Madoka Magica - Episode 3

Mmmm ok

A bit weird they were unrecruitable with that role

VTL Wryly

No one vote. Pie is lying one moment while I dig for the proof

No one vote. Pie is lying one moment while I dig for the proof

What’s the point in me lying here. It’s 5-2

If Pie is lying it’s an instant lynch DP3

Dp4*

Never mind. I had it in my mind that wf’s justification was being bedridden so I thought that didn’t go with your justification. I was conflating with what they said earlier

you're immune to NK’s right

I have some thoughts on this. This will be an interesting NP that’s for sure

Kohai - Hitomi Shizuki - Emissary

Vader - Sayaka Miki - 2x Redirector

Mag2cman - Kyoko Sakura - Inspector

Pie - Mami Tomoe - 1x Bulletproof

REF - Junko Kaname - Contract Cop

Whiteflame - Homura Akemi - Ascetic

Wryly - Kyosuke Kamijo - 1x Bulletproof

Mag1cman - Madoka Kaname - Doctor

Kohai - Hitomi Shizuki - Emissary

Vader - Sayaka Miki - 2x Redirector

Mag2cman - Kyoko Sakura - Inspector

Pie - Mami Tomoe - 1x Bulletproof

REF - Junko Kaname - Contract Cop

Whiteflame - Homura Akemi - Ascetic

Wryly - Kyosuke Kamijo - 1x Bulletproof

Mag1cman - Madoka Kaname - Doctor

Ugh. I’m paranoid af but I want to town lock pie.

Given mafia have both recruits and kills a doctor and two bp can be plausible to give town multiple defense.

Vote Count

Wryly (2/4) | ILikePie5, Vader

RexFavilla (1/4) | Wryly

Kohai (1/4) | RexFavilla

Not voting: whiteflame, Kohai, Mag1cman

Ugh. I’m paranoid af but I want to town lock pie. 

Given mafia have both recruits and kills a doctor and two bp can be plausible to give town multiple defense. 

If there are two bulletproofs this game is bastard along with a doctor, that’s unquestionably bastard

Ok I understand the assignment. Yeah let’s get this lynch over with and then we can have some real clarity going into the next DP

Read the day 1 info

1. Scum have been provided with fake-claims and/or information to help them concoct fake-claims. There may be anti-claim mechanics.

Since mafia was given fame claim why would the fake claim be something a town already has

Read the day 1 info 

Scum have been provided with fake-claims and/or information to help them concoct fake-claims. There may be anti-claim mechanics.

Since mafia was given fame claim why would the fake claim be something a town already has 

It says “or” plus it doesn’t saying whether it was character or role or both.

Fuck it, we don’t have time. I am CCing Wryly. I am the 1x Bulletproof. My justification is that I was the only one to survive a car crash and fated to be an orphan

So, yeah, this is a direct CC. Both of your justifications make sense to me on first read. Mami does get orphaned early and that’s pretty much the impetus for her accepting Kyuubey’s contract. Wryly mentioned Kyosuke as Hated (which would’ve made sense), but a wish does save Kyosuke’s life. Difference is that the latter happens as a consequence of Sayaka becoming a magical girl, whereas the former is something that happened before Mami went in with Kyuubey. Both read as real, so if one of you is lying, you did your homework.

The CC from Pie would be extremely ballsy and dangerous, since her flip would out him. I’ve been hard townreading Wryly behaviorally for a while now, so I’m going to need to dig back and hear from her before making a decision, but this doesn’t look good.

Fuck it, we don’t have time. I am CCing Wryly. I am the 1x Bulletproof. My justification is that I was the only one to survive a car crash and fated to be an orphan

VTL Wryly

wtf It's you? Holy shit I would never have the balls to do this lol.

Then why the fuck didn't you speak up when whiteflame said Vader is sus because no one else has an x-shot? You just agreed with him.

What even is this? Did you finally realize you weren't gonna pull off the Vader lynch and would get rolecopped after all, so you're kamikazeing or something??

I don't buy that for one second.

VTL Pie

I've said previously that we win the game with lynches on Rex, Kohai, and Pie. With the Vader lynch (likely mafia's target for the day) going away, and with no traction on anyone else, scum has to make something happen. If one DP is stolen by mislynching Wryly, then we have to make a call between Kohai and Rex in the F3, at which point his teammate (whichever of the two) has a fighting chance.

wtf It's you? Holy shit I would never have the balls to do this lol. 

Nice try lol. This is fake af and you were sussing me

Then why the fuck didn't you speak up when whiteflame said Vader is sus because no one else has an x-shot? You just agreed with him.

I don’t consider BP an active role. It’s a passive role. X-shot implies active role.

What even is this? Did you finally realize you weren't gonna pull off the Vader lynch and would get rolecopped after all, so you're kamikazeing or something??

Lmao that makes no sense. Realistically Kohai was going to be lynched and I’ve been on his ass for the past two dayphases.

I have no reason to CC you because if I’m wrong, I die tomorrow.

I don't buy that for one second.

VTL Pie

I've said previously that we win the game with lynches on Rex, Kohai, and Pie. With the Vader lynch (likely mafia's target for the day) going away, and with no traction on anyone else, scum has to make something happen. If one DP is stolen by mislynching Wryly, then we have to make a call between Kohai and Rex in the F3, at which point his teammate (whichever of the two) has a fighting chance.

Lol what? If Im scum, then why am I hounding Kohai since DP2. Okay let’s say I’m bussing. Then I go ahead and lynch REF lmao.

This is just bad.

It says “or” plus it doesn’t saying whether it was character or role or both.

Here's the problem: We already had a doctor flip. BP + Doctor by itself doesn't make sense. As scum I would never fake claim bp after a dr flip.

Lol what? If Im scum, then why am I hounding Kohai since DP2. Okay let’s say I’m bussing. Then I go ahead and lynch REF lmao.

Ok, then REF is your teammate.

Ok, then REF is your teammate.

Then why do I CC here vs taking the Kohai lynch lmfao

Here's the problem: We already had a doctor flip. BP + Doctor by itself doesn't make sense. As scum I would never fake claim bp after a dr flip.

There is a massive tinfoil possible here, but it seems likely we do have a bulletproof around.

Then why do I CC here vs taking the Kohai lynch lmfao

Lol what? If Im scum, then why am I hounding Kohai since DP2. Okay let’s say I’m bussing. Then I go ahead and lynch REF lmao.

Honestly, both of these are refuted by the fact that POE has basically shrunk to you, Rex and Kohai. Scum's gotta do something here.

Here's the problem: We already had a doctor flip. BP + Doctor by itself doesn't make sense. As scum I would never fake claim bp after a dr flip.

And I as scum CC the BP? What type of logic is that? Especially when I can get the lynch on you with me, Vader, WF, and REF?

Literally what incentive do I have as scum here for this CC?

And I as scum CC the BP? What type of logic is that? Especially when I can get the lynch on you with me, Vader, WF, and REF?

Literally what incentive do I have as scum here for this CC?

Which is why I'm tinfoiling both of you being town and town just having two bps. I'm working on a long post so please let's slow down for a few moments and think things through

Which is why I'm tinfoiling both of you being town and town just having two bps. I'm working on a long post so please let's slow down for a few moments and think things through

???