Madoka Magica - Episode 3

Remember how I was saying I would like to be rolecopped? Because of the fact that Doctor and BP aren’t believable?

Remember how I told WF I would prefer to wait till DP4 to full claim? It was to bait the NK.

Oh right, I should vote.

VTL Pie

hm. Noted.

that could just be part of the setup tho

as in the setup for this specific play

Unofficial Vote Count

Wryly (2/4) | ILikePie5, Vader

Pie (2/4) | Magic2man, wryly

RexFavilla (1/4) | Wryly

Kohai (1/4) | RexFavilla

Not voting: whiteflame, Kohai

Remember how I was saying I would like to be rolecopped? Because of the fact that Doctor and BP aren’t believable?

Remember how I told WF I would prefer to wait till DP4 to full claim? It was to bait the NK.

Exactly why I think you are town and it's possible for town to have two bps.

Again I'm asking everyone to please slow down for a moment

Which is why I'm tinfoiling both of you being town and town just having two bps. I'm working on a long post so please let's slow down for a few moments and think things through

Holy fuck dude. There is absolutely no way there are 2 bulletproofs and a doctor

I don’t consider BP an active role. It’s a passive role. X-shot implies active role.

It does?? I thought x-shot implies, like, x-shot.

Lmao that makes no sense. Realistically Kohai was going to be lynched and I’ve been on his ass for the past two dayphases.

I got suspicious after you suddenly started going after Vader when you'd been on Kohai consistently, and wondered if maybe he's the target scum needs to lynch. If we lynch Kohai and he's not the scum target, then town gets a rolecop, and you could get outed tomorrow.

It does?? I thought x-shot implies, like, x-shot.

No, it doesn't. This is a quick on the spot excuse.

Active or passive doesn't matter, 1x is still 1x.

Let's slow down a bit here

Kohai - Hitomi Shizuki - Emissary

No justification for role

Vader - Sayaka Miki - 2x Redirector

My character is Sayaka. My character has a really good sense of movement and flow because they appreciate classical music and are also energetic and open to change.

Mag2cman - Kyoko Sakura - Inspector

Her father kills his family and himself, except for her. She’s made an orphan and forced to develop street smarts, making her more observant of the world around her. Hence inspector.

Pie - Mami Tomoe - 1x Bulletproof

Fuck it, we don’t have time. I am CCing Wryly. I am the 1x Bulletproof. My justification is that I was the only one to survive a car crash and fated to be an orphan

REF - Junko Kaname - Contract Cop

I'm the contract cop. I can target a player and learn whether they accepted a witch contract. NP1 I targeted Kohai and had him on my scum list the second he didn't come straight out and say that he accepted, didn't put himself down on his own list as having accepted it, then scumread me after saying that I accepted it. Last night I targeted Magic and learned that he declined, but that's kind of useless information now. The theory I've been going off of is that the person who lied about accepting the contract is probably the one who actually became scum. This is part of why I am so locked in on Kohai as the convert. I targeted Magic because I genuinely did not think that Pie would choose to be scum in this game but I don't know Magic as well. If Pie is scum I'm 99% certain he is OG scum, not the convert.Whiteflame - Homura Akemi - Ascetic

Wryly - Kyosuke Kamijo - 1x Bulletproof

I have a 1x Bulletproof because my character was saved from a cruel fate by a magic girl's wish.

Whiteflame - Homura Akemi - Ascetic

Anyway, I said I'd claim if anyone else pushed for it, and I will: I'm Homura Akemi and I'm Ascetic. The justification is that I was isolated from others due to being bedridden for half a year and that I don't trust others.

I got suspicious after you suddenly started going after Vader when you'd been on Kohai consistently, and wondered if maybe he's the target scum needs to lynch. If we lynch Kohai and he's not the scum target, then town gets a rolecop, and you could get outed tomorrow.

Literally I’m inviting a rolecop on me because even I know a BP with a Doctor doesn’t make sense. And why would I put my vote on Kohai as well lol. I’ve been on his ass since DP2. The optimal strategy is to always lynch who you think is OG scum, not recruited scum. Vader and WF are those and I have explained why multiple times. But you’re confirmed scum lol.

No, it doesn't. This is a quick on the spot excuse.

Active or passive doesn't matter, 1x is still 1x.

Tomato-Tomahto. I’ve been softclaiming BP since early today lol.

If Pie's claim is true, we'd have two slots (Mami- Bulletproof, Kyoko- Inspector) whose justification relies on being an orphan. Not completely out of the question, but unlikely.

I just looked back at my rolecard it gives three additional names: I'm a classmate of Madoka and Sayaka and I develope a romance with Syosuke. This leads me to think they're probably originally town.

Question: Does anyone else's role PM list other characters?

Tomato-Tomahto. I’ve been softclaiming BP since early today lol.

Meaningless if you were going for this play to begin with, given the Rex-Kohai-Pie PoE.

The fact that you wouldn't even question the similarity is alarming.

Oh, and for all your softing, you never CC'd Wryly right away. You questioned it, and didn't CC until a few posts later. You were likely putting down a placeholder while you were searching for a justification to CC with.

If Pie's claim is true, we'd have two slots (Mami- Bulletproof, Kyoko- Inspector) whose justification relies on being an orphan. Not completely out of the question, but unlikely.

Oh no no. That’s part of it. The main part is that I was the only one to survive a car crash

 just looked back at my rolecard it gives three additional names: I'm a classmate of Madoka and Sayaka and I develope a romance with Syosuke. This leads me to think they're probably originally town.

Question: Does anyone else's role PM list other characters?

Mag1cman and Mag2cman do not have others. I'm pretty sure the reason for your PM is that way is because your character is a side character, who is only relevant because of her relationships with other characters.

Meaningless if you were going for this play to begin with, given the Rex-Kohai-Pie PoE.

A) Lol that’s a POE from your POV, not everyone else’s

B) I lynch either of those 2 unless I’m bussing them cause one of them is guaranteed town vs killing myself as scum lol

The fact that you wouldn't even question the similarity is alarming.

Oh, and for all your softing, you never CC'd Wryly right away. You questioned it, and didn't CC until a few posts later. You were likely putting down a placeholder while you were searching for a justification to CC with.

Lmaoo, I wanted to confirm that’s what she was claiming and then when she said she was leaving I CCed. Again. Why CC when I could’ve gotten a free town lynch in Kohai or REF.

Mag1cman and Mag2cman do not have others. I'm pretty sure the reason for your PM is that way is because your character is a side character, who is only relevant because of her relationships with other characters.

This is fair. Wryly's character being unrecruitable does make sense from a flavor POV. This is why I'm so torn

I'm currently tin foiling two things:

(1) Wryly and pie are both town and town has a doctor + 2 1x bp town

(2) One of them is scum

(3) pie is scum and Wryly is the target that scum needs to lynch

IMO I'm leaning towards option 1. I need to do some digging.

Kohai why are you entertaining the idea that there are two BP's in one game dude??

This is simple: the only 2 people that were realistically going to be lynched were Kohai and REF.

If you think I’m scum and Kohai is my partner, you’d have to assume I was bussing him since DP2, which is fine. In this case if I was going to bus him, what’s the point in me CCing here and potentially dying. Better yet, I could just lynch REF.

If you think REF is my partner, then again, why do I CC here when Kohai is a feasible lynch for us.

I'm currently tin foiling two things:

(1) Wryly and pie are both town and town has a doctor + 2 1x bp town

(2) One of them is scum

(3) pie is scum and Wryly is the target that scum needs to lynch 

IMO I'm leaning towards option 1. I need to do some digging.

Omg you’re retarded lmao. Literally both sides are telling you you’re stupid for even considering this is possible and you still go with it.

You know that you’re town. If I was scum, I could’ve secured a lynch on you with WF, Vader, and REF. Why tf would I CC here and risk getting lynched.

YOU KNOW YOURE FUCKING TOWN

Kohai why are you entertaining the idea that there are two BP's in one game dude??

(1) Mafia is overpowered already with night kills and recruits. Having multiple protection roles is necessary for town. We already have at least 1 doctor + 1 1x bulletproof. I can see a second 1x bulletproof as well.

(2) I have a very strong town read on you and don't see you fake claiming BP

(3) I think pie's cc is also very townie so I'm now going paranoid

Oh no no. That’s part of it. The main part is that I was the only one to survive a car crash

And Kyoko was the only survivor of her father's madness. Both were orphaned as the only survivors. This is a pedantic nitpick. I think it's more likely that Mami's real justification has to do with her life after the tragedy, before she became a magical girl.

A) Lol that’s a POE from your POV, not everyone else’s

You tried to get a lynch on Vader. It failed. You tried to put pressure on Whiteflame. That went nowhere. Wryly and I have been effectively off the table.

It's common sense that's the PoE.

B) I lynch either of those 2 unless I’m bussing them cause one of them is guaranteed town vs killing myself as scum lol

You and your teammate are still under fire after getting that mislynch. You mislynch Kohai, you and Rex are the only ones left under fire. You mislynch Rex, you and Kohai are the only ones left under fire.

Lmaoo, I wanted to confirm that’s what she was claiming and then when she said she was leaving I CCed. Again. Why CC when I could’ve gotten a free town lynch in Kohai or REF.

She claimed 1x nulletproof, verbatim. You don't need to spend time confirming because she said it explicitly.

Vote Count

ILikePie5 (2/4) Mag1cman, Wryly

Wryly (2/4) | ILikePie5, Vader

Kohai (1/4) | RexFavilla

Not voting: whiteflame, Kohai

(1) Mafia is overpowered already with night kills and recruits. Having multiple protection roles is necessary for town. We already have at least 1 doctor + 1 1x bulletproof. I can see a second 1x bulletproof as well.

(2) I have a very strong town read on you and don't see you fake claiming BP

(3) I think pie's cc is also very townie so I'm now going paranoid

I am at a loss for words

Either of you on? Lynch is between pie and castin and I'm completely lost and tinfoiling like crazy

I understand going for Wryly here, but I feel pretty confident Pie is kamikazeing here.