Mikal

Scarlet or toran

myself - scarlet 

David - scarlet 

Castin - scarlet 

max - scarlet - Sanchez (miller, was traitor to the liberation)

Mharm - scarlet

Shining - scarlet

Luna - scarlet

Are you scarlet ?

myself - scarlet 

David - scarlet 

Castin - scarlet 

max - scarlet - Sanchez (miller, was traitor to the liberation)

Mharm - scarlet

Shining - scarlet

It’s way more complex than that. It’s not just the ending. It’s the entire game and the lead up to the ending. It’s not easy to research and takes some game knowledge from playing or a lot of research. I’m js. Recruiting is limited.

There is no hard truth anticlaim mechanic, but revealing information about your character will allow scum to use their roles to much greater effect

skep choosing to use the word their in this. Leads me to believe. There is more than 1 at the start.

Character claiming is prob bad because you can infer roles. My ego is telling me I could solve this outside of fake claims

his pm says he can’t be recruited. There are multiple people that fall under that criteria and it’s under very specific conditions in game. Again it’s not something scum would know or can even find. But with his pm and something mine references. I am all but sure this assumption is correct. I think scum has like a 50/50 shot on if they get someone.

Yeah I don’t think he gave them a list though. I know exactly who scum can recruit cus endgame but I really doubt scum know that

interested to see if Ted’s in the game. Will say a lot

Given maxs pm there possibly 5-6 players scum can’t recruit

Scum is also limited on recruiting. There are very specific people they likely can rec and there is no way they know who that is if they didn’t play the game

unless skep told them

myself - scarlet 

David - scarlet 

Castin - scarlet 

max - scarlet - Sanchez (miller, was traitor to the liberation)

Mharm - scarlet

myself - scarlet

David - scarlet

Castin - scarlet

max - scarlet - Sanchez (miller, was traitor to the liberation)

Toran or empire ?

Toran or empire ?

toran or empire?

I don’t think it’s tp

if there are cultist. Scum are prob cult

there is literally only one person. Not even a faction that could be a tp in my mind

but maxs pm directly implies he is from the liberation

I know a lot more than what I’m saying but I don’t want to say it as it will tell mafia how to navigate the game.

based on maxs pm and my pm

I def think I’m right in my earlier assumption but there is intricacies that scum prob won’t pick up on unless they have played the game.

max is either a lock or it’s a fake claim

I do think theme will play an important part. There is very few scarlet empire choices. Less than 9 that make sense and then it will be odd claims. So depending on how many fake claims they have. Theme can absolutely isolate the og scum. It won’t isolate the recruit. But there is very likely a hidden aspect that recruit that mafia don’t even know and it’s glaring obvious if you beat the game

Plus a tp being Able to do that doesn’t mesh with the you can’t recruit them mech

maxs pm also 100 percent scum locks toran and I have a feeling the game is a snap shot of the game at the time of the game starting. I am not going to elaborate until I confirm but I would be dammed if it’s not toran and they can’t recruit.

actually I did just come up with one possible tp who would make sense with a recruit rule. But it’s a stretch to think it’s that over toran recruiting

I don’t think it’s as simple as you think

just because it’s pretty obvious the rebellion is scum doesn’t mean it’s easy. There is a recruit mechanic which just flips the game on its head.

no he almost flat said character claiming is not an anti claim. He’s directly referring to roles. If you claim cop, they may a role thag fuck with it. If you have a visiting role, they may have a role that can fuck with it etc. he doesnt like character anti claims like David did and he said he balances it with roles.

I am simply saying character claiming is not detrimental other than some characters likely have roles that are easy to guess based on their character. It’s an rpg so if there is a healer (doctor) etc.

Cus was curious there are some very obscure things but none of it makes sense with the recruit outside of the Toran liberation army.

I’m reading through stuff again to make sure I’m not missing anything. I don’t think there would be a tp. Nothing makes sense or is prevalent in my mind. Think it’s scarlet vs liberation

Heavily leaning toward a town max and town David right now

If they can recruit. It’s kinda busted to have 3 so thinking back at that

it’s prob

2 people + recruiting

I don’t think it’s 1 plus recruit so the game ends if we get a lucky kill dp1

the most likely scum characters are

odessa

flik

victor

tir

there is a world where tir is town. If I’m a betting man I think Odessa is the big bad

leaning toward the latter. Or like odessa+1 and can recruit etc

There is 2 possible splits

a world where tir + 2 is scum

or scum is odessa flik and victor

max claiming literally pins them as scum. “The rebellion thinks I’m part of them or whatever”

the good news is there is only a few people from scarlet moon who can be recruited so there are options are limited.