Solo Leveling Mafia - DP1

You know what? As much as I just want Shining BTFO'd for easy self-pres and to inactivate an inactive, whiteflame's hardon for pushing my claim as though it's on par with Leprechaun from Suikoden shows mala fide. This is not OMGUS.

Gonna repeat the points made in #1363 and #1381

Vote Count

Thoth (7/9) - Mestari, Lunatic, Alyssa, Rex, Wylted. Kohai, Pie (L-2)

Shining (3/9) - Wryly, Casey_Risk, Helz (L-6)

Whiteflame (1/9) - Thoth (L-8)

Some of the posts that pinged me

#111 - not a fan of his reason for joining the Mestari wagon

#116

wtf am I looking at

Ur mom

Check out this post from day phase 2 of Suikoden. This is what you are doing. And before you say that I was scum in that game, Mikal was still railing against a townie.

Ur* mom

Anyone remember the Russian Mafia when That2 suggested lynching Luna after he came out and claimed Dreamer results, the idea being that either he'd be scum or they'd know the results were accurate? I say we follow that plan for real here. If Thoth is scum, great. If not, we know his list and know SJW must be on there.

I am unrecruitable. Justification is that I'm not a Hunter.

I'm the Nurse / backup Doctor (would suck if Airmax is the Doctor and he's not around to at least say this is a point in my defense). Justification is that I want to go to medical school.

I started with a list of three people and was told that one of them is Jinwoo: Helz, Alyssa, and Rex. Justification is that I'm close to Jinwoo. That's why I thought Alyssa being Jinwoo would explain a lot, because I figured that Jinwoo might have information that pointed to me being innocent.

That's everything.

So an unrecruitable informed nurse, looking for Jinwoo. It's so unbelievable that Thoth using it as a fake claim feels unbelievable.

Lemme think guys.

Gonna repeat the points made in #1363 and #1381

Could it possibly be that I am defensive because town is testing if my claim is made of wood by seeing if it weighs the same as a duck?

Some of the posts that pinged me

#111 - not a fan of his reason for joining the Mestari wagon

#116

Just seems like genuine annoyance to me. You take the time to put together an articulate argument, it's just kind of shitty for your interlocutor to say tl;dr. Especially in mafia.

If not, we know his list and know SJW must be on there.

And other water-cooler chatter in the FBI branch office while hunting for the Charlie Kirk shooter

Again as I said these were extremely early pings and didn’t like the main wagons.

I'm not hearing a counter-argument.

The only thing making me hesitate to put you at L-1 is the fact that I do still want to hear from Shining.

Again as I said these were extremely early pings and didn’t like the main wagons.

Understood.

Yes let's not put him at L-1 and let Shining and Airmax off the hook. I don't even like him at L-2. What if some nefarious quickhammer lynches him and plays it off as an accident.

Yes let's not put him at L-1 and let Shining and Airmax off the hook. I don't even like him at L-2. What if some nefarious quickhammer lynches him and plays it off as an accident.

I wonder who would possibly do such a thing…

You know what? As much as I just want Shining BTFO'd for easy self-pres and to inactivate an inactive, whiteflame's hardon for pushing my claim as though it's on par with Leprechaun from Suikoden shows mala fide. This is not OMGUS.

Literally an OMGUS as you VTL'd me right after this, but call it whatever you want.

Yeah, I held off on it because I wasn't sure that I was going to be lynched (I'm still not) and, thinking Jinwoo was town's Big Good, I would have considered taking my list to the grave anyway.

So you never questioned why you would have received a list of players who could be Jin-woo if he "was town's Big Good"? You'd think you would have considered alternative explanations for why you received that information.

Alyssa for her absurd defense of me, which was possibly because she has an ability that told me who I am, which would make even more sense if she's a 3P and needed to get rid of me than it would if she were town and her information made us like paired Emissaries. Why would she defend me? Because she wanted to look extra good and buddy-buddy knowing she was in my PoE after she flipped 3P. That's a possibility, anyway. I don't know whether or not she has information about my role or what information she has if so. Helz seems behaviorally town but could be 3P. I'm confident he's not scum. There's too little information from Rex for me to say how much I sus him.

Alright, so you have no idea which of them could be Jin-woo. Even if you're right that one or more of them is scum or a TP, their flip does not necessarily confirm you, so at best, you're fishing since you don't have any clue which of them it is.

No, of course not. Hence why I never hard-claimed my role as confirmable. But it very much could have ended up confirming me if I claimed my PoE and then one of them flipped Jinwoo. I'm a lot of things, but I'm not an Oracle.

Doesn't seem like a workable strategy when you're already the center of attention and asking for some rather specific eliminations under the pretense that one of them could be Jin-woo. Especially odd since the one who you scumread most is chiefly being sussed over statements you've made.

Jinwoo is an S-rank Hunter, why wouldn't he have an ability that kills all the Mafia and makes Town win instantly? You're not letting anything past the checkpoint of, "it's not the role I would come up with for this character".

Again, not responsive to my point, but I've repeated it twice already and I'm not expecting a response.

Check out this post from day phase 2 of Suikoden. This is what you are doing. And before you say that I was scum in that game, Mikal was still railing against a townie.

Unlike Mikal, I'm not calling out a single role that seems off from what I would expect. I'm pointing to multiple points that don't make sense with your character thematically or logically, several of which you still haven't addressed. I just don't see a world in which Mikal included this character and attached these roles to her.

I feel like we're stressing you out with all this heat and I'd just like to say -- for the record -- that "I'm Banana's Shift key. I'm a perma-Commuter" was peak comedy.

 It's so unbelievable that Thoth using it as a fake claim feels unbelievable.

You know what? Screw this. This is Thoth's whole style. I'm not overthinking this. He probably just made this as complex as possible to try and survive by confusing us.

I'm just gonna vote Thoth at the end of this. I don't even see the point in continuing after Shining's claim at this point. I see the people not wanting Thoth at L-1 and I'll wait just to see Airmax this DP.

I'm not hearing a counter-argument.

I've countered every argument that everyone has thrown at me, and nobody is listening to reason. Unless you can come up with a fresh point against me, I've got nothing to do but tell jokes and die. Alas, poor Thoth! I knew him, Casey: a fellow of infinite jest, of most excellent Mafia playing: he hath borne town on his back a thousand times; and now, how abhorred in their process of elimination it is!

I’m fine with Shining giving thoughts, but I don’t think he should claim. We’ve had enough for today imo. First thing tomorrow though is a good idea tho.

As for Max, don’t really know if he’s gonna be on, nor who the replacement would be.

I'm just gonna vote Thoth at the end of this. I don't even see the point in continuing after Shining's claim at this point. I see the people not wanting Thoth at L-1 and I'll wait just to see Airmax this DP.

Yeah, I'm in the same boat. I think it's a given that Thoth is the lynch this DP and I'm good with being one of the final votes, but I'm good waiting for whatever we can get from Airmax and Shining with the remaining time. Not expecting anything from the former, but you never know.

I literally just provided a new argument in #1418 that you pointedly ignored after I said you weren't countering it.

I’m gonna hit the sack and sign off. Gn and gl. I think this DP dragged on enough and OK with ending the DP

sleep sounds awesome rn

1400+ posts by the way. We're well beyond the largest mafia thread in DART history. Crazy activity this game and we've had a few inactives/low-actives

Holy shit, it is actually later than I realized. This game has been engaging

we'd probably be at 2000 by now if everyone were as active as me

me and a few others