which leads you to circular reasoning. Nobody observed a natural phenomenon that you call the Big Bang, so your hypothesis is null and void. You have no experimentation, so you have no observations of said experimentation. Repeatability exists not. You do not have science because you have sorcery about your light recipes which you presented.


You leap to faith for your abundance of light as support for your Big Bang.

4. Galaxies change


Galaxies changing over time does not indicate that a Big Bang occurred. The Earth revolves around the Sun, so this results in change for the Milky Way Galaxy, yet the Earth’s orbit is by no means proof of your fantasy Big Bang Theory.


If you looked at a small galaxy, then all you science (know) is that you saw a small galaxy in relation to your location. You know (1) not whether the galaxy is truly large and very distant, (2) not whether the galaxy is truly small and very near, (3) not the luminosity at the galaxy, and (4) not the galaxy size as an age determinant. Your “Young galaxies look: ● smaller” is an astoundingly unscientific conjecture (theory) which makes your conjecture a leap of belief/faith.


During your Big Bang, the speed of light was greatly exceeded. You do not know whether current conditions conducive to exceeding the speed of light exist out in the vastness of space; therefore, your “When we look billions of light-years away, we’re looking billions of years into the past”, presented as fact by you, is truly your faith based statement.

The Zenith Model


I examine just how untenable it is to believe you can accumulate sufficient data to draw conclusions about an event 13.8 billion years ago.


Carl Sagan wrote Cosmos, and in Cosmos, Sagan presented his Cosmic Calendar representing 13.8 billion years as a conventional single calendar year with January 1st as the Big Bang and December 31st as the current time. Are you familiar with Sagan’s work?


Sagan’s calculations put the birth of Christ on December 31st at 23:59:55. That’s mere seconds before the end of the calendar year.


Each second on the Cosmic Calendar corresponds to 438 Earth years, According to historians, Hans Lippershey applied for a “telescope” patent in 1608, and astronomical observations were initiated by Galileo Galilei using an improved design. For your sake in this model, I’ll give you the more ancient date of 1608 which is 417 years of documentary evidence for telescopes which is one second at the very end of that Cosmic Calendar year.


You believe you collected sufficient data about the Big Bang through such a negligibly small window, one second out of 31,536,000 seconds as represented by Sagan’s Cosmic Calendar.


As an aside, Edwin Hubble is largely credited by the scientific community with discovering in 1924 that almost all galaxies are moving away from Earth, about 100 years ago, which is the last one-quarter second of 23:55:59 on December 31st. Further distilling the times into equal time segments, each unit being equal to 0.25 of 1 second, the ratio is 1:126,144,000 for your data collection since Hubble’s work.


Back to giving you the full second.


The model also needs to compensate for space, and I’m extending a beneficial handicap to you. I’ll only calculate for an X-axis, and I’ll skip the Y-axis and Z-axis. Light reportedly travels at 186,000 miles per second, so one light year is about 6 trillion miles (6,000,000,000,000 miles).


Earth is 8 light minutes from the Sun, so the field of measurement is about 16 light minutes (2,976,000 miles diameter of orbit).


Scientists speculate the solar system is about 4 light years across (24,000,000,000,000 miles).


Our own Milky Way galaxy is about 100,000 light-years (600,000,000,000,000,000 miles) across according to NASA personnel, and they estimate that the observable universe is about 92 billion light-years (552,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles) across.


As of Feb. 1, 2020, Voyager 1 is about 13.8 billion miles (13,800,000,000 miles) from the Sun.


Let’s pretend CMBR data, telemetry data, and such continues to flow back to Earth’s scientists from Voyager 1 collected with instruments congruent with 2025 technology instead of 1977 technology; in other words, I’m giving you another big fat handicap.


Your data collection ratio is 13.8:552,000,000,000,000 miles. That ratio is a linear X-axis - excluding the compounding effect of the Y-axis and the Z-axis.


Scientists collected data across 13.8:552,000,000,000,000 distance units spanning 1:31,536,000 time units (a.k.a. 438:13,800,000,000 time units). This is conservatively favorable to your advantage.


I observe that you collected data over an insufficient time frame in an insignificantly sized sampling region.


In conclusion, the Big Bang Theory is not science, and the Big Bang Theory is a leap of faith.


Scientists had a leap of faith with a data reading in time - a sliver of time - in a sliver of space. No detailed temperature with path history embedded in the particles. That’s not science.


The above is titled the Zenith Model.


Your “4. Galaxies evolve over time” section is laden with assumptions, that is, your believing without proof (see thefreedictionary.com/assumption).

5. The Cosmic Distance Ladder is a poorly formed faith


As you coalesced your prior four points into your “5. Multiple independent measurements agree on the universe’s age”, your astronomer astrologer cosmic distance ladder, which you as a scientist failed to specifically name, emerges with broken and missing rungs; in other words, your Big Bang is a leap of faith as evidenced above. In fact, the following obliterates your foundational rungs.

The Episcopic Model


Now, I arrived at your cosmic distance ladder or your “star bible” as I put it. You have a book of your forefathers, and that book was developed with less mature technology as compared to your current instruments.


A galaxy candidate named HDI is pegged at 13.5 billion light years from Earth by astronomers who put HDI in the early universe.


The astronomer astrologers cannot use parallax in combination with the inverse square law because of the hyper super-small angles (even in arcseconds), the requirement to know the luminosity at the source, or the requirement to know the distance to the object.


Astronomers already claim to know the distance without visiting the source to determine the brightness.


This leaves telescopes for determining the distance.


Astronomers claim that telescopes provides evidence for you, even that telescopes enable you to determine the distance from Earth to celestial bodies many light years away.


If you take a first measurement to a particular object in space from a telescope on Earth on June 21 and a second reading on December 21 of the same year, then you can use the angle-side-angle geometric formula to determine the distance to the object.


For the purposes of this example, I’m switching to a much more manageable distance from 13,500,000,000 light years (HDI) to an object 1 (one) light year away from Earth.


I want to give you an idea of just how narrow that triangle is by way of a scale model.


A first person uses a red marking pen to put a dot on the TransAmerica building in San Francisco.


A second person sets up two street survey instruments on tripods 800 miles away on the Space Needle in Seattle, and the survey instruments are set 16 inches apart. These two points sixteen inches apart represent Earth’s orbit around the Sun for a triangulation base.


Now, the second person finds the red dot and collects the angle-side-angle data for calculating the distance to the red dot.


That is one NARROW triangle, and that is merely a single light year scale model.


The triangle with respect to the nearest solar system, Andromeda, at 4 light years away, is much narrower. Think of it, the first person leaves San Francisco California, 800 miles from Seattle, to travel south, past Los Angeles, past Mexico City all the way through Mexico, further south into Central America, into the northern outskirts of Managua in Nicaragua, 3,200 miles from Seattle, and tethers a red helium filled balloon to the top of the tallest tree; meanwhile, the second person keeps the two survey instruments in the same 16" separated locations on the Space Needle in Seattle of the USA, and the second person finds the red balloon and collects the angle-side-angle data for triangulating the distance to the red balloon. Those angles are ever so slight!


linate, if you don’t perceive your evidence disappearing, then that’s a shame.


Astronomers claim VY Canis Majoris, is approximately 3,900 light-years away from Earth. Could the second person place a red tarp over the descent stage of the Lunar Module Eagle sitting on the moon for this example? Not without being about 60,000 to 80,000 miles too close to those two survey instruments sitting 16" apart on the Space Needle in Seattle, WA, USA, Earth (312,000 miles required for the 16" surveyor scale model)! I’m giving you the benefit of the red tarp over the decent stage, yet the triangulation has the appearance of being parallel lines for a celestial object far less than 100,000 light years from Earth, and this example hasn’t even touched upon the 100,000 light years diameter of the Milky Way galaxy, so Astronomers are faith based regarding celestial bodies being 1,000,000 (one million) light years from Earth instead of science based. 1,000,000,000 (one billion) light years from Earth is a triangulation distance measurement nightmare leap of faith calculation.


Back to galaxy candidate HDI, the resulting triangle using telescopes on Earth to arrive at 13.5 billion light years from Earth is nonscience, definitely not the scientific method.


Your star bible fails to help you avoid the leap of faith because your star bible itself is a foundation based on faith.


I title this the Episcopic Model that proves you only have the characteristics of received particle emissions at the time of reception. Light particles contain (1) no date of production data, (2) no static location of production data, and (3) no internally recorded path of travel data. You do not have accurate origin object distance nor luminosity nor size nor age for celestial objects purportedly exceeding 6,000 light years from Earth.

Your closing inquiries


Your “What doesn’t the Big Bang explain?” is irrelevant.


Your “How strong is the evidence?” is addressed in detail, above, so it’s redundant and irrelevant.

The Big Bang is a belief system


Your AI failed to establish fact for the Big Bang, so your AI (augmented intelligence) is ieft with a leap of faith for the Big Bang.


You possess bad evidence for the Big Bang. Your grounds for belief (evidence) is just shifting sand, and Lord Jesus says this about shifting sand:

Therefore everyone who hears these words of Mine and acts on them, may be compared to a wise man who built his house on the rock. And the rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew and slammed against that house; and yet it did not fall, for it had been founded on the rock. Everyone who hears these words of Mine and does not act on them, will be like a foolish man who built his house on the sand. The rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew and slammed against that house; and it fell—and great was its fall.
(Matthew 7:24-27)


Kermos

Again, poignant! Again, your content was blocked.

SatanLucy wrote: If a ball rolls across your foot and you noted what direction it was moving in and what speed it was moving, would you not be able to tell where it was 5 seconds before you first saw it?No, because you dont know the starting point. Just because a ball moves in a straight line at speed of 5 meters per second, doesnt mean it was moving in that straight line for 13 billion years before it reached me. Calculating starting point based on current movement speed and pattern, is logically impossible, and anyone who does that is pretty much doing witchcraft and not science.

Consider three balls in a park:

  1. a croquet ball,
  2. a lawn bowling ball,
  3. a baseball.


Next, a grandpa out in the field carrying a toddler while pointing out the nearest game, the croquet game.


The toddler coos, and the grandpa carefully launches the giggling toddler into the air.


At that moment, a croquet player sledges one ball that collides and ricochets a ball near the grandpa’s foot at high velocity.


Also at that moment, about twenty feet away, a bowler trips and launches his ball across the ground directly toward the grandpa’s foot at high velocity.


Furthermore, a baseball from the distant field flies out of the park past the fence, lands, and rolls toward the grandpa’s foot at high velocity.


The grandpa senses a ball roll over his foot. The grandpa kepps his eye on the toddler, and he safely catches the giggling toddler.


When the grandpa looks down to see what happened, he sees 3 balls bunched on the ground about 5 feet away, beside him.


He doesn’t know which ball hit his foot.


He didn’t know where the ball, which rolled over his foot, started its journey.


Was it a wayward throw by an outfielder? Was it a powerful hit by a batter? Was it the croquet ball which initially started movement very near his foot? Was it the bowling ball?


The Grandpa needs human witnesses to help determine which ball rolled over his foot, much less where it came.


Consider an additional dimension, uneven terrain.


Every example has someone who instigated the rolling ball. Not one "just happened".


I could go on about variables related to Double_R’s scenario, but enough has been written to demonstrate Double_R’s fallacy.

SatanLucy wrote: Well, most of science is witchcraft anyway. Its actually often amazing how many stupid things scientists believe in. I know they say science improves the world, but I really dont see that happening. the world is pretty much on a straight line of getting worse and worse.

Well written. I have another completed composition about the “science sorcery spectrum”, but that is not for this time.


Kermos
linate wrote: Also even if the big bang theory requires faith, its still based on the best available evidence

So says linate, who posted no evidence!


I think it’s best to define the term “evidence”:

Noun ground for belief or disbelief; data on which to base proof or to establish truth or falsehood
Collins English Dictionary – Complete and Unabridged, 12th Edition 2014 © HarperCollins Publishers 1991, 1994, 1998, 2000, 2003, 2006, 2007, 2009, 2011, 2014 obtained from www.thefreedictionary.com/evidence

Notice, you are right back to belief/faith, or the absence thereof, the moment you talk about evidence.


Big Bang philosophers possess bad evidence.


Kermos
Double_R wrote: You didn’t provide anything for us to refute, all you did was equate scientific findings with faith while providing no reason to justify such categorization.Do you know where the big bang theory came from? Do you know why the scientific community accepts it? Do you understand the difference between arriving at conclusions via the scientific method, and faith?Perhaps if you give us something to work with other than vague assertions we can help you understand where we’re coming from.

I requested of scientists to “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. The statement is self-explanatory. Are you a scientist? I engaged in this very conversation with scientists, and they knew precisely what the self-explanatory means.


Kermos
FLRW wrote: Hmmmm, the oldest confirmed fossils are about 3.5 billion to 3.77 billion years old, consisting of microscopic bacteria and mounded structures called stromatolites.

THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. You have no good evidence for the Big Bang.


Kermos
Sidewalker wrote: Christians can believe in evolution, most do I think, becoming a Christian doesn’t necessitate ending belief in evolution by any stretch of the imagination.

THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


But, I respond to your incorrect belief/faith about Christians, here.


Actually, distinct incompatibility exists between Cosmic Evolution (13,800,000,000 years) and Christianity (6,000 years).


Jesus Christ is the Word of God (John 1:14), and the Word of God says “in six days Yahweh made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that is in them, and rested the seventh day; therefore Yahweh blessed the Sabbath day, and made it holy” (Exodus 20:11) as part of the Ten Commandments.


Christians believe Christ. Christians believe the beginning of creation week (Genesis 1:1) is about 6,000 years ago. The calculation is based on Biblical record from the beginning until the birth of Christ added to the about 2,000 years after Christ’s birth.


Therefore, a person who claims to be a Christian yet does not believe the above Word of God (Christ) references to the creation account, then that person is not a Christian.


Christians understand six days is not six billion years, not six weeks, not about 14 billion years, but six days that the Word of God says God made Heaven and Earth.

Sidewalker wrote: The mechanics aren’t completely worked out, but Big Bang Cosmology is the scientific consensus.

Scientific consensus does not equal scientific fact, so you need to show scientific fact, Sidewalker, for your Big Bang.

Sidewalker wrote: You are trying to sell us on a deceitful God …snip

THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. You have no good evidence for the Big Bang.

Sidewalker wrote: I’m pretty sure Christians “of the Big Bang persuasion” define faith that way also …snip

THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. You have no good evidence for the Big Bang.

Sidewalker wrote: Sure, the Big Bang is science because it is a scientific theory based on scientific observations, philosophy and science are two different things. Just because faith is involved in science, that doesn’t mean it isn’t science. One of the founders of modern physics, Max Planck said: “Anybody who has been seriously engaged in scientific work of any kind realizes that over the entrance to the gates of the temple of science are written the words: Ye must have faith. It is a quality which the scientist cannot dispense with”

Perhaps a definition of the word “theory” would help right about now:

  1. A set of statements or principles devised to explain a group of facts or phenomena, especially one that has been repeatedly tested or is widely accepted and can be used to make predictions about natural phenomena.
  2. The branch of a science or art consisting of its explanatory statements, accepted principles, and methods of analysis, as opposed to practice: a fine musician who had never studied theory.
  3. A set of theorems that constitute a systematic view of a branch of mathematics.
  4. Abstract reasoning; speculation: a decision based on experience rather than theory.
  5. A belief or principle that guides action or assists comprehension or judgment: staked out the house on the theory that criminals usually return to the scene of the crime.
  6. An assumption based on limited information or knowledge; a conjecture. American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fifth Edition. Copyright © 2016 by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. Published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. All rights reserved. Obtained from thefreedictionary.com/theory

In definition 1, “accepted” is a synonym for “believed”, so you arrived at “widely believed” which is faith, not fact.


You do not have a Big Bang as a natural phenomena observed by man.


You failed to present a “group of facts” regarding the Big Bang.


In definition 6, the highly Big Bang relevant keyword “assumption” is found. You Big Bang philosophers admittedly make assumptions, and an assumption is “belief without evidence” - your conjecture.


You have a Big Bang Theory, a.k.a. Big Bang Conjecture, a.k.a. Big Bang Belief.


The Big Bang is a leap of faith.

Sidewalker wrote: Yes, LiveScience provides a pretty good rough overview of the scientific method, and that method is the process by which scientists arrived at Big Bang Cosmology …snip

You failed to provide facts for your statement. You succeeded in presenting your belief (faith).

Sidewalker wrote: …snip I think your post betrays a lack of understanding of both science and Christianity. I cannot accept your contrived conflict between religious truth and scientific truth because to do so I would have to believe in a self-contradicting God; and that is something I simply cannot accept.


You demonstrated a strong misunderstanding on your part. I did not ask you to accept anything. If you come back, then do make an effort to bring evidence related to the topic! The title of this thread says it quite well with “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
SkepticalOne wrote:The universe is expanding - this is a verifiable fact. Trace this expansion back in time and you get to a single dense beginning 13.8 billion years ago. If not the Big Bang, then how does one explain the expansion?

You have a leap of faith that the Universe is expanding at a rate that traces back in time 13.8 billion years ago to a Big Bang, not scientific fact.


You have no good evidence for the Big Bang.


Kermos
linate wrote: Saying the earth is 6000 years old …snip

THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


I admitted that mine is faith in the opening post of this thread.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. You have no good evidence for the Big Bang.


Kermos

Faith is proof of things not seen; in other words, that which you say/think but not see is what you believe.


I want to give you an idea of who I am. I was an evolutionist, but Christ changed me into a Christian.


Many scientists believe the beginning of Universe was about 13.8 billion years ago. A subset of those scientists believe an infinitesimally small, densely packed, super-heated region (point) exploded as the Big Bang, and other scientists believe that nothing exploded as the Big Bang.


Regardless of alternative models, such as a cyclically oscillating Universe, I am focusing on the beginning, that is, the origin of the Universe.


I believe the Universe is about 6,000 years old. For me, and not for scientists of the Big Bang persuasion, "faith is assurance of things hoped for, proof of things not seen" ([Hebrews 11:1](https://biblehub.com/hebrews/11-1.htm)) applies because my assurance of things hoped for is my Lord and my God Jesus Christ's triumphant return while scientists are not hoping for the Big Bang since scientists believe the Big Bang is an event of the past.


Scientists believe the Big Bang Theory is science. I postulate that the Big Bang Theory is based on faith. I propose scientists of the Big Bang Theory are more accurately identified as philosophers of the Big Bang Philosophy or Evolution religion, and I write this because of the difference between science and faith. Can any of you scientists rationally explain away this postulate as wrong?


LiveScience presents an excellent explanation of the term science at [www.livescience.com/20896-science-scientific-method.html](https://www.livescience.com/20896-science-scientific-method.html) with an essence of the scientific method including (1) hypothesis, (2) repeatable observation and experimentation, and (3) conclusions. This is pertinent to this thread.

Kermos

Earlier today, I read an interesting angle which has parallels with this thread’s progression.


In “4 stages of a nation’s collapse, according to a KGB defector”, the article’s author documented that Yuri Bezmenov, a Soviet journalist and KGB agent who defected to the West in 1970, presented a now-famous 1983 lecture. He explained about the intentional aggressor targeted self-destruction of a nation by:

  1. Demoralization (15–20 years)
  2. Destabilization (2–5 years)
  3. Crisis (weeks to months)
  4. Normalization.


That “new normal” that the adversary wants is detailed in the article, and I quote, “That is what a nation looks like after decades of sustained demoralization — a nation that has been taught, patiently and systematically, to distrust truth itself, to distrust its own foundations, and increasingly, to distrust one another”.


There are people who desire the coercion of government to enforce “you call me what I am not or you go to jail”.


There were people who instigated a crisis of epic proportions resulting in lockdowns for large swaths of the world’s population, yet people permitted massive riots in select cities by select groups gathering in tight formation.


Language is based on distinct concepts. When word to definition correlation is intentionally subverted, then confusion inevitably ensues.


Christ Jesus, Lord and God is not a God of confusion but of peace (1 Corinthians 14:33, so we who are in Christ utilize peacefully accurate linguistics because we Christians are destined for everlasting peace and joy in Christ. We want this for the people of the world.


The U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling established that word to definition correlation matters in the U.S.A.


Kermos

I would like to invite a few people (a PhD, astronomer, and their associate) to apply to DebateCraft.com in order to debate about the Big Bang, but I would like less constraints than the formal debate section of the site.


I propose two parallel threads in the science forum:

  1. a primary debate thread (restricted).
  2. a commentary thread (unrestricted).


“Free and open conversation” remains unhindered in the commentary thread. People could reference particular posts and participants of the primary thread.


I haven’t invited them at this time. I want to implement the framework, first.


Are you a staff member? I didn’t notice you on Current Staff.